United's Ecuadorian winger had the unenviable task of being Sir Alex Ferguson's only major import of a summer that saw Ronaldo depart for an astonishing world record £80m fee.
Valencia cost £64m less when he arrived from Wigan but the $64m question was could he fill the right-wing vacancy?
Nobody expected another World Player of the Year or Ballon D'Or future winner and comparisons to Ronaldo were too unfair and were quickly ditched by most.
Valencia, though, still had to win Old Trafford fans' hearts if not as the new Cristiano but as a more-than-capable new incumbent of the wing berth.
It has been a relatively slow process for the 24-year-old but with four goals in his last seven starts the modest South American is beginning to win over the Reds' support.
Those warming most to Valencia are the 50-somethings age bracket who travelled the country and filled OT in the mid-70s wearing Butcher's coats with bar scarves tied around their wrists entranced by the cavalier Tommy Docherty era.
Among the Doc's young swashbucklers was the direct raider Steve Coppell.
There was nothing flash about the former Liverpool University graduate but he took on defenders and kept a consistent supply line for the likes of Lou Macari, Jimmy Greenhoff and Stuart Pearson.
Valencia is turning into the modern-day Steve Coppell as he slowly but surely beds into his new surroundings.
"You knew with Steve Coppell what you'd get," Lou Macari told M.E.N. Sport.
"When Steve got the ball you knew he was going to get past his full back, get to the by-line and there would be an end product for strikers and midfield runners in the penalty box.
"For the likes of myself it was great knowing you could make your run knowing that nine times out of ten Steve would put in a cross and there would be a chance of getting a goal.
"I think you are getting the same from Valencia now and there also appears to be a lot more to come from him. He's a powerful lad and doesn't mess about he just beats a player and then delivers a decent cross.
"The fact he is also scoring goals now suggests he is getting more and more confident.
Valencia signed for the Reds from Wigan last June just four days after Ronaldo's exit was announced.
"Valencia's arrival was totally different to his arrival at Wigan and also Steve Coppell's signing for United in the 70s," added Macari.
"He had nothing to lose when he came to England from Villarreal to Wigan. He was an unknown quantity and was initially on loan. There were no expectations and no price tag.
"So anything he did was something of a bonus to fans. It was the same with Steve when the Doc signed him from Tranmere Rovers for £60,000.
"There was no great pressure on Steve and he just came in and played his game and the fans were delighted. There had been no pre-conceived ideas about his play. So he was like a breath of fresh air.
"It is the same with Gabriel Obertan this season. He arrives for next to nothing and without any expectations.
"He has put in some decent cameos recently and everyone is impressed. However, it wouldn't have been the same if you'd stuck a £16m fee on his head like Antonio had. Then it is a lot more difficult to create an impression."
Meanwhile, defender Jonny Evans intends to remain grounded - as he wants to stay on the right side of Sir Alex Ferguson.
Evans has enormous respect for the United manager.
He said: "It is very rare for him to say anything bad about his players. He always gives them 100 per cent backing. It is great to have that from a manager.
"You have to be on your toes as well as you cannot upset him. You have seen what he has done in the past. If you are taking your eye off the ball, he will get rid of you. He treats everyone as men. Everyone has got to deal with certain situations but if you need to go to him, he is there for you.
"He just wants you to enjoy your football."
Tweet


Showing comments 1 to 25 and replies | View All
wholeoftheroon, Northern Ireland (24/11/2009 at 09:03)
Uwe the Goat, Brighton (24/11/2009 at 09:23)
Utds best bet would be to buy British in the window with Ashley Young, Jermaine Defoe, Gary Cahill and Joey Barton being sensible targets.
However, I have a sneaky feeling you might get Veron mark II.
paul salmon (24/11/2009 at 09:50)
And IMO the early signs are good. Despite being labelled one footed and one dimensional, his qualities are his pace, strength, crossing and disciplined workrate. Add to that a powerful shot, and you have the makings of a more than decent winger. Yes, he admittedly lacks the glamour and sheer 'wow factor' of most of the other wingers who have graced the hallowed OT turf. But at the the end of the the day great teams rarely ever possess eleven superstars.
Four goals in his last seven games suggests there is a decent goal output there, and I certainly see no reason why he should not weigh in with a double figure goal output each season. The power of his shooting is impressive, and his pace will always give him and head start on most full backs. Can anyone ever remember Ashley Cole being as subdued against us as he was in the recent game? I bet he would not want to be up against Valencia every week!
Whilst I would still like to see how Nani would fare on the right, I can only see Valencia getting better and better, eventually becoming one of the most effective wide men around.
Paul, Whalley Range
paul salmon (24/11/2009 at 09:54)
Paul, Whalley Range
Lee , Heywood, Heywood (24/11/2009 at 10:12)
Alias Smith, over the moon (24/11/2009 at 10:14)
Monkey tennis?, yes please (24/11/2009 at 11:21)
I find tony "the deflection" valencia just too frustrating for words.
I think he is least effective when attempting to beat his man - and rarely goes past the full back to the bye-line to put in a cross - so not sure where the similarities to Coppell come in (but i saw little of Coppell in the flesh due to my tender years, so hands up, i'm not best placed on this part).
Tony has had more success when he's drifted inside when the play has been more towards the left, and seems much happier there than hogging the touch line.
