A "star" player ?, at the moment he is a "star" player in a poor team and stands out. I look at Michael Shenton, a "star" player at Cas, went to Saints, and has been found out as an ordinary player and looks like he is on his way out, probably back to Cas where he will become a "star" again. Saints are a poor team at the moment and need a clearout, they have not got over the retirements of Long/Cunningham and Ron Weasley going to the Bulldogs. Smith is better than what they have got. I.m undecided about Smith being a Wigan player, but im not the coach, and if he becomes half as good as Tommy, then he will do good.