Padraig Harrington was beaten in a play-off for the 36-hole PGA Grand Slam of Golf for the second year running in Bermuda tonight.

Twelve months after Angel Cabrera eagled the last to catch the Irishman and then won at the third extra hole, Jim Furyk birdied the 18th and then eagled it when they went into sudden death.

Harrington, four clear at one point last year, had been two ahead with seven to play this time and also one up on the final tee, but he once more had to settle for the £180,000 runners-up cheque rather than the £350,000 first prize.

Retief Goosen was third on one over and Masters champion Trevor Immelman fourth and last four strokes further back.

The event is designed for the year’s four major winners, but Furyk and Goosen came in as reserve because Tiger Woods was injured and Harrington, of course, won both the Open and US PGA.

Harrington, named as the PGA of America’s Player of the Year during the event, and Furyk finished on the four-under-par mark of 136, both returning back-to-back 68s on the Mid-Ocean course.

The Dubliner made the perfect start to his second round with two opening birdies.

Furyk responded with two birdies in the next four holes and with Harrington bogeying the fifth the former US Open champion led by one.

Harrington hit back, though, by finishing a front nine 31 with two more birdies and added another on the long 11th, but Furyk birdied the short 13th and Harrington double-bogeyed the 504-yard 15th to fall behind yet again.

The ding-dong struggle continued, however, when Harrington made a birdie two to Furyk’s bogey four on the short 17th.

Goosen shared top spot after three birdies in the first four, but was out of it from the moment he ran up a seven on the 12th, while Masters champion Trevor Immelman’s opening 76 left him too much ground to make up.