A drink and drug fuelled attacker who killed an innocent man in an assault at a pub has had his prison sentence slashed by a third by top judges in London.
Geoffrey Prestley Humphreys, 39, of Victoria Street, Hyde, was jailed for six years at Manchester Crown Court last March after he was found guilty of manslaughter.
At the Court of Appeal, he failed in a challenge to his conviction, but succeeded in winning a two-year cut in his jail term.
Sir Anthony May, sitting with Mr Justice Foskett and Mrs Justice Nicola Davies, said the six-year sentence was ‘excessive’ in the circumstances.
Humphreys had been drinking all day and had taken some cocaine when an altercation broke out at Stalybridge’s Grosvenor pub in January 2008.
He was asked by staff to help clear the pub and remained inside while the fight spilled into the street outside and the premises were emptied.
A group of people then tried to get back inside and Humphreys punched one man, David Grainger, twice in the face, causing him to lose consciousness.
Mr Grainger, from Ashton and who had not been involved in any of the drunken violence that night, choked on his blood and died.
After punching Mr Grainger, Humphreys then hit one of the man’s friends, Simon Harris, resulting in a charge of assault occasioning actual bodily harm, which he admitted.
This week lawyers for Humphreys argued that he should never have been convicted, since there was not sufficient evidence to justify a guilty verdict.
Identification evidence had been ‘intrinsically unreliable’, with all witnesses intoxicated, except one woman who gave a description which pointed to another man as the more likely attacker.
Rejecting the argument, Sir Anthony said there was a ‘plain and sufficient’ case to go before the jury and the trial judge was right to allow them to make up their minds about Humphreys’ guilt.
But, since the offence was not the most serious of so-called ‘one-punch manslaughter’ cases, the six-year term was too long and would be cut to four years.
The decision means that Humphreys will serve only two years in jail for killing Mr Grainger, before being released into the community on licence.
Tweet

Showing comments 1 to 19 and replies | View All
rebecca meredith (11/03/2010 at 11:36)
"But, since the offence was not the most serious of so-called ‘one-punch manslaughter’ cases, the six-year term was too long and would be cut to four years."
How can you state that his sentence was too long, he killed one of the kindest people anyone could possibly wish to meet and you say 6 years in prison and then halved was too much time to serve!
Is it any wonder that this country is full of booze guzzling fighting idiots who have no concern for anybody else, you are basically stating that It's OK to commit offences like these...It isn't serious is it...try telling all of Dave's loved ones that!
This country makes me sick, no amount of time in jail will ever bring Dave back but some form of justice for the loss of a great person is not much to ask!
What is it going to take to put this man behind bars forever, this isn't his first offence, are you going to wait till he does something you "deem" as being sufficient to keep him locked up! It's a darn right disgrace!
RIP Dave xx
Joan Swift (11/03/2010 at 12:43)
Not sufficient evidence? There was CCTV footage clearly showing Humphreys hitting ALL people involved. CCTV cannot be intoxicated and classed as an unreliable witness.
We clearly have no Justice System in this country.
Joan Swift (11/03/2010 at 12:43)
Is it any wonder that our society is turning to s*!t when scumbags like this are not given what they truly deserve? It used to be that people were afraid of the law - it was something to abide by because the consequences of getting caught doing something bad would mean something bad happening to you - permanently. Now it seems not to matter that if you should kill someone, you'll get your life back after a few year's 'good behaviour'?
This man will be free to live his life in a few short months, with no remorse for what he has done. His victim's friends and family get to live their life without their loved one and suffer that pain on a daily basis.
Where is justice in this? Because I, amongst the many others, fail to see how justice has been served.
SANJRA HUGHES (11/03/2010 at 14:35)
You are giving "drunken drug fuelled brawlers" the ticket they want.
Justice has NOT been done.
"JUSTICE FOR DAVE GRAINGER"
R.I.P.
The Hatchet Man, Cuckoo land (11/03/2010 at 15:53)
But how many people can say that they have not had a punch up with someone in there entire life with someone and escaped with nothing but an hang over.
Obviously I can only go off what has been written here and not what people sumerize has happened.
It clearly states that he punched him twice, If this guy has previous well thats a different matter and turns events against him.
But what I refuse to do is join a pathetic facebook witch hunt like some brainless sheep.
RIP young man I am sure you will be missed by many
Lisa Warrender (11/03/2010 at 16:43)
And I think there are many, many people who can say that they have never had a drunken punch up, this includes myself, and in fact Dave. He was a peace loving man.
