Kuszczak - Could do nothing about West Ham's two goals but was generally sound otherwise, although his kicking could be better 6
Brown - Full back was generally solid in defence but his distribution often let him down
6
Ferdinand - For three quarters of the game he looked in complete control on his old stomping ground but will not have been happy to concede two goals from set pieces 6
Vidic - Serbian nullified the aerial threat of Carlton Cole in the first half but he too will have been disappointed with West Ham's goals
7
Evra
- He was unusually shaky and his sloppiness might have cost United twice in the first half. It was his foul that led to West Ham's winner
6
Ronaldo
- Rose to give United a rather fortunate lead in the first half, but his penatly miss was the turning point of the match on a day when the winger was unusually quiet
7
Fletcher - As busy as ever but struggled to dominate alongside Hargreaves 7
Hargreaves - Never really got into the match when confronted with a particularly lively West Ham midfield 6
Giggs - One of the rare bright spots for United. His movement and cross led to Ronaldo's goal and he worked tirelessly when moved into the centre of midfield
7
Tevez
- Given a fine welcome on his first return to Upton Park but while he worked as hard as ever rarely troubled the West Ham defence
7
Saha - A disappointing showing after his two goals against Sunderland. The Frenchman was largely shackled by the outstanding Upson 6
Subs
Anderson (for Tevez, 64) - United were crying out for composure in midfield but the Brazilian had little impact
6
Nani (For Hargreaves, 80) - Came on as United desperately sought to salvage points but rarely looked likely to make a telling contribution
6
O'Shea
(for Brown, 89) - Too late to mark
Subs not used - Tom Heaton, Gerard Pique
Referee: Mike Dean - Tried to let the game flow
7
Agree with the ratings? Have your say.
Tweet


Showing comments 1 to 25 and replies | View All
mjw, New York (29/12/2007 at 18:40)
Devil's Own,, malaysia (29/12/2007 at 18:48)
adam chance, lowestoft, suffolk (29/12/2007 at 19:01)
He was non existenet vs Liverpool away the other week, and didn't do much today in the 'cauldron' of Upton Park.
Needs to up it...
Red Lou, Malta (29/12/2007 at 19:24)
Dev, Johannesburg (29/12/2007 at 19:27)
DelawaRED (29/12/2007 at 19:31)
tim chorlton (29/12/2007 at 19:55)
arletta red, USA (29/12/2007 at 20:14)
roykeane, Holland-Germany-Poland (29/12/2007 at 20:38)
give danny simmo more games ! chelskov have won too so its still a 3horse race . tevez and saha played really bad. we missed roon. We just need to cool down and murder the brum . Come on United!
BrewDevil, Clemson,USA (29/12/2007 at 21:38)
I guess Fletch's generous rating came from his brave defending of his own 18 yd line (except on set pieces). Why was he paired w/ Hargreaves? I counted one time he beat a man at midfield and took the ball down the middle. If his value and role is not as a defensive backup for OH (and apparently SAF has little confidence for him in that role, as when he is paired with carrick, MC mostly takes a role in behind DF)then his only value is as a makeweight in a deal to move Brown, unless he has some aptitude for backing up JoS at RB until we get quality for WB.
Except for mostly competant, if uninspiring, defending, WB's woeful attacking and his indifference to attempting sensible distribution suggests he is busy contemplating how close his next club is going to get to the wages he has been offered at United. Doubt he will get much more in salary while plumbing the depths of mid-table with the likes of Newcastle.
Saha seems indifferent, but i think it is more a case that he is finally shot, not because of out and out fitness or sharpness that is gained by more matches, but because his knee is so daqmaged he cannot make acute cuts or even accelerate to a ball merely a few feet away. He can still craft a telling pass, as in that wonder to giggs or tevez that set up ronaldo at arse, but his days as a consistent major danger against stout opposition may be over. Another makeweight may lie as his destiny. A shame.
Giggs left all his touch impersonating Elvis at "the Party". Shocking lack of composure and touch in the midst of our most desperate need.
Too many people attempting shots that they have never come close to making in their careers.
COLIN,, Canada (29/12/2007 at 21:58)
SAPPER, MANCHESTER (30/12/2007 at 00:02)
Only 2 I say again 2 shots on goals one of them a penalty.
