CITY and Paris St Germain played out a goalless draw on a freezing night of UEFA Cup action at Eastlands.
The Blues, who have already qualified from Group A and are guaranteed at least second place, failed to find inspiration and Daniel Sturridge passed up City's best chance of the night early on.
Peguy Luyindula was PSG's main threat but he could not find a way past Joe Hart in the Blues goal, and with the game stretched late on it was the visitors who looked more dangerous.
If they were being brutally honest about this game, both managers would have admitted, albeit sheepishly, that it got in the way of more important matters that lie ahead.
City, having already qualified for the UEFA Cup's last 32 from a tricky Group A thanks to a home win over FC Twente and the clinical despatching of Schalke in Germany less than a week ago, have Premier League points uppermost in their minds ahead of Christmas.
PSG, meanwhile, have not exactly been 'pulling le finger out' in the group matches making multiple changes to their regular - and best - side for their games against Twente (lost) and Santander (drew) and doing so to a much lesser extent again at Eastlands.
Of course for the Blues there was the carrot of a first place finish, and the 'easier' knockout draw that goes with it, but in the back of their minds they knew, too, that they would have a second stab at that reward in Spain later this month had things gone pear shaped in this one.
Expedition
There was an eerie lack of tension and adrenalin in the freezing night air with some of the players dressed more for a Polar expedition than a game of football.
It was not a look that would have gone down well on the catwalks and runways of the great Parisian fashion houses.
It is part of that great city's psyche that its inhabitants can be charm, style and elegance personified or, if they are in a different frame of mind, both diffident and disinterested.
For most of this encounter Paul Le Guen's men, watched from the stands by old boy Nicolas Anelka and Sale Sharks star Sebastien Chabal, were clearly the latter appearing as though they would have rather been anywhere else but in an ice-laden East Manchester awaiting another miserable snow flurry.
It was hard, then, to discern whether a much changed City side minus the recently outspoken talisman Robinho but containing two of his countrymen in Elano and Jo `lacked the mentality of champions' though perhaps we will be able to judge that better when he and the rest of the automatic first choices roll up in West London to face a rejuvenated Fulham on Saturday morning.
Blues boss Hughes had some alterations to his line-up forced upon him by injury but others were self-imposed as he left out Benjani and Didi Hamann from the side that won at Schalke but then lost the derby.
There were chances available for others to stake their claim not to be discounted or put to the back of the rack after the forthcoming January sales that are bound to see multiple changes to the make up of the City squad but no one ceased their opportunity to suggest there is real top class depth waiting in the wings
In addition to the two recalled Brazilians, Danny Sturridge, Tal Ben Haim and Pablo Zabaleta all came in for a start and it was the first named who should have opened the scoring in the fourth minute when Elano - who has clearly forgiven him for swiping the penalty against Arsenal - superbly slotted the youngster through the inside-left channel with huffing and puffing Parisians trailing in his wake.
Unfortunately Sturridge was unable to do the pass justice and his heavy first touch allowed the ball to run away a little and give goalkeeper Mickael Landreau the chance to smother the final shot.
Feisty
Some of the tackling was feisty and presumably to the liking of Sale Sharks' French rugby colossus Sebastien Chabal who was in the stands watching his countrymen.
He would have been less impressed by the sporadic skirmishes that took place between rival fans inside and outside the ground.
Paris followers were believed to be the instigators though Blues fans asking them where they were in WWII hardly helped matters!
Vincent Kompany and Pablo Zabaleta both brought Landreau back into serious action in a far from incident packed affair and PSG threatened even less frequently their best opening coming in the last minute of the first-half when Richard Dunne was rescued by Ben Haim after Peguy Luyindula had intercepted the City skipper's errant pass.
City lost Elano to injury in the opening m oments of the second period that stripped them so close to the bare bones in midfield that for a short while it appeared Felipe Caicedo might make a rare appearance.
The game, though, lacked pattern and purpose with Kompany the outstanding player on either side and chances few and far between with City seemingly devoid of fresh ideas and PSG certainly no better.
After Vassell was off target for the second time in the game it seemed it would take a set piece or a howler to decide the contest and Kompany had the chance to add to his burgeoning reputation in the 65th minute but cleared the wall and the bar with a fiercely hit 20-yard free kick.
Twente's win over Schalke means that it is now a straight fight between City and the Dutch side for who wins the Group.
And that means the Blues having to do things the hard way by winning in Santander in two weeks' time.
What is your verdict on the game? Have your say.
Tweet


Showing comments 1 to 25 and replies | View All
crosspennineblue (03/12/2008 at 21:41)
Sam Haggar MCFC4EVER (03/12/2008 at 21:44)
Kippax Lover, Manchester (03/12/2008 at 21:45)
A 2 man midfield won't win any game. Stevie and Kompany can't carry passengers like Vassell and Sturridge were tonight.
Also, a sad state of affairs when nearly £30m of strikers offer no hope of a goal. No movement, no ideas. Poor indeed.
A point's a point but this undeserved result papers over the growing cracks.
Fulham, Everton and WBA could be the final nails in Hughes' coffin. I hope not because I'd love him to succeed, but this can't carry on.......can it?.....can it???.....or maybe it can.
The King of Siam, Siam (03/12/2008 at 21:45)
The Goat's Big Toe (03/12/2008 at 21:45)
Sturridge thinks he's the new Robinho - he ain't
Vassell wouldn't make the Hull team (I'm talking Rod Hull)
Jo was OK to start but was given no support and faded badly
Elano (who I normally stick up for) has his head up his ar*e at the moment
A better team would have made mincement of Dunne and Ben Hiam
Hamahn's big end has gone, it's time to retire
Kompany, Ireland and Hart were the only Blues up for it...
