Have to disagree mate, Rio's was poor on Boxing Day, as was Evans, but Evra has been consistently the weak link for some time now. His goals have been a welcome bonus, but he then spoils that by shocking defending that leads to goals conceded. Rio's legs have gone, whilst Evans is still relatively young. Evra is not yet at the veteran stage, and should be performing at a similar level to Ashley Cole.

Paul, Whalley Range