A CON-ARTIST stole a woman's identity as part of an elaborate scam to sell her luxury home and pocket the cash.
Angela Hargreaves used a false name to obtain the tenancy of Catherine Litherland's five-bedroom semi in Hale, near Altrincham, before assuming her identity.
Manchester Crown Court heard how she took birth and marriage certificates belonging to Ms Litherland from a cupboard inside the house in Ashley Road.
Hargreaves, 32, then twice tried to sell the '560,000 property - for '430,000 and '480,000 - while Ms Litherland was living abroad.
Joanna Rodikis, prosecuting, said that a sale was only scuppered when police arrested Hargreaves for shoplifting at Tesco in Altrincham and discovered suspicious documents.
Hargreaves, who admitted theft and deception charges, was given a 200-hour community punishment order after the judge accepted that she didn't organise the deception.
When police arrested Hargreaves for shoplifting, they found a driving licence application in Ms Litherland's name and a loan application in the name of Jane Wright.
Hargreaves used that name and donned a blonde wig and dark glasses to secure the tenancy of Ms Litherland's home from Rooftops letting agents in Hale in August 2003.
The company checked her references and she produced a driving licence and bank account details in the bogus name to pass a credit check before being given the keys.
Once inside, she took Ms Litherland's personal papers and passed them off as her own, approaching two prospective buyers for the house and two solicitors' firms to carry out conveyancing.
She also stole 19 pieces of antique furniture worth '14,200 from Ms Litherland's house, which her father Roland left her with the house when he died in 1997. The antiques were sold on for just '1,250.
Hargreaves was spared prison after a judge accepted she was not the orchestrator of the fraud. She said she had been asked by a man to help him look after a house he had to sell.
Judge Adrian Lyons told her: "Any fraud of this nature is serious, involving as it does an offence which is becoming more prevalent, which is theft of an identity."
While she would have faced jail in normal circumstances, he said the benefits for her and losses suffered by others were "nothing like as great as they might have been".
Mark Graffius, defending, said the offences came after Hargreaves fled a violent relationship and was left in debt. He said he had been instructed to convey his client's "extreme remorse" to Ms Litherland, who was in court.
Speaking after the hearing, the 60-year-old, who lives on a boat in New York, said: "I feel very disappointed. She should have gone to prison."
Should Hargreaves have received more than 200-hours community service? Have your say.
Tweet



Showing comments 1 to 25 and replies | View All
Rachael Robinson, Eccles, Manchester (20/04/2005 at 09:52)
mickey, oldham (20/04/2005 at 11:04)
Mark, Manchester (20/04/2005 at 12:21)
Steve, Crumpsall (20/04/2005 at 12:39)
She knew exactly what she was doing and planned maticulously to do the crime.
who can trust her with anything now?? with this and burglars getting off what a sad sad justice system we have defence lawyers should be ashamed of themselves
hannaford, south east queensland australia (20/04/2005 at 12:41)
des, manchester (20/04/2005 at 12:55)
mjc, stockport (20/04/2005 at 12:59)
GRR, Manchester (20/04/2005 at 13:34)
Fact of the matter, Hargreaves stole more than just property, she stole identity. A jail sentence would seem appropriate to me.
David, Stretford (20/04/2005 at 14:34)
Rach, Crumpsall (20/04/2005 at 14:48)
Jamie Whelan, MCR (20/04/2005 at 15:35)
I really hope that she can rebuild her life as i remember her as a popular and well liked girl. She was kind and never wronged anyone. There are very often much more to these kind of stories than meets the ye and i wish people wouldnt be so quick to jump on the daily mail "string em up" bandwagon.
abs, old trafford (20/04/2005 at 15:49)
Teresa Ahearne, London (20/04/2005 at 16:53)
I'm sorry but she should have gone to jail. It seems that the victim has no redress on this out come. Look's like all con-artist will be headin to Altrincham way!
David Horrocks, Burnage (20/04/2005 at 17:00)
sam, london (20/04/2005 at 17:28)
dave, swinton (20/04/2005 at 18:21)
Tirthankar Basu, Manchester (20/04/2005 at 19:12)
I think the world needs to learn a lot from the British lawmakers....how to NOT serve justice under all possible circumstances.
John McGowan, North Carolina USA (20/04/2005 at 19:53)
Deborah, Bolton (21/04/2005 at 18:40)
Good solid hard labour I say, after my home burgled twice I no longer have feelings for these type of people, the country is to soft on them.
Mr. A. Parker, Chester (22/04/2005 at 14:03)
THe sentence her to have just 200 hours is not really a sentence but a pass a fob off to the victim.
I believe that this will send the message out to all that it is easier to commit fraud than hard honest work as like the victim.
Kevin, Manchester (22/04/2005 at 14:04)
Ben, Manchester (22/04/2005 at 14:46)
It is obviously getting easier by law to take the easy path through life.
So what can I get for a few days' worth of community service? I can do with some nice things!
trev raymond, leigh (22/04/2005 at 15:31)
Matthew, Didsbury, Manchester (22/04/2005 at 15:56)
Alan Gill, St John's Newfoundland.Canada (22/04/2005 at 16:51)
Identity stealing is unforgivable.