Home | Sport | Football | Manchester City

Manchester City

FC Midtjylland v City: Player ratings

8 HART: one fine save in the first half kept hopes flickering then superb in shoot out

6 CORLUKA: distribution was not at its best and never really settled into rhythm

8 DUNNE: absolutely terrific won everything against a lively and robust forward line

6 BEN HAIM: much better in the middle than at left back in first leg not troubled much

7 BALL: another to impress. Made goal-saving tackle and cross for late leveller

7 IRELAND: got through awful lot of work in a midfield that was hard pressed

7 JOHNSON: never able to dominate but better and better as the game wore on

7 RICHARDS: found it hard going in central midfield and happier at the back

6 PETROV: main threat was well marshalled and his shooting radar not tuned in

5 ELANO: had a most frustrating afternoon when nothing he tired went his way

5 JO: perhaps too early to judge but he will have to offer a great deal more

SUBSTITUTES:

HAMANN (for Ben Haim 58) – passing was superb; case to say he should have started game - 7

STURRIDGE (for Elano 57) – needs better peripheral vision but a big talent - 6

EVANS (for Jo 79) – his directness and forcefulness upset tiring defence - 6

UNUSED: Schmeichel, Garrido, Fernandes, and Caicedo

BATTLE OF THE BOSSES: Hughes’ gamble to play Richards in midfield and Jo up front was not a success but Thomasberg stuck to his guns and got it spot on

REFEREE: Robert Malek (Poland) – didn’t mind a bit of physicality and the game was better for his leniency - 7

ATTENDANCE: 9,460

MIDTJYLLAND: Heinze, Afriyie, Califf, Borring, Florescu, Thygesen (Madsen 77), Poulsen, Olsen (Kristensen 88), Salami, Reid, and Nworuh (Collins 66). Not used: Madsen, Raska, Ipsa, Flinta, and Christensen.

Comments

Login or Register to comment

Hart was excellent, kept us in it. 10/10

Scores are too high for the rest of the team.

Report This Reply

c'mon you didn't expect us to do it the easy way did you ? thats not the CITY way and we all know it,lol.
onward and upward for the BLUES, welcome back home SHAUN !!!

Report This Reply

Johnson was never a 7 !

Hart 9 - Hero
Corluka 6 - Steady
Ball 7 - Great clearance
Dunne 8 - Rock solid
TBH 6 - Fair but nothing special
Johnson 5 - Was he playing? Tried everything to lose us the match!
Ireland 6 - Final ball when 3 on 2 was shocking!
Petrov 6 - Average game for him
Richards 5 - Not his position. much better at the back
Elano 5- Not enough energy and lucky not to be sent off
Jo -4 Oh dear - We need much better from him for that sort of money!

Sturridge/Evans and Hammann all 7

Report This Reply

How can Hamman get a 7 and Evans only get an 6? Hart should have got a 9.

Report This Reply

How can Hamman get a 7 and Evans only get an 6? Hart should have got a 9.

Report This Reply

johnson and ireland a 7 ?? youre having a laff...they were both very poor and never gave us a foothold in midfield or a platform for elano.
the whole team misfired and the only bright sparks were ched evans and sturridge again. but onwards and upwards...it was nearly a classic away performance IF we'd have done the bizz at home.

Report This Reply

Yeah, I think we all know it was a bad performance but we're through that's the main thing, did any of actually think City would do it the easy way. Jo needs time to settle in so lets not be too harsh on him. SWP is back home and there may be a couple more on the way so lets just look forward to the ride ahead!

Report This Reply

Who the bleedin hell gave these player ratings...7 for Johnson WHAT !

8 for Dunne
9 for Hart

The rest of em 1

Report This Reply

Chris what game were you watching? Dunney went completely missing last 15 of the 90. Didn`t look interested. Lost his man, showing no real desire to correct. Luckily the Danes were abysmal in front of goal. Looked to me like our "captain" gave up on the game when he should have been driving more from everyone. Sorry Dunney, i love you mate but that`s not good enough. Johnson? New contract? You`re havin a laugh pal.

Report This Reply

Johnson was pathetic. More like 4. Spineless. Who ever compared this nobody to Colin Bell ? What a joke. This kid, cos that is all he is, is pathetic. He wants shipping out; not EPL quality by a long chalk ! WEll done the rest of the lads !

Report This Reply

For once can't argue much with the ratings. Good to see Dunnie make amends for his error in 1st leg while Ball had his best game for some time. Rode our luck a bit but I'd rather get a result than looking fine & fancy in going out. Subs worked well too so lets pray for a good draw in the next round. A good holiday destination would do me!

Report This Reply

another great performance from mr dunne

Jo you dont deserve to wear that shirt how many million did we pay for you? utter muck

Report This Reply

Abysmal. Nearly all the team should have got less than 3 except for Joe Hart.

Report This Reply

How can Johnson get the same as Ireland????????? Steve Ireland best player on the pitch

Report This Reply

Jo: "Perhaps too early to judge but he will have to offer a great deal more." You're not kidding he will.

Report This Reply

hart 9
dunne 8
evans 6
sturridge 5
elano 2
jo 2
everyone else 4's

Report This Reply

Jo recievied no service whatsoever...you need the ball sent up to you to score goals.The midfield is shambolic.Totally out muscled by an ordinary workmanlike team.Johnson was pathetic,Petrov not much better.Dont let the euphoria of getting out of jail gloss over this inept shocking performance.

Report This Reply

JOHNSON 7 ? he is a disgrace to the shirt, over hyped and overly confident in his own mediocre abilities, he will prove to be a flop. Missed a sitter, missed a penalty, looked second best to most of their side throughout and has been like this in most games he plays, has the odd good one which is not good enough, Dont care that he's only young, so is Messi. Johnson is Championship material, with Ireland who is so far from being a winger its untrue. Very poor.

Report This Reply

I thought Ball, Corluka, Ireland, Johnson, Dunne, Ben Haim, Jo, Elano, Petrov, Richards were all awful!

Report This Reply

some scores here way off the mark. Jo 5? 4 at best. very poor. Johnson, i like him but he got better as the game wore on did. er no. missed pen and missed simple one on one. only players with any credit today were hart, dunne and charlie. ireland bust but ineffectual. we were VERY luck y today but we should be happy and now go on and win it!

Report This Reply

Johnson 7 ???????? Your off your trolley Chris. He was shocking.

Report This Reply

Same as usual when we have a game like this it was that dominant experienced midfield general we lacked. May be Kompany would have been that today. If anyones place is in jeopardy after today it should be Johnno not SI but Petrov, Jo & Elano were poor today. Evans has the heart and bottle to go far and reminds be a bit of a young Robbie Keane, just needs the goals to suceed. Happy day all in all and MH has some selection decisions with squad numbers now swelled.

Report This Reply

Hope there is more from Jo otherwise Chad and Danny must be worth 20 Million each.Johnson was not at the races today very poor and Tel played even worse than him.Plus side we are through and can only get better with Kompany SWP still to play.

Report This Reply

Chris must have been watching another game or was he dreaming? Johnson and Ireland both 7! your joking - they were both abysmal and a disgrace to the shirt they both wore,against West Ham I thought Ireland was terrific but today his performance was like Johnson's --- APPALLING! also if Dunne warranted 8 then Joey Hart should have got 10 Dunne was 6 in my book because mainly his leadership once again raised great concerns....

Report This Reply

Do our club a favor and lay off Jo. He's hardly played a game and people are tearing shreds out of him.

Unbelievable.

Report This Reply