A UNIQUE piece of Withington's architectural and cultural history could be saved from demolition.
Cine City appeared doomed when Town Hall chiefs gave owner Mohammad Jamil permission to demolish the old building, much to the consternation of residents who feared yet another block of flats would take its place.
But now a glimmer of hope has appeared on the horizon after Mr Jamil agreed to put the demolition plans on hold to give people the chance to refurbish one of the first cinemas in Britain.
It was built as The Scala in 1912. On Wednesday, June 1, a meeting took place between Mr Jamil, owner of Arrows International Limited property developers, Roger Smith, chairman of Withington Civic Society, and representatives from the film industry, including the Commonwealth Film Festival (CFF), North West Films and Kino Films.
Mr Jamil said: "I love this building. It's beautiful. We are trying to save it in some way. I have got a kind of love affair with Withington village.
"We want to work with local people to achieve a happy medium, which is workable for everybody. We don't want to work against the grain, that's why we have involved the civic society."
Although the cinema, which was closed in July 2001, is in a sorry state of repair, it retains an air of faded grandeur, with many original features still intact like gold brocade seats, wall freezes, cornices and ceiling roses.
It would take many thousands of pounds to restore it to its former glory.
But following a tour of the site the feeling among delegates was that it should be preserved as either a cinema or music, theatre or general arts venue. Mr Jamil said he would be willing to lease or sell the building, or find space for arts in the new development.
Maria Ruban, of CFF, said: "It's depressing and upsetting really. I hadn't realised it had deteriorated so badly in such a short time. I'm intrigued as to why it has been left in this state. It shows how quickly things can fall apart if they are not maintained and loved."
Maria added that a campaign should be mounted to save the cinema, such as the one in London to preserve the Old Vic Theatre and Hackney Empire. She said costs could be kept to a minimum with community volunteers doing some of the work. Maria said: "It's such a good space and a charming building. I'd like to see it saved and used in some way. We can't let a beautiful design be ruined in this way. It has such status in Withington, it's a part of the culture.
"It would be terrible for it to be taken down and replaced with something you can get anywhere else in the city. It's important it stays as a cultural venue in Withington."
John Wojowski, of Kino Films, said: "If we had the money to buy it we would. It's in a worse state than I thought it would be.
"It needs a lot of money to completely strip it out. It needs a rich benefactor."
Withington Civic Society has already fought off plans to turn Cine City into a JD Wetherspoons pub but, if it cannot be saved this time, it will be bulldozed to make way for a five-storey building with covering 4,000 square feet on each floor.
The basement will contain an underground car park, retail space at ground level, and four floors will be turned over to residential apartments with a boiler room on the top floor.
- Write to the South Manchester Reporter and let us know about your views on the future of the Cine City site.

Showing comments 1 to 9 and replies | View All
Victoria Turrell, Lancaster (05/06/2005 at 14:19)
Robert Burgess, Withington (07/06/2005 at 10:46)
amanda sutton, Copson street (07/06/2005 at 11:35)
Amanda Sutton, Co-director
alexia mcgoun, Manchester (06/08/2005 at 16:46)
I would like to help in any way I could to save this cinema. It would be a shame to demolish it. Specially because I couldn't save my own city from destruction and I have seen it all before in my country. Where everything is beyond reparation and every day someone witnesses Havana City crumbling for ever.
The place could be used for future generations as a centre for arts and recreation, crafts, a market hall, a little place where to play music and dance. The options are countless. We may need to envolve the whole community for this project. Make them feel proud of their heritage and tresure it for eternity. Its worth a try!
Elliot Woods, Manchester (23/08/2005 at 19:32)
If anybody has got any information on how to volunteer then e-mail me on elliot.woods@gmail.com, thanks!
John Young, Stockport (07/11/2006 at 12:56)
It was proven not to be viable as a cinema, and a well run pub - as Wetherspoons generally are - would have been an ideal use for the building, probably retaining many of the original features.
Serban, Cambridge (08/02/2007 at 15:12)
Vicky Russell, West Didsbury (20/02/2007 at 13:41)
I used to live in Withington as a student and it broke my heart walking past Cine City everyday.I'm in my final year at Manchester Met Uni doing film and media so I'm quite busy with essays and my dissertation etc but I'm determined and willing to put in as many hours as I can to help you save this beautifull building.I desperatly want to be a part of retaining the cinema. Please contact me
caroline guard, 60 henwood road (29/04/2007 at 04:33)