Home | Sport | Football | Manchester City

Manchester City

Manchester City's dream XI

THE M.E.N.s chief sportswriter Paul Hince here provides an explanation of his all-time Manchester City XI.

But do you agree, or has one of your Blue-shirted heroes been overlooked? Vote for your own City dream XI here, and watch out for the results in the M.E.N. next week.

GOALKEEPER: BERT TRAUTMANN

Had I arrived on the planet a few years earlier, I could well have been nominating Frank Swift, who I'm told was an incredible goalkeeper. But I never saw big Frank in action so there is only one name in my mind for this slot, the legendary Trautmann. Funny that, I never thought I would be voting for a German paratrooper. But don't mention the war. Bert was something special. Big, blond, wonderful athletic and - with apologies to Joe Corrigan and Tony Coton - the most brilliant keeper I've seen in 50 years of watching the Blessed Blues. Bert could catch the fiercest shot - sometimes with one hand - and hurl it back into the opponents half like you or I would throw a cricket ball.

DEFENDERS: TONY BOOK

Astonishing to think that Skip didn't arrive at Maine Road from Plymouth until he was in his 30s, but still had a career in the top flight that most players could only dream about. Forget his age. Book was lightning fast. And I should know. I had to try to out-run him in practice games - and never succeeded. England's first Player of the Year in 1967 and captain of City's championship-winning side the following season. He was a wonderful right-back. World-class skipper.

CENTRE-BACK: DAVE WATSON

What a mountain of a man! Virtually unbeatable in the air and surprisingly nimble with the ball at his feet. What more could you want in a centre-half? It speaks volumes for Watson's defensive abilities that he was capped by England while still playing for Sunderland in the old Second Division. And he certainly lived up to his reputation when he arrived at Maine Road in 1975, exerting a massive influence on the Manchester City side which came within a whisker of landing the English championship in season 1976-77.

CENTRE-BACK: ROY PAUL

Long before the term was invented to fit Bryan Robson over at Old Trafford, the indomitable Paul was City's Captain Marvel during his seven-year career at Maine Road in the fifties. Paul began his working life as a coal-miner in south Wales and he was as tough and unrelenting in a blue shirt. Both ferocious and fearless in the tackle, the craggy Welshman captained the side which beat Birmingham to lift the FA Cup in 1956 to assure his place in the history books as one of City's greatest-ever skippers.

LEFT-BACK: GLYN PARDOE

The claims of Willie Donachie couldn't be overlooked when considering the left-back position but by a whisker, my vote goes to the chunky, ever-cheerful Pardoe who - if memory serves me right - began his professional career at Maine Road as a striker. From day one, the Blues knew they had a special talent on their hands in the kid from mid-Cheshire. He still holds the record as the club's youngest-ever first-team player when he was called up for senior duty while still 15 years of age. Pardoe suffeered a serious leg injury in a Manchester derby in the early 70s which cut short his career, but over 370 senior appearances bear witness to his remarkable consistency.

RIGHT-WING: MIKE SUMMERBEE

Signed by Joe Mercer from Swindon Town for a paltry '37,000 in 1965, the contribution made by Buzzer to the most successful era in City's history cannot be over-estimated. Summerbee was the only winger I can recall who could intimidate full-backs with his sheer physical presence. But there was much more to his game that mere brute strength. He was in the Beckham league with his crosses but, unlike the England skipper, Buzzer knew how to take on and beat an opponent. You couldn't add up the number of goals he made for others and two successive player-of-the-year awards in the early 70s demonstrated his standing throughout English soccer.

CENTRE-MIDFIELD: COLIN BELL

Is Nijinsky THE finest player ever to wear the famous sky-blue shirt? Perhaps City fans of the 30s and 40s will nominate the Irish genius Peter Doherty for that accolade. What I can say with absolute conviction is that Bell is the greatest player to represent the Blues during my lifetime. His running power and stamina were legendary throughout soccer in the late 60s - hence his well-merited nickname. But Bell was the complete box-to-box midfield player. Tackling, passing, shooting, heading. You name it, he had it, in spades. He would have been the captain of his club and country for years had his career not been cut short by the infamous tackle from Martin Buchan in a Manchester derby.

CENTRE-MIDFIELD: BOBBY JOHNSTONE

A selfish choice, this, perhaps. But for a starry-eyed kid in the mid-50s, watching Bobby Dazzler jinking past opponents with the ball tied to his feet was worth the admission money alone. Signed from Hibernian in 1955, Selkirk-born Bobby didn't look like a professional footballer. Rotund might be the kindest way to describe his physical appearance. But he had more tricks up his sleeve than Paul Daniels. An absolute joy to watch - and no slouch in the scoring stakes, either. Fifty goals in just under 140 appearances for the Blues. How many of today's midfield stars can boast a goal-scoring record like that?

