Steve Bruce's side were ahead early on through a smartly taken Darren Bent goal before a superb volley from Dimitar Berbatov levelled the score.
Striker Kenwyne Jones outjumped United goalkeeper Ben Foster to head the Black Cats ahead, but with the clock ticking down Patrice Evra's shot was diverted in by Ferdinand.
The result ends United's run of eight consecutive victories in all competitions.
Sunderland were the ones who adapted to the blustery conditions quicker. Indeed, it could have been argued United did not adapt at all.
Rare are the times an opposition goalkeeper comes to this ground and gets through an entire half without having to make a save. But this was one.
Craig Gordon did make one meaningful intervention, diving low to cut out John O’Shea’s curling cross. Apart from that, the Scotland keeper was redundant.
Anton Ferdinand, the one member of his family to start after brother Rio was consigned to the bench by Sir Alex Ferguson, produced an effective central defensive performance alongside the equally impressive Michael Turner.
Yet even they must have been surprised by how little they had to do.
With teenager Danny Welbeck handed only his second Premier League start, a tentative approach from one flank was to be expected. Maybe the same could also be said of Nani given his dismal display at Stoke seven days previously.
The Portugal international was no better this time, and this time Ryan Giggs was not on the bench to bail him out.
And, in Bent, Sunderland boasted a man at the top of his game.
When he made the quick dash down from Bolton, England coach Fabio Capello might not have been expecting to spend half-time thinking about whether Bent should be in his squad for the World Cup qualifiers against Ukraine and Belarus.
Sunderland lead
Yet, had it not been for his decision to hand over penalty duties to Jones at Sunderland last week, he would now be top of the scoring charts.
And what a fine effort his seventh of the season was as Sunderland took the lead in only the seventh minute.
He got far enough away from O’Shea during a lengthy Black Cats build-up to have room to turn away from the Irishman when Lee Cattermole played the final pass.
The finish was inch perfect, giving Ben Foster no chance.
Replacing Paul Scholes at the break was a bold statement by Ferguson, which triggered an instant response.
Nani was a suddenly a man inspired, twice causing confusion with direct runs, the second of which demanded a brave low save of Gordon to deny Wayne Rooney.
The clearance came straight back out to O’Shea, whose curling 51st-minute cross was perfectly met by Dimitar Berbatov’s overhead kick, which nestled in the bottom corner.
As they say when the TV picture goes down, normal service was expected to resume shortly. Instead, United conceded again.
Foster, and no doubt Ferguson, who had already been incensed by a couple of Alan Wiley’s decisions, will doubtless feel Jones fouled the United keeper as he rose to meet Andy Reid’s cross just before the hour mark.
But Foster should have been stronger in the challenge. Instead, he was shoved aside to allow Jones to head into an empty net.
Thrilling late comebacks from such positions are the stuff of Manchester United legend.
Probably only this knowledge kept the hosts going as, even after Kieran Richardson’s needless dismissal, it never actually looked like happening.
Evra refused to accept second best, though, leaving Ferdinand to beat the ground in frustration.
What is your verdict on the action? Have your say.
Tweet


Showing comments 1 to 25 and replies | View All
keithmat (03/10/2009 at 19:36)
Why have Welbeck wide outside when there are quality wingers not even making the bench?
Happy Valley Barry, San Francisco, California (03/10/2009 at 19:38)
very well. Foster should have easily out jumped their stiker to punch the
ball away - VDS will be a welome sight between the sticks soon. Nani barely passed to the red shirt, what's up with him, it's like playing with
10 men when he's on the pitch, is Nani a secret agent man for the other teams? Good fight back by the reds for the tie.
Up the Reds!
Hilal Sued, Dar es Salaam, Tanzania (03/10/2009 at 19:43)
On second thoughts, it's better that he did not add those seconds, else there would have been a great uproar had United scored. Let other teams do that but not United!
BrewDevil, Clemson,USA (03/10/2009 at 19:50)
Is It Me? (03/10/2009 at 19:54)
danny, WILMSLOW (03/10/2009 at 19:55)
Did not like the side that started, I just wonder if they joined Valencia and Nani together they would make one good winger.
Today was crying out for a Ronaldo no messing direct play when our midfield was not giving the ball away; they were passing the ball back instead of forwards. We did not have one recognized center forward on the bench poor Kiko and Tosic.
Brucie must have thought it was his birthday today yes we should have had at least one penalty but this ref will not give us anything here.
Fergie got it wrong the players did their part to loose the game the donkey does his bit but he should have played Fabio today who could have got behind their defense
We could have nicked it in the end Giggs was not there to put in a cross..
Seamus, Vanisle,ex-Stretford (03/10/2009 at 19:57)
frank clarke's guitar tutor, warrington (03/10/2009 at 20:06)
Clawfinger Chadwyn (03/10/2009 at 20:08)
steve chew, usa (03/10/2009 at 20:09)
(4) SAF's subs made a big diffference but nothing to show for.
All said, the whole team has to bear the responsiblity of 2 points lost at OT. Lastly, when is VDS coming back between the sticks? SAF must be having early 'squeaky bum' times every time he has to make the decision who he is going to be between the sticks.
I'm just like Stewie Griffin, Fictional Quahog, Rhode Island (03/10/2009 at 20:12)
3/10/2009 at 20:06
You've had your first football lesson this season and you'll get another in April.
Shammers, marton moss (03/10/2009 at 20:15)
I'm just like Stewie Griffin, Fictional Quahog, Rhode Island (03/10/2009 at 20:15)
Referee.......I HATE YOU!!!!
Macca, Cornwall (03/10/2009 at 20:16)
Poor display despite having all of the possession, ridiculous to think we didnt have a shot on target at home in the whole of the first half. Not really sure if Foster is at fault for the 1st goal, it was a good strike, but Foster didnt seem ready similar to Arshavins strike weeks ago. The defence certainly dont look comfertable in front of him, the sooner VDS is back the better.
Not sure why Welbeck played on the left side, he did well wide right in the Fa cup semi last year but give the lad a chance. Giggs should have been on the bench, when he's in such good form a 10 minute cameo could have triggered a reaction from the players.
At least we didnt lose despite playing poorly, hopefully both Liverpool and Chelsea drop points tmrw.
barnsey (03/10/2009 at 20:18)
danny, WILMSLOW (03/10/2009 at 20:18)
trevels1968 , Failsworth (03/10/2009 at 20:19)
Rooney was awful today, Nani can't get a cross pastr the first man, Wellbeck is useless on the wing and Foster is a calamity, he causes the whole back four to become nervous wrecks.
Get some money spent on a goal scoring midfield player or there are going to be more days like tday.
stevi, france (03/10/2009 at 20:24)
George Kane, Stretford (03/10/2009 at 20:24)
Booed off at half time.Ben Foster is dreadful.
Fergie Fergie sign him up !!!
Sparky was the best ever (03/10/2009 at 20:24)
United weren't cohesive. Too many under performers.
Wellbeck has no ability to maintian possession. He's really crap and should not get a 1st team game again for United.
Bringing on Carrick for Fletcher effectively ended United's chances of getting a win.
United's midfield is pretty average and Sunderland proved it.
RemiMoses, Ireland (03/10/2009 at 20:24)
united--1999, over there.. (03/10/2009 at 20:28)
Bigmouth strikes again, Manchester (03/10/2009 at 20:34)
Red Afro, Derby (03/10/2009 at 20:49)
Squire of Newton, Newton nr. Hyde (03/10/2009 at 20:49)