I doubt he'll become a true winger, let alone one of the best. And as much as nancy gets my back up, it would be interesting to see him tried on the right just to see if it ups his game at all.
As for the goal scoring, if the deflections continue, yes - he may well reach double figures...
I hope to be proved wrong, but he's not abated my frustrations one bit since he joined. SAF clearly sees, as do many others on here, a definite improvement in him, so maybe i've just got a mental block on him.
Mushhhty (24/11/2009 at 11:22)
Joey Barton!!! I think someone needs to put you out to pasture. I can`t think of any single english player who has the technique required to be at OT. Not even Rooney as that good!!!!
Scholesy passed me the ball..., England (24/11/2009 at 11:27)
yorkie-cpm, Huddersfield (24/11/2009 at 11:27)
Mrs Fullaway`s lodger (24/11/2009 at 11:42)
Brings tears to my eyes . . . and didn't we hate Leeds . . .
Lee , Heywood, Heywood (24/11/2009 at 12:07)
Gerry, Glastonbury (24/11/2009 at 12:32)
I think his progress has been very good to date.
RED ARMY 1999, swinton (24/11/2009 at 12:49)
outstation, perth, australia (24/11/2009 at 12:52)
MUTD the one the only, manchester (24/11/2009 at 12:56)
you were doing well up to joey barton i wouldnt give him a job as roadsweeper let alone in the midfield at OT.
if we are going to buy i think Fergie will wait till the summer we should all know by now that he wont be pressured into anything especialy if the prices are too inflated like they usauly are in january i dont think we should be that desperate to sign new players lets give some of the youth a chance and see what they are made of.
Fergie has usualy done right by us with the odd mistake here and there but who doesn,t make mistakes his are just highlited because of who he is and what he does.
Silvestre's Easter Island Head (24/11/2009 at 13:23)
I like both Valencia and Obertan and it is a bit of a throw back to the 70's. Been quite impressed with Valencia's contribution overall and delighted with his crossing and distribution, he can only get better and unfair to even compare him to Ronaldo. He is a differnet player and he brings different qualities to us which benefits the team.
Just wish he would show a bit more emotion when he scores? (if it was me, i'd do a lap on honour naked!)
Duncan, London (24/11/2009 at 14:17)
Uwe the Goat, Brighton (24/11/2009 at 14:22)
If Fergie can make a silk purse out of a sows ear like Fletcher, what can he do with a player who has reached his mid 20s and missed his way but has a lot more ability.(Joey will be cheap as chips too).
I know he is not a particularly nice character but neither was Ronaldo or Keane and that didn't seem to bother you much.
paul salmon (24/11/2009 at 14:23)
Fair comment, and I respect your opinion. However, I stand by my comments regarding Valencia. I think up to now he has done well enough, especially given the shoes he has been expected to fill! No I don't expect him to become a winger blessed with dazzling skills, bewildering full backs with feints and shimmies! Instead I see a winger who uses pace, power and sheer directness to cause problems for any full back. Along with intelligent link up play.
To do this he will need the right players around him. It was encouraging to see the link up play between him and Rafeal on Saturday, for example. I also think other players need to play to his strengths; namely his pace and power. If he is coached into making earlier runs into space, then it will be down to others to find him. The forwards would also need to then bust a gut to get into the box! This will all take time of course.
As for his goalscoring, yes Saturday's was a deflection, but they all count. Not every one of Ronaldo's were screamed into the top corners!
What is clear is that he packs a powerful shot, and a willingness to attack the penalty area. It follows that, given the space and chances Utd normally create, he could regularly reach double figures.
You will note that much of what I am talking about is potential here. I in no way consider him the finished article, just a youngish player who has started encouragingly and promises plenty.
And I do believe he can develop into a top class winger.
Paul, Whalley Range
Uwe the Goat, Brighton (24/11/2009 at 14:23)
He is better than what you have in that position and he probably hates City, plus he'll be cheap. Surely this guy ticks all your boxes.
Monkey tennis?, yes please (24/11/2009 at 14:32)
Someone else has commented that Valencia must be a real pain to play against, and that's something i've not really taken into consideration, but he does seem pretty relentless at times.
Also agree with thoughts on him needing a consistant right back to play with - a rapour is important... intersting that Pat and Gab seemed to pick things up pretty easily though - maybe due to Pat's experience more than anything else though.
Uwe, on a separate matter - you really are a top class p taker aren't you!
paul salmon (24/11/2009 at 14:35)
Great comments from you all. Nice to see the support for Valencia on this site. Some people ought to ask Ashley Cole if he thinks Valencia has the makings of a decent winger! He's arguably one of the best attacking full backs in the world, yet looked anything but when faced with Valencia.
So far, so good, the boy will certainly do for me!
Paul, Whalley Range
Duncan, London (24/11/2009 at 14:36)
Remember looking good for City is a whole different ball game to looking good in the Champions League. You obviously aren't aware of this and unlikely to ever be if truth be known.
paul salmon (24/11/2009 at 14:47)
If, as I fear, you are still talking about Joey Barton, then it would appear you truly have taken leave of your senses. I will not dignify your suggestion that he is better than what we have in that position with a response. However, I would suggest he left city for a BIGGER club. Given that Newcastle's fortunes have since spiralled downwards, and that Barton seems to be drifing along in no man's land, then perhaps city might be able to tempt him back!
If nothing else, he could entertain the squad by fighting with adabeyor and bellamy!
Paul, Whalley Range