Benittez is the chop and change manager and you can wee why they have not won the league in so long, Fergy has done the same over the holiday period, he did it with Nani after he scored a wonder goal and player very well, then dropped him, he did the same with Anderson and it showed when he came on because he was off the pace when previously he has been one of our best performers.
Don't say it is because we have so many games in such a short time he is young and fit.
Fletcher is without a doubt one of the worst players in the premior league, and again apart from the the cross Gigis was nowhere to be seen. Ronaldo was not in the game either because the centre of our midfield could not hold on to the ball.
If you look at all the goals we concede most are from corners or free kicks into the box, we only have one decent header of the ball and that is Vidic, move him out of the flight as West ham did then we are in trouble.
Saha is well past his sell by date no trouble at all to the West ham defence.
West ham could and should have won by a greater margin the 2-1 we seem asleep straight from the off and never woke up apart from on move. Very poor perfomance will have allowed Arsenal to claim the top spot back again, and Chelski to close to2 points behind.
Sam Davis (30/12/2007 at 00:06)
Christer, Norway (30/12/2007 at 00:44)
I can't for the life of me understand how Fletcher gets the whole 90 minutes. His contribution today was abysmal, giving away posession on several occasions. And, considering West Ham was by far the better team in the first half, i'm surprised that noone seemed to able to up the tempo, and fight our way back into the game. No bookings or guts, just silly/clumsy, Smudge-like tackles outside the box, to provide West Ham with freekicks. Rooney was getting into form, where was he? He's the only player we have that carries on the Keane-mentality when it comes to rolling up their sleeves. And when it comes to the penalty; the one that should have been awarded was against United; when Rio stamped off Solano's shoe. Spector's "handball" was outside the box. However, Ronaldo can continue to take our PK's in the future; the penalty against Everton was pure class. Composure and precision all the way. Just be happy that Robbie Keane doesn't take them... hehe.
AP United, Luxembourg (30/12/2007 at 02:16)
Jonathan Chin, Truly Asia (30/12/2007 at 02:38)
Anderson should start ahead of him. And.. Saha... poor pass, poor shoot ( in fact just one shot i remember ).
Suhaima Samsudin (30/12/2007 at 06:20)
Savant, Singapore (30/12/2007 at 07:53)
Let's be honest, it was a poor showing. Perhaps too much Christmas turkey over the holiday period?
Even so, I believe this is a one off game and so let's take it out on Birmingham next!
saha rocks, work (30/12/2007 at 08:49)
Again, I'm sure whoever does these ratings has his tongue firmly in cheek to invite as much reaction as possible.
P.S. Thought Saha was OK. Great close control.
ryano (30/12/2007 at 09:19)
Sad to see the defence lose two goals from set pieces as they have been superb this season.
And why oh why fergie continues to play the fletch i just do not know - running around a lot and passing two yards is fine in the championship but not for a team looking to win the Premiership!!!!!
Saha also continues to worry!!
chris, oxford (30/12/2007 at 12:14)
manu xpert (30/12/2007 at 13:08)
Birdy, Ireland (30/12/2007 at 13:36)
As for these ratings, theyre incredibly generous. We played very poorly. Giggs was terrible, so was Fletch. Evra wasnt his usual self and Tevez and Saha hardly threatened. Not oone of our players could say they genuinely had a good game. Ronaldo probably has the best case to make for himself, with his goal and lovely pass to Giggs which he proceeded to miscontrol when the most basic of first touches would have seen him 1 on 1 with the keeper. I'd excuse Ronaldo his penalty miss as he's usually spot on with them. he didnt take it in the same way he normally does. He usually places rather than going for power, not sure why he switched.
Anyway, onwards and upwards. I think SAF has a lot to answer for picking Fletcher in a tough away game like this, however even though Anderson immediately looked lively when he came on, i think the general standard from everyone else was so poor changing Fletcher alone wouldnt have altered the result. There was a lack of effort and we were not outplayed by West Ham but outworked, and that should never happen. If we match the opposition for effort then 9 times out of 10 we'll win the match
fatmanwalking (30/12/2007 at 19:40)
I don't think more than a coupla players deserve a rating more than 5. Giggs, Ronaldo.
Pie in the Sky, Manchester (30/12/2007 at 20:44)
If the Rags are allow to make comments on the City section, then why can't we comment here?