LEFT-WING: ROY CLARKE

The dashing left-winger signed from Cardiff City in 1947, Nobby Clarke holds one particular record that will surely never be equalled - he played three consecutive games in three different divisions. Clarke's all-action displays down the left-flank earned him 22 caps for Wales and he was a vital member and chief provider of the City team that appeared in two successive FA Cup finals in the mid-50s. And like his roly-poly team-mate Johnstone, the Welsh wing wizard knew where the net was. Seventy-nine goals Clarke scored for the Blues. Not bad going for a player who liked to get lime on his boots.

STRIKERS: NIALL QUINN

What a vastly under-rated player the big Irishman was during his six years at Maine Road in the nineties. A veritable "roof inspector," the genial giant was best known for his heading ability but there was more to his armoury than that. As a leader of the line and target man up front, Quinn at his peak was the best in the business. As strikers go, Quinn wasn't a prolific scorer during his time in Manchester - 78 goals in 219 appearances for the Blues confirms that. But he was devastatingly effective at set-pieces and corners where those clever, cushioned headers created chances galore for his fellow forwards. Just '800,000 was what he cost, when he was signed from Arsenal in 1990. And the Irishman was undoubtedly worth every last penny.

STRIKER: FRANCIS LEE

Lee acquired two nicknames after joining the Blues from Bolton Wanderers in 1967 - Barney Rubble because of his similarity to the cartoon character and Lee One Pen for his unspottable trick of tripping himself up in the opponents' penalty area. But don't let those nicknames distract you from the fact that Lee was one of the great strikers of his generation, or any other, come to that. A pocket-sized bundle of dynamite. Barrell-chested and immensely strong with a kick like a mule. He averaged almost a goal every other game during his seven years at Maine Road and was the main strike weapon in the fabulous Joe Mercer-Malcolm Allison side that swash-buckled its way to the championship title in 1968.

YOU'VE READ PAUL HINCE'S BEST, BUT WHAT ABOUT THE REST? VOTE FOR YOUR CITY DREAM TEAM HERE

Comments

Login or Register to comment

I agree with Paul Hince selection.
There are some other players that will come close.

Report This Reply

Drool Drool! None of the present lot get a sniff do they? I just missed out on seeing Bert so have to go with big Joe & also never saw Nobby, Bobby or Roy unfortunately so would choose Mike Doyle, Ali Benarbia & Tommy Hutchinson as replacements.
I have to put Niall on the bench in favour of Neil but these debates always tear my guts out because you realise all the greats you leave out. Tomorrow I'll pick Booth, Oakes, Tueart, & the day after????

Report This Reply

I was never lucky enough to have watched most of these players but they are all Blue Legends....I was quite disturbed to read that a lot of them had their careers cut short by the RAGS in their theatre of failure. Add to these, the injurys of Alf Haaland, Paul Lake.... and many Others.

Report This Reply

Do you think you could remove our voting form from the UNITED pages? Thanks.

Report This Reply

Nobody on the team since the Niall days.
Tell you something about the current team?
Or, the fact that our players don't stay around long enough to make something like this.
I don't think Niall should have made it either, the Mighty Wyn Davies being the best at his position that I have seen in Sky Blue.
It would be really interesting if you could only take one player from a five year period, starting in 1954. There's another story for Hince.
And a last one. A team made up of Blues, who got transferred and became great. Some of my best half time arguements over a balti pie have surrounded that morbid subject.
Who, from today's team, gets in and would fit in with our hard-working lads of the past.
Difficult!
Then, who sits on the bench, alongside Big Mal.
Answer: Nobody.
This team of Paul's played 90 minutes and would be real dischuffed if they got substituted for after 68 minutes.

Report This Reply

What a poor selection of strikers.Love the man or loathe him, the likes of Quinne & Rosler are not in the same class as Anelka

Report This Reply

who ?

Report This Reply

What,no Paul Lake & Trevor Francis!Strange one that IMO!

Report This Reply

1. Simon Tracey
2. Richard Edghill
3. Jason Van Blerk
4. David Brightwell
5. Steve Redmond
6. Ged Brannan
7. Andrei Kanchelskis
8. Steve McManaman
9. Barry Conlan
10. Lee Bradbury
11. Gerry Creaney

Subs. from:
Kernaghan, Immel, McGoldrick, N Summerbee

Report This Reply

Andy Dibble
Lee Bradbury
Nigel Clough
Gerry Creaney
Craig Russell
Robbie Fowler
David Sommeil
Steve Bananaman

where are they?

they should be in this team...

