They are less fluent. Less efficient. Less dynamic. Less exciting. More predictable.
Minus Cristiano Ronaldo they are not nearly as watchable.
Yet if they defeat CSKA Moscow at Old Trafford they will take their place in the knockout stages of the Champions League with a flawless record with two matches to spare.
And if they beat Chelsea at Stamford Bridge on Sunday they will retake the summit of the Premier League with almost one third of the season gone.
It suggests that Sir Alex Ferguson is doing something right. Actually, doing something week after week which eludes Rafael Benitez at Anfield.
Ferguson is getting the most from his players.
United do not have a Fernando Torres at Old Trafford. They no longer have a 30-goal-a-season striker following the exit of Ronaldo.
United do not have a Steven Gerrard. There is no surging presence in the United midfield. No talismanic creator.
Yet United have game-breaking players adept at influencing the ebb and flow of a football match in Ryan Giggs, Paul Scholes, Michael Carrick, Dimitar Berbatov and Wayne Rooney, and a team ethic which demands they work and scrap for every minute of every match.
They also have a depth of quality in the squad which allows players such as Wes Brown, Jonny Evans and John O'Shea to provide robust back up when Rio Ferdinand is going through his current blip and Nemanja Vidic is injured.
It is why you just do not see Ferguson sides capitulating as Liverpool did against Fulham on Saturday.
Ferguson authority
But, you might point out, Liverpool beat United 2-0 at Anfield just over a week ago.
How come they managed to do that when they looked so abject in the second half at Craven Cottage?
The answer might well lie in the aura and authority of the managers.
Benitez is in his element in one-off situations, especially when his team are seen as underdogs. It has served him well in the Champions League these past few years.
It contributed to a tactically shrewd performance against United when he worked out a system to deny Rooney space and thus blunt the edge of United's attack.
But one-off hits to do not get the job done in the Premier League.
Ferguson is the master of pacing a season. And while undoubtedly his team are missing the direct running and decisive decision-making of the world's best footballer in Ronaldo, they do have Rooney.
When Alan Shearer, the best England striker of the past 20 years, was asked this weekend who he would prefer in his team, Rooney, Torres or Didier Drogba, he answered unequivocally: "Wayne Rooney."
Why? Well, not because he scores the most goals, because already this season in the Premier League Torres has 10, Drogba nine and Rooney seven.
I suspect Shearer's reasons had more to do with what Rooney brings to the team week in and week out.
Rooney has become United's kite mark for industry. No player works harder. None appears hungrier for success. No striker mixes unselfish slaving, sublime finishing, copious assists and the ability to lift the game of those around him quite like Rooney.
That is a precious asset for any manager.
It is why Ferguson must enter the most testing week of the season so far with confidence.
United should have few problems disposing of CSKA Moscow, who they so clearly outplayed in a 1-0 win in Russia. Indeed, Ferguson will have the luxury of taking no risks, resting those with niggles and probably excusing Rooney, whose wife Coleen is about to give birth.
The clash at Stamford Bridge will be more revealing.
It will tell us whether a less watchable, less dynamic United are still too consistently powerful for the rest.
What do you think? Have your say.
Tweet


Showing comments 1 to 25 and replies | View All
Yashin, Manchester (02/11/2009 at 15:36)
Other teams need to get rid of the fear factor when playing United as did Sunderland....I look forward to seeing how you fair up to Chelsea as that will be your real test to date............
palomablanca, manchester (02/11/2009 at 15:47)
Monkey tennis?, yes please (02/11/2009 at 15:49)
The Trawler, Stockport (02/11/2009 at 15:53)
Gilly, Belgium (02/11/2009 at 16:17)
Happy Valley Barry, San Francisco, California (02/11/2009 at 16:18)
last season's. More team play, better crossing from the right, more competitive in midfield as SAF rotates all of them. Yes, we have no
Steve Gerrard in the middle dominating play, call the shots, but at United
our players don't necessarily need that, they have SAF bulling them into the top performances, no matter which 11 on picked. I see this season's team maturing into a fine and commanding champion - VDS, Rooney/Berbatov, Evra and Darren Fletcher leading the way.
Up the Reds!
Balders!, W3106, Tier2 (02/11/2009 at 16:32)
We could also, & probably will be 5 points behind the Chavs come sunday night....and in all truth, our performances to date, pretty much sum up where we are..........at the moment!!!.............