The only positive was that Hughesy didn't look happy - I'm still confident that given time - he'll sort it.
Captain Underpants---True Blue , Southeast, Kent (03/12/2008 at 21:47)
Cliff Sear's left boot, Los Angeles (03/12/2008 at 21:48)
To put the EUFA cup into perspective per our great win in Germany, well Twente, who looked crap against City beat Schalke, so City are really struggling, what are your plans now Hughes.
Lets test our patience if we lose to Fulham hey lads? See how long we can tolerate Hughes and his poor selections, what next make Vassell captain?
Lamby30676 (03/12/2008 at 21:50)
mazamet, cheltenham (03/12/2008 at 21:55)
The loyalty to the likes of Vassell, he would not hit the target if it was the width of the pitch, is way beyond belief. The rest are simply not good enough. Even Elano is starting to become a fading star, we need players with heart and the desire to win to come to the club.
Robinho is right, Looking at what was on the pitch tonight only Kompany, Ireland, Zabaletta (is improving) and Dunnie seem to give 100 percent for the club. Jo needs time and confidence. SWP excused for tonight. Well done MH, United clearly set out to eliminate him from the game, same tactics that the Oldman at the rags claims for the girl in the no 7 shirt.
Where are our so called good young players, give them a chance it works for Arsenal why not city, otherwise we will be buying a new squad in January,
jackblue, Prescot (03/12/2008 at 21:57)
david whites fatsuit , sheffield (03/12/2008 at 21:57)
Phil Neal's Laxative (03/12/2008 at 21:58)
One shining beacon in the gloom of this completely uninspiring encounter was Vincent Kompany, who played a blinder, with Dunney not far behind him. Everything else was eminently forgettable to say the least. Huge improvement needed if we want to get anything at Fulham.
Nick F, Kettering (03/12/2008 at 22:14)
Vassell - championship player at best.
Elano - as commentator suggests, his attitude is poor.
Benjani - he plays with a smile and works hard. So what? If there is no real ability to score regularly get shot.
Jo- he can't do it plain and simple. Loan him out or take money if we can.
Hamann - too old legs have gone.
Mills - clearly.
Berti - if he hasn't had a game now he never will.
Evans - loan him out to get further experience - prem if possible.
Ball - take an offer of £1m for him.
Logan - never will make it at this level.
Fernandes - not a prem player.
Etuhu - likewise.
Castillo - loan will end.
Caceido - again championship level at best.
With our squad being so thin these need to be replaced and a few more added. Let's not wait until the summer to begin the clear out lets shift out the dead wood and start from January. We aren't going down but will we reach Europe with what we have ?
mike , usa (03/12/2008 at 22:14)
John Syred, Vancouver, Canada (03/12/2008 at 22:16)
delboyblue, a-u-l (03/12/2008 at 22:23)
ted knott, droylsden (03/12/2008 at 22:25)
Ste , Cheshire (03/12/2008 at 22:31)
Without Robinho,SWP and with a tired looking Ireland we looked no better than West Brom. I fear for us at Fulham if we play anything like that.
Our forwards are just dire. Jo is looking worse than Samaras at 3 times the price, Benjani offers little other than a smile, Evans isnt good enough and Sturridge whilst showing promise at times was very average tonight, though being played as a left winger by the master tactician Hughes doesnt help!
Elano looked like he was still sulking and other than one pass, everything else went wrong for him.
Positives
Dunne had a steady game but for one five yard pass that he managed to gift to them almost conceding a goal from it.
Ben Haim was better
Kompany was excellent
Hart did well
Zabaleta was ok
Other than that dross....
City soap opera, Manchester (03/12/2008 at 22:34)
We can't pull Hughes up for effort; if we are not winning then lets bring on every striker we have. But from where I was sitting it left too many gaps in midfield.
Good job Jan is coming up or I would fancy this team to finish in the bottom half of the table. Can someone also please shout to Dunne to keep his legs closed. The guy is being constantly megged!!
City Slipper, Manchester (03/12/2008 at 22:35)
Elano carried on his poor performance from Sunday, why go forward when you can play a back pass?
My boy Sturridge was poor. Someone just needs to tell him what to do. Keep wide and make forward runs to receive the ball. Simple really.
There is no point in going through it player by player. The team was terrible, unbalanced and disjointed as a whole. You have to look at the manager for that.
Good performances against Schalke and Arsenal. Poor performances against United and PSG. Take your pick but the table doesn't lie.
Lastly, it was clear that we were happy with the draw. Otherwise, why would Jo take so long to walk off the pitch? That is an insult to the fans who are not happy with second best......erm, that sounds familiar. Well said Robinho.
City soap opera, Manchester (03/12/2008 at 22:38)
sold me wellies, Canada (03/12/2008 at 22:39)
O'Fortuna (03/12/2008 at 22:45)
Shaun, At My Desk (03/12/2008 at 23:01)
play like eleven strangers,or he's not.
Our "strikers" yet again have to feed off
less than scraps,same as it was under
Pearce and Sven,so it will be under Hughes.
By the time it got to the hour mark it suddenly dawned on me that we were not going to score.I was so relieved 'cos
now I could just concentrate on praying that PSG didn't either-something that was far more likely.Onwards and onwards.CTID.
wollongong blue. Aus (03/12/2008 at 23:02)
Kompany and Ireland looked fantastic working the ball around and supporting each other and I think Garrido has proven he is a far better player then we gave him credit for at the start of the season.
While it might be admirable that benjani plays with a smile on his face I do feel that he just doesnt give a hoot about winning. He gets caught offside constantly or scuff's his shots and just turns around grinning like "wow i cant believe that just happened", believe it muppet, you do it all the time, can you not see a pattern developing??
I hope Jo comes good, but would love to have boom boom bojinov back sooner rather than later, we are struggling big time for strikers!