Report This Reply

Toss up between Immel and Suckling in nets. Then my rock solid defence would be built on the ability's of messer's Van Blerk, Gayle, Kernaghan and Beesley ,Midfield would be a combination of style and guile with the mercurial Simon Rodger partnered in the centre by the electric pace of Gary Megson. As a club famous for playing dazzling wingers the right flank leaves me a dilemma...do i chose the workrate and sheer love of the blueshirt of Nicky Summerbee or go for the electric pace of the Dazzling Rick Holden ??? left wing is no problem with that household name Neil Heaney fitting the bill.Upfront a combination of options with the powerhouse abilities of Tony Grealish , the fox in the box stealth of Gerry Creaney, King in the air Barry (Bazza) Conlon or perhaps the Armyboy himself , step forward Mr Bradbury leaves me with serious decisions to make. Any suggestions welcome and before you all start yes i am a blue and this is supposed to be a joke.If anyone can beat that then please let me know.

Report This Reply

Missing some important names.

For pure class, Kazi Deyna, Kinki x5.

For pure heart, Nicky Reid, ran himself to death for the cause every game.

SWP is the man right now, but only those that didn't see Buzzer could have picked SWP ahead of him.

ctid

Report This Reply

Can you lot not get anything right? The voting selection is a joke! Please tell me when Paul Power played at right back?!

Report This Reply

as the only manc here..i think the comparison of niall quinn and franny lee compared to denis law and tommy taylor says it all.....

Report This Reply

This is all very subjective and a good way to fill in slow days during the summer, however not to include Mike Doyle makes me think Hince was asleep during the sixties and early seventies.An absolute giant on the field Mike Doyle in several different ways.PS. Why is Hince doing this same exercise with he Rags????????

Blue Moon
Vancouver.

Report This Reply

Paul Anthony. Just so long as you never pick Fowler, Macmanaman, Reyna or Sun.

Report This Reply

Where in this list is Neil Young one of the most under rated City player of all time. Scored so many important goals.

Report This Reply

What in heavens name is Colin Hendry doing on that list? I saw most of the games he played for us and he was bobbins most of the time. Tommy Caton was ten times the player Hendry was. Why is he missing from the list? Anyway, going in completely the opposite direction, i think the forward options could be boosted with inclusion of one of Stefan Karl, Gordon Smith, Darren Beckford or my favourite Trevor Morley.

Report This Reply

"Oh Asa Hartford, Asa Hartford, na, na,na, na"

Report This Reply

Where are Kazi Deyna, Tommy Caton, Kinkladze,Gerry Gow, Joe Corrigan, Paul Power, Dennis Tueart,Neil Young, Willie Donachie, etc etc. I am sure that old Hince is a closet red, its a wonder he didnt pick Martin Buchan!!

Report This Reply

Anelka is world class.Fact.Niall Quinn is never considered when the word 'world' is used. But what else did we expect from a very ordinary 'don't tell it how it is' football journalist.

Report This Reply

Ok after the laughs before of naming my all time worst city XI i will now name a favourite starting line up, however it will be based purely on players who at the age of 29 i can actually claim to have watched thus ruling out the easy options of lee,bell,summerbee etc...in goal it will be Tony Coton,leftback may surprise a few people but Neil Pointon wins my vote for this just ahead of Paul Power.Central Defence would consist of Keith Curle (at his best i.e first season or so-pacey,clever,commited,a leader) and Colin Hendry (why did Peter Reid never give them a chance ?)Rightback is hard possibly Andy Hill due to the fact we signed him for 200k and he hardly ever put a foot wrong, not a world beater but what would we do for a rightback who could actually defend now ?.Moving on into midfield and i will go for SWP on the right,Gio and Paul Lake in the middle (wasted anywhere else) and push Eyal out not as a winger but a wide midfielder. Upfront it has to be Anelka who despite his critics is the best i have seen at city and i would actually play him upfront on his own with Paul Walsh (the little genius) behind him as the link man just in front of the midfield.No height in the team up front agreed so id have Niall on the bench just incase along with the Goat.

Report This Reply

You missed a few good oldies. What about Johnny Crossan who was a great inside forward; Derek Kevan and Jimmy Murray were one of the best scoring duos that City ever had.
Tommy Booth should really get a place too.

Report This Reply

if the Goat isnt in there is diagree totally!! Quinny was quality but the Goat is god!

Report This Reply

mike of leigh provides a chilling reminder of how bit it all got in the 90s. other contenders: frontzeck, clough, beardsley, mason, margetson, atkinson. i need a lie down

Report This Reply