A TEENAGE girl was turned away from an upmarket shopping centre in Manchester - because she was dressed like Coronation Street's Rosie Webster, who wears black clothes.
Melissa Fletcher, 16, met two friends at the Triangle, in the city centre, for some Saturday afternoon shopping. But security guards would not let them inside, apparently because of the way they looked.
Melissa has red and black hair and a pierced lip, just like the character Rosie in the Street who has rebelled against her parents Sally and Kevin Webster by dyeing her hair black and listening to Goth hard-rock music.
Melissa's mum, Sharon, 34, from Denton, said she had already taken her daughter shopping inside the complex on Saturday morning. But Melissa was barred when she returned with her friends, both 16, later the same day.
Sharon said: "Melissa does not drink, smoke or take drugs. She knows what is right and what is wrong but dressing differently is no reason to be singled out. She had money in her pockets to spend but Melissa did not even get through the front door.
"The security guard told me later that he was under strict orders not to let them in because of the way they looked."
The Triangle - the former Corn Exchange - includes designer clothing stores like Karen Millen, Jigsaw, and Muji, and a Nicky Clarke hair salon.
Melissa, a pupil at Egerton Park High School, Denton, said she would not be returning to the shops. She said: "I think it is discriminatory."
A spokesman for the centre said: "If it is believed the behaviour of some is likely to compromise the safety or enjoyment of others, then the Triangle is able to reserve the right to refuse admission."
Should people be barred from shops for wearing black? Have your say.
Tweet

Showing comments 1 to 25 and replies | View All
Katie, Eccles (06/06/2005 at 10:05)
Dave, Manchester (06/06/2005 at 10:11)
Emma, Salford (06/06/2005 at 12:28)
Tiz, Ashton (06/06/2005 at 12:35)
BigK, Stockport (06/06/2005 at 13:06)
jumpers for goal posts, bolton (06/06/2005 at 13:07)
Jill, Ashton (06/06/2005 at 15:30)
Whats wrong with you people? Have you ever actually been young?
I used to be a goth about 25 years ago and used to get the funny looks but it didnt stop me being what I wanted to just because people are narrow minded bigots.
She is a child so why should she "grow up" as someone pointed out.
Its a pity the original shops from the Corn Exchange have disappeared as she would have been welcomed with open arms.
BigK, Stockport (06/06/2005 at 16:02)
jill, Ashton (06/06/2005 at 16:21)
I have often seen gangs of goths, moshers etc and not once have they been causing trouble.
Bigk the Corn Exchange didnt just sell stamps, it sold jewellery , cds, etc etc.
Eamonn O'Brien, Longsight (06/06/2005 at 16:29)
Lianne, Bolton (06/06/2005 at 16:47)
Oh and in my experience, goths are always the nicest, most respectful kids. Why everybody should be expected to dress the same is beyond me.
Horvendile, N. London (06/06/2005 at 17:01)
I don't think much of that myself. Not everyone dresses differently because they want to be 'shocking' - some just like it aesthetically. The world would be dull as hell if everyone looked alike.
Unfortunately, it does sound like some of this girls' peers had acted unpleasantly, but I would think they should make a call on someone's demeanour. A rowdy, maybe drunk group of people who've been bothering those outside, probably no, but a small group of girls together who just seem to be chilling out, why not, however they dress?
Dom, Chorlton (06/06/2005 at 17:13)
adam, essex (06/06/2005 at 18:10)
Liane, Somerset (06/06/2005 at 18:19)
stephen, stockport (06/06/2005 at 18:37)
The Triangle shops may have high thoughts of themselves but are just pretentious and the lass can get better value and better fashion in real shops elsewhere.
The Triangle is just another bit of Manchester to avoid. Increasingly Manchester is becoming just poor value film set show with no value.
Bungle, London (06/06/2005 at 18:54)
I was brought up to beleive you judge people on there actions not no how they look or choose to dress,
I bet if put a ban on my shop saying mancs or scousers where barred because they are ALL drug users I would be up in court in 5 seconds flat. btw before someone goes off the deep end I don't think mancs and scousers are all drug users, like any society you had a few bad and lots of good. Don't insult the good by presuming they are all bad.
And as for the comment about goths not collecting stamps, I know a good amout of goths that do collect things, stamps included.
Jessica, Manchester (06/06/2005 at 19:39)
alistar, whalley range (06/06/2005 at 20:46)
Ian, London (06/06/2005 at 20:48)
Seriously. Show me the times that a group of Goths have caused trouble, they are far too vain to risk chipping a nail. Take a close look at their boots, it's not footwear for running away in.
Imagine the police line-up. "It was her with the bright red hair and 15 facial peircings."
Ian, Nottingham (06/06/2005 at 23:17)
ben, london (06/06/2005 at 23:33)
Michael, Surrey (07/06/2005 at 02:38)
Dress does not necessarily dictate behaviour. The implication that goths are expected under some "goth credo" to act a certain way is as ridiculous as suggesting that women who wear floral print dress MUST like scones. Black was also the colour of the young facists but I doubt you'd find many goths who support their views just because they wear the same colour clothes.
That said, I know if I'm walking along the street and I see a gang of punks on one side and a gang of chavs on the other I'm going to the side with the punks. Perhaos black-wearers are less well behaved in Manchester but, here, only people who believe Channel 5 documentaries give themselves reason to fear goths et al. The chavs, on the other hand, are happy to provide plenty of reasons to despise them. When was the last time a goth spat at you for not liking your shoes?
Aaron, Isle of Wight (07/06/2005 at 08:15)
One more thing, innocent until proven guilty. If and when they do something against the shops rules, then bar them/kick them out.
Natalie, Toronto Ontario, Canada. (07/06/2005 at 08:22)
Thank you;
-Natalie.