''Sir Anthony May, sitting with Mr Justice Foskett and Mrs Justice Nicola Davies, said the six-year sentence was ‘excessive’ in the circumstances''.
An innocent man's life was taken away by an indiscriminate thug, how can any sentence be viewed as excessive? His parents, friends, all the many, many people who loved Dave received a life sentence the day he died.
''But, since the offence was not the most serious of so-called ‘one-punch manslaughter’ cases, the six-year term was too long and would be cut to four years''.
The taking of a life is universally wrong, how can you have a 'less serious' manslaughter?
Lisa Warrender
11/03/2010
rebecca meredith (11/03/2010 at 16:50)
These people are allowed to continually re offend with no thought or care for anyone else!
The Facebook Group is no "Witchhunt" it is simply showcasing how people feel about the so called justice system in this country whether that be in Dave's case or all the other offenders that have committed crimes and simply gotten away with them!
K_C, Hyde (11/03/2010 at 17:20)
What difference does it make if Humphreys has previous? I fail to see the relevance of your comment? Dave had never been involved in a punch up in his life so he most certainly didn't deserve to lose his life, and his parents lose their only child!
The fact that six years is deemed "excessive" is laughable. I doubt the judges would see it that way had it been their child who lost their life.
There are too many cases like this at the moment, with the justice system repeatedly letting the british public down. How can they expect our support if the punishment never ever fits the crime?!?!
Nicola Deacon (11/03/2010 at 20:35)
If making a group makes people feel better and it's somewhere to write our feelings down, who are you to look down on it as a "pathetic facebook witch hunt like some brainless sheep".
The Hatchet Man, Cuckoo land (11/03/2010 at 21:07)
Listen this is the story of my life, I got into a fight approximately 20 odd years ago as a 17 year old snotty nosed fool, I had no previous convictions what so ever, not even a speeding ticket, unfortunately and with something that I have to live with for the rest of my life, the young guy died, not at the scene, but some near 12 months later. It was a drunken punch up on a Friday night that went tragically wrong.
I was sentenced to 3 years prison for GBH and then later was charged with Murder following the death of my victim some 6 months later. This was only dropped at the last minute due to the victims(I use the word victim as I don't want anyone to know this gentlemans name, I don't use the word without thought or respect) parents standing up and requesting no further charges pressed against me. The courts viewed this and was reduced to manslaughter.
I owe more than you can imagine not only to this gentlemans parents for there thoughtfulness, but also to the prison service for recognising that I wasn't the usual riff raff that comes through their gates but a fool who had been in the wrong place at the wrong time.
When I was serving my sentence I saw scrote after scrote come and go, some I saw 8 times in and out whilst I was doing my sentence.
It isnt the system that fails these lowlifes It's their families, when you know no better you act like a neanderthal. The reason I say their families is because these people would rather be in prison, they don't have the stability and loving that a family should give.
I saw it everyday, being in prison wasn't a punishment to me, it was not being able to be with my family when I wanted. These people didn't have families so they missed nothing at all. So prison is their life they are second, third, fourth and even fifth generation criminals.
People clearly don't have the respect anymore, this was summed up recently in a documentary that I saw on TV, Ian Wright the ex Arsenal footballer, was trying to rehabilitate young offenders, by using football to motivate them. Anyway to cut a long story short, one of the offenders had been refused an outside pass to play football and abused the gym prison officer so much that the prison officer had to leave the room, well this would not have happened when I was incarcerated, everyone had respect for the officers, you spoke to one out of turn and you would have been punished.
I hear your cries for this mans blood and understand your anger but I still don't see anywhere were it states any previous and believe me I have searched, I'm not saying your wrong, however surely to get the public behind you the press alone would have highlighted his previous.
I may have a different view of things now, but in my opinion I see very clearly and openly, that doesn't say that I don't want peodophiles and rapists to recieve the maximum sentence possible. I understand peoples views I just view things differently now.
I am so remorseful for what I have done and caused and will live with this for the rest of my life, fortunately I am able to, there isnt a day goes by that I don't think about what happened back then and the hurt and pain that I caused his lovely family, I will never forget what they did and what I did.
I dont ask for sympathy nor want it, I just ask that you understand that there are different views and on rare occasions people are in the wrong place at the wrong time, and for the record I have never been anywhere near trouble ever since of any kind
Again my thoughts are with David Grainger's family and friends, RIP David.