.... in a position to contend for honours, come May, & thats all any fan should want.....even the Dippers........aahhh, doh !
Red-Brit-in-It (02/11/2009 at 16:39)
Taggart , Ulverston (02/11/2009 at 16:56)
Happy Valley Barry, San Francisco, California
2/11/2009 at 16:18
I see this team as more than slightly inferior to last season and they will be found out at The Bridge (mind you, so will everyone else). Give it to Chelski now
Is It Me? (02/11/2009 at 17:09)
Mrs Fullaway`s lodger (02/11/2009 at 17:13)
Carragher didn't get sent off as he should have.
We didn't get the penalty we should have.
Lucas and Mascherano were allowed to continuously and blatantly foul.
Otherwise a draw or win for United if the ref hadn't bottled it.
Enigma? Yeah, sure. Benitez good for a "one off", maybe. Blah blah.
you know the one, you buy one you get one free., Tick tock, not long now. (02/11/2009 at 17:37)
Brora boy, Highlands (02/11/2009 at 17:41)
Brora boy, Highlands (02/11/2009 at 17:41)
ZuluUtd, St. Julian's Malta (02/11/2009 at 17:51)
paul salmon (02/11/2009 at 18:01)
Once again you two chaps make very interesting points with your respective posts, whilst maintaining the type of positive thinking much needed on these pages. I absolutely agree with Happy VB, Utd are developing into a powerful all round team, already capable of winning games without hitting anything like top form. Thus, accumulating points whilst still having plenty in reserve.
Admittedly Chelsea are looking formidable at the moment, yet are still merely two points clear of us. I personally would not be at all surprised if we get a result there on Sunday, despite form suggesting quite the opposite. I actually think Chealsea must be just a tad concerned that we are still ominously close to them, despite such a low key start to our campaign.
I also agree with The Trawler questioning the need for a thirty goals a season striker. Whilst Ronaldo's feats brought undoubted success, many observers felt it was at the detriment of other players, most notably Rooney and Berba. I maintain belief that both these strikers will enjoy more successful seasons this time round, injuries permitting. We should also remember that RVN's final seasons saw him continuing to plunder the goals, whilst the rest of the team failed to do likewise. Hence the silverware effectively dried up.
I maintain that we are still going through something of a transition, especially having lost that force of nature that was Ronaldo. That we are still managing to compete with Chealsea at the moment is in itself an achievement. I most certainly would not write us off. On the contrary, with the burgeoning potential of the youngsters coming through, I see another great United team on the horizon. Maybe even the best ever.
Paul, Whalley Range
Red Rob (West Lower) (02/11/2009 at 18:45)
Amazing how when he was at United, the media constantly banged on about how he went missing in the big games, he was a flat-track bully, he was no where near the quality of Messi et al. Now he's left he's universally labelled the best player in history and United are going to get relegated without him.
Look at the table. He was good - but he wasn't THAT good
Ben Taylor (02/11/2009 at 19:37)
moorz, Dublin (02/11/2009 at 19:56)
Matthew Savage (02/11/2009 at 21:01)
It was inevitable that this season would require some re-grouping and re-focusing of the team's pattern of play but with a little patience and squad tweaking I am sure we are well placed, and with the right manager, to kick on beyond the level of last season.
That United are second in the league and look well capable of winning it again is a real achievement.
Lee , Heywood, Heywood (02/11/2009 at 21:20)
Doylee, worsley (02/11/2009 at 21:46)
tooth&claw, manchester (02/11/2009 at 23:19)
Don't get me wrong, we're not there yet by any means but it's about this time each season that we start getting our act together and I see no reason why we can't prevail again over the course of the season. It's a pity that we have to face Chelsea with yet another defensive crisis (but then SAF never listens to me) but there's no reason for us to be overly pessimistic about the game. Only Drogba and Essian would be certain starters in our side, whereas VDS, Rio, Vidic, Evra, Fletcher, Carrick, Giggs and Rooney would get into their side.
The game at the weekend is a question of getting the tactics right. I'm more concerned about tomorrow's game, although there's less riding on it. I was thinking of bringing my boots to OT in case I could get a game!
tooth&claw, manchester (02/11/2009 at 23:28)
Unite against the UAF (03/11/2009 at 01:19)