A YOUNG man drowned in the Manchester Ship Canal as horrified office workers looked on helplessly from their windows.
Police were called after the man in his mid-20s was seen dangling from the edge of a canal path between Trafford Road Bridge and the Pomona tram station.
Officers tried to coax him away from the water at Exchange Quay. But the man, who had been holding on to chains attached to the side of the canal, appeared to jump in.
Witnesses said officers tried to use a belt as a lifeline for the man and then dived into the water after being joined by two colleagues.
Company boss Kay Clough, 32, whose offices overlook the scene, said: "After the guy jumped in, his arms were waving everywhere but eventually he put his hands together and just sank.
"After about five minutes a policeman dived in after him with no safety equipment, only a rope tied round his waist.
"He spent five or 10 minutes looking for him and after a while another police officer jumped in, but they couldn't find his body."
Another worker, Martina O'Brien, said: "The police were handing him things but he wouldn't take them. At one point they threw out a rope and an orange buoy, but he turned his face away."
Shouting
But business surveyor Katy Lund, who saw the incident at about 4pm yesterday from an office on the other side of the canal, believed officers hesitated in responding to the situation.
Ms Lund, a qualified lifeguard, said: "The boy fell into the water and he was thrashing around for two minutes and the police officers didn't really do anything. The man either couldn't swim or was a very weak swimmer.
"The police officer could just have leaned on to one of the chains and grabbed him because he was less than a metre away from the bank, but they didn't go into the water until they were joined by another two.
"Everyone in our office was shouting at the police to jump in to save him. These officers looked like they were just not trained to deal with it."
Chief Constable Michael Todd visited the scene but police said this was because he happened to be passing.
A police spokeswoman said: "Officers spoke to the man and tried to encourage him to come away from the canal. He was then seen to step from the chains and into the canal, going under the water. Two officers jumped in after him, while other officers called instructions to him from the quayside."
Police divers and fire service crews were still trying to locate the body last night.
Tweet
Man drowns in canal horror
September 15, 2005
SEARCH: Police divers tried in vain to find the body.

Showing comments 1 to 25 and replies | View All
Chris, Building 8, floor 4, Salford Quays (15/09/2005 at 10:16)
It is our opinion here that no-one needed to die.
Anon, Salford Quays offices (15/09/2005 at 10:20)
Dave, Manchester (15/09/2005 at 10:23)
Tiffany, Salford Quays, Manchester (15/09/2005 at 10:38)
Jo, Stockport (15/09/2005 at 10:54)
An onlooker - by their own admission, a trained lifeguard - didn't jump in, so why should the police in their heavy uniforms?
My condolences go out to the family of this young man - but the police can't be blamed!
Eddie Rayner, Manchester (15/09/2005 at 11:29)
I watched that man drown.
He clearly could not swim and was thrashing around, clearly fighting for his life.
He died in about 3 minutes.
An arm's reach away from help.
I saw the 4 coppers standing 'round scratching their chins to begin with. Then they started flapping. Not very good use of the few minutes this fellow had to live. Anyway. The point is: The first policeman entered the water when the drowning guy obviously took his last breath and sank away. He died within an arms reach of 4 burley coppers. Another blunder, another one we will hear nothing more about. Now I really don't feel safe.
Ron, Salford Quays (15/09/2005 at 11:57)
Horrified Office Worker, Salford Quays (15/09/2005 at 12:31)
Someone was out there talking to him whilst he stood on the canal tow rope.
The police showed up and he jumped a few minutes later.
The police took off their shoes, walked back and forth a bit and then jumped in whilst the man was thrashing around.
They appeared to try and offer things for him to grab but never tried to grab him.
He went under after about 5-10 minutes of thrashing. The police dove for him and couldn't find him.
A boat showed up and they began trawling the canal.
Paramedics/police and firemen arrived shortly after.
So, make your own deductions. To many of us watching the whole ordeal it seemed like the police simply waited for far too long and weren't prepared for what was happening. To others the police did a brilliant job.
Gary, Longsight (15/09/2005 at 12:49)
Dave, Salford (15/09/2005 at 13:07)
anon, exchange quay (15/09/2005 at 13:38)
He clearly never wanted to be 'rescued' - had he committed a criminal act?
Open your eyes
The police do a very difficult job and should not be 'hung' for this.
Horrified Office Worker, Salford Quays (15/09/2005 at 13:39)
bob, manchester (15/09/2005 at 13:56)
Anon, Exchange Quays (15/09/2005 at 13:59)
Tez, MAnchester (15/09/2005 at 14:01)
Fred Elliot, Pomona (15/09/2005 at 14:14)
Sophie, Old Trafford (15/09/2005 at 14:37)
I think we should at least respect his decision and look at offering more help before more people like him decide to take their life. Maybe if it had been there for him, he might never have made sure a horrific decision.
Sophie, Old Trafford (15/09/2005 at 15:15)
Horrified Office Worker, Salford Quays (15/09/2005 at 15:16)
I'm sorry to say that this is one of those 'you had to be there' situations.
Horrified Office Worker, Salford Quays (15/09/2005 at 15:20)
I think we rather he would have been saved though :(.
ANON, SALFORD QUAYS (15/09/2005 at 15:27)
ANON, SALFORD QUAYS (15/09/2005 at 15:41)
John Davies, Carnforth (15/09/2005 at 16:14)
Roger, Oldham (15/09/2005 at 18:40)
Melody Shaw, Bolton (15/09/2005 at 20:42)