A PAIR of drunken thugs who attacked a BBC reporter while he was trying to do his job have avoided going to jail.
North West Tonight journalist Paresh Patel was setting up a live broadcast in Sackville Gardens, central Manchester, when a group of drunken yobs began harassing him and his cameraman.
Two of the thugs followed Mr Patel through the city streets as he left the area, repeatedly shoving and goading him. But the yobs didn't realise Mr Patel was a black belt in karate and he finally lashed out at his attackers, knocking one of them to the ground.
CCTV footage shows how Mr Patel was forced to defend himself after a barrage of abuse and harassment.
John Nugent, 22, of Balmer Street, Beswick, and David Neville McKenna, 27, of Bardell Crescent, Poynton, punched, shoved and goaded Paresh Patel through the streets of the city centre for half an hour.
At Manchester Crown Court, the pair, who admitted charges of affray and common assault at an earlier hearing, were condemned as 'drunken louts' by Judge David Hernandez. But he chose not to jail them on the spot and handed them community orders, warning them they would go to prison if they breached them.
Speaking of the victim, he said: "He defended himself, he delivered a blow. I say good for Mr Patel. He had no reason to be subjected to that level of abuse and threat by you."
The court heard that, on the evening of September 11, Paresh and his cameraman, Steve Capstick, were trying to film a North West Tonight report about gay computer pioneer Alan Turing, who had been given a posthumous apology by Gordon Brown.
The journalists were setting up at Sackville Gardens, near where six men and women were loitering and boozing, when two of the group began jumping on the statue of Turing while trying to get themselves on TV.
When Mr Patel rang the newsroom to explain the problem, the yobs thought he was ringing the police and turned on him. Jodie Anderson, 26, who was handed a six-week suspended sentence and 12-month supervision order at an earlier hearing after pleading guilty to common assault, first chucked a pint over Mr Patel.
Then, when he tried to walk away, Nugent and McKenna started on him. As the journalist headed for Oxford Road, the louts pursued them, before Nugent punched Mr Patel in the face and split his lip.
As the intimidated BBC workers neared Princess Street, the men began swinging advertising boards at them. But, when Nugent lunged to hit Mr Patel again, the martial arts champ punched him in the face and kicked him in the groin, knocking him to the ground.
In a victim impact statement read to the court, Mr Patel said: "I am shocked and upset by what has happened. I was trying to go about my business in a peaceful way."
McKenna claimed he lashed out at Mr Patel because he called his friend 'tramps' and a 'slag' while boasting of being a Thai boxer. He was given an 18-month community and supervision order, an alcohol education programme and 140 hours' unpaid work for common assault, affray and vandalism.
Nugent had been boozing since 10am that morning after a funeral and said he couldn't remember the incident.
He was on a conditional discharge for theft at the time. He was given an intensive alternative-to-custody order for 18 months plus supervision, ordered to attend an anger-management programme and given unpaid work for 80 hours.




Showing comments 1 to 25 and replies | View All
A Saracen (23/10/2009 at 09:59)
P&L Account, Prestbury, Macclesfield (23/10/2009 at 10:08)
uncle bulgaria, Wimbledon Common (23/10/2009 at 10:13)
What is going on here, why is the judge so lenient??
This kind of 'judgement' sends out the message that it is acceptable to harass the public because if you get caught you'll get some free treatment and some work experience. (Which will look good on the otherwise blank cv's of these trash, because the likelihood of them having done any legitimate work is slim)
want to leave, Stretford (23/10/2009 at 10:15)
tiggerluc, somewhere in shaw (23/10/2009 at 10:29)
Guten Tag, Manchester (23/10/2009 at 10:34)
Guten Tag, Manchester (23/10/2009 at 10:40)
hjk (23/10/2009 at 10:43)
daniel james (23/10/2009 at 10:44)
JohnB, Manchester (23/10/2009 at 11:01)
AngusDangus, Salford (23/10/2009 at 11:07)
Well done Sir.
Seemingly Ignored, Heald Green (23/10/2009 at 11:12)
Manchester - what an embarrassing place to live these days.
The Truth (23/10/2009 at 11:17)
BDZ, UK (23/10/2009 at 11:23)
Inner city Manchester is crawling with idiots like this pair but they rarely make it as far as the city centre in daylight hours!
Mark, South Manchester (23/10/2009 at 11:29)
What utterly shameful & embarrassing images.
Mike, Manchester (23/10/2009 at 11:30)
Black Flag (23/10/2009 at 11:33)
Judges operate according to sentencing guidelines which exist to ensure that people convicted of similar crimes get similar sentences. Trying to place the blame on the judge because you don't like the sentencing guidelines is stupid and ill-informed.
tiggerluc, somewhere in shaw (23/10/2009 at 11:45)
Seemingly Ignored, Heald Green (23/10/2009 at 11:46)
tiggerluc, somewhere in shaw (23/10/2009 at 11:49)
coolhead, Copenhagen (23/10/2009 at 11:56)
I'm booking my karate lessons this week.
Geoff J (23/10/2009 at 12:02)
He can obviously handle himself, he should have took him out the first time he started bothering him.
Well done Mr Patel, he had it coming to him.
Nice to see so many people helping him out...
bren 2, bolton (23/10/2009 at 12:02)
james cromley, stockport (23/10/2009 at 12:10)
Mad Welsh Scotsman, Cadishead (23/10/2009 at 12:15)
Who did that lad think he was with his arms stretched out, I noticed as soon as the reported started retaliating, they both backed off, cowards! Two on one and they were the ones who backed away.