B V Flute, Newton Moor (11/03/2010 at 22:20)
And what will the powers that be have to say when he commits his next atrocity ...because there's nothing more certain he will do "lessons to be learned"? Maybe.
The reduction of this scumbags sentance is a downright disgrace to the memory of David Grainger.
The Hatchet Man, Cuckoo land (12/03/2010 at 10:34)
We can all carry on the witch hunt via facebook and don't tell me it isn't it clearly is, this campaign unfortunately will be as effective as Utd's green and gold campaign.
I know that anger runs deep and rightly so, i'm sure that David is looking on saying "go for it guys love you all"
I see some people calling for capital punishment and totally disagree with this, basically I could so easily have been killed for doing what I did, but I will give you an scenario that you could so easily be in.
For the Males: Lets say that one day you are out in town with your mates and a girl comes on to you, you go back to her place and stay the night. two days later you get a knock on the door and you are now charged with Rape(don't tell me it doesn't happen because it does). That is a capital offence and it is basically your word against hers. you have a 50/50 chance of living, basically a mistake or mis carriage in justice would see your existance terminated.
For the females: same senario out in town and a guy pinches your backside, you slap him and he falls over banging his head and dies, you are charged with manslaughter and you end up again being terminated.
Believe me there are things that need to be changed tv's, playstations etc. in cells, curtains, any luxuries, but also seriously increased sentences for repeat offenders, even to the extent of life imprisonment just like the american scheme, but instead of 3 strikes make it 2.
I just can't jump on the sheep like mentality that is facebook, I have my own thoughts.
I must address one thing that was aimed at me, what would i do if it was someone I knew, with my hand on my heart if something or someone did something to any of my loved ones we wouldn't need the police and I would accordingly after face the consequences. So for Davids immediate family to have these thoughts in my opinion is correct and normal.
This facebook thing though steps over the mark and people that never even knew David are jumping on the band wagon because a friend asks them to join the campaign, that is wrong.
My heart will always be with the victim and their family always.
The Allseeing Crystalchild (12/03/2010 at 11:26)
"...A group of people then tried to get back inside and Humphreys punched one man, David Grainger, twice in the face...."
"...After punching Mr Grainger, Humphreys then hit one of the man’s friends..."
Seems to me Humphreys was nothing other than a drunken, cocaine-fuelled thug so being handed the opportunity to get into a bit of a fight that night probably just rounded things off nicely for him. How dare some so-called "top judges in London" (who, lets face it, are nicely far enough away from all the alcohol-fuelled crime we witness here in Tameside) decide that his ensuing sentence was too long! I don't suppose they bothered to consider the feelings of Mr. Grainger's family & friends on the matter, being as they're only the real victims here?
The sensibility of the management of the Grosvenor at the time should also come in for some criticism -
"...He was asked by staff to help clear the pub and remained inside while the fight spilled into the street...."
Why? Was he the resident 'heavy'/unofficial 'bouncer'? And how on earth could they think someone so obviously drink-fuelled as he had been 'drinking all day' - never mind under the influence of drugs too - would be fit to act as some kind of peacekeeper or doorman?
No doubt there'll be yet more "lessons to be learned" that never actually are when he comes out and history repeats itself as it so often does in these cases.
kel power (12/03/2010 at 12:14)
BRD, Ashton (12/03/2010 at 16:51)
big stockportlad (13/03/2010 at 08:58)
heroine addicts get extra money from the social to buy crack and they still rob ppl for a fix >>> why
Alcohololics get extra money as well
our law and our government havent got a clue about anything (GET A GRIP)
DrPepper (16/03/2010 at 15:56)
on me 'ed, dukinfield (17/03/2010 at 08:42)
Pauly.K, Levenshulme (09/04/2010 at 23:44)
I have no Criminal record , I work hard and dont do sickies, I pay my taxes and have brought up hard working law abiding children - alcohol and males and punch ups have always occurred and always will occur - its in our DNA.
I'm all for executing the evil scum who pollute our society ( eg: the Gary Newlove murder ) however Manslaughter and Murder are totally different and rightly should have different sentences - we can all commit manslaughter , how many of you have done 40 mph in a 30 mph zone or been on a mobile phone whilst driving etc etc - given the right circumstances you may have hit and killed a pedestrian - should you be executed for that or would you want your sons / brothers / fathers executed for that ?
Punishment yes but execution no.
Manslaughter is not Murder.