News

Saved: Manchester's Sure Start centres to stay open after massive protest by parents

VICTORY: Families campaigned against the closures

Sure Start centres in Manchester will stay open under town hall plans to save them from the axe.

The council had said huge government funding cuts would force the closure of all the city’s 39 Sure Starts if new groups could not be found to take them on. That announcement, a year ago, sparked a massive backlash by parents.

Now we can reveal children’s services chiefs have drawn up proposals to keep the centres open.

But the cuts – of 21 per cent of the council’s government grant – mean plans to end council-run daycare for under-fives will go ahead. Instead, there will be an outreach programme that will see every family of a newborn visited at home by a council worker, who will stay in touch until the child is three.

The battling army of mums and dads who didn’t give up the fight to save Sure Start centres

The plan to save Sure Starts, which provide childcare and parenting advice to some of Manchester’s poorest families, follows a three-month public consultation – the biggest the children services department has ever undertaken. Face-to-face meetings were held with 8,200 parents and carers and 4,700 people responded to questionnaires.

The city’s early years budget is being slashed by £22.1m, with the loss of 400 jobs, as part of £170m of council cuts.

Coun Afzal Khan, the town hall’s executive member for children’s services, said the council was ‘determined to continue to improve provisions for under-fives across the city’ and would ‘move fairly and progressively forward’.

He added: "We anticipated most of the issues that would be raised by parents during our consultation, and have listened closely to the concerns of the many parents and others who have responded to it.

"The proposals that we have drawn up will see far more families accessing Sure Start services than at present, which in turn should result in far better outcomes for children and families across the city."

The council will maintain all core Sure Start provision at 39 centres – including health and parenting advice, breastfeeding support and early learning.

But some of the extra, discretionary services will be lost.

The £3m cost of keeping the provision going will be met by moving other services – such as Jobcentre Plus, youth and midwifery services – into Sure Start buildings, allowing the council to close other sites.

The buildings will be open for longer, with space rented out to community groups.

The council will also save £11m by pulling out of providing universal daycare for under-fives, affecting 800 youngsters who use heavily-subsidised local authority provision across 24 locations, including nine council nurseries.

Those youngsters make up about 2.5 per cent of Manchester’s 32,500 under-sixes – but are more than one in ten of those in daycare in the city.

The daycare plan was first proposed in September and will move forward, despite opposition from two-thirds of people who responded to consultation.

Parents affected face a rise of between £11 and £37 a week in private daycare costs.

But the council is promising additional help for lowest-income families, who could find themselves better off out-of-work because of the changes.

Bosses are planning to pull out of daycare over the next two years. They say they will not withdraw from an area until an affordable, high-quality alternative is in place. Where that cannot be found, they will continue to act as ‘provider of last resort’.

Mike Livingstone, director of children’s services, said: "Our analysis shows there is already enough good quality and affordable daycare provision being provided by the private, voluntary and independent sector, so over time we will no longer need to provide it ourselves."

Remaining resources will be focussed on commissioning daycare for the most needy families and children requiring additional support.

That comes on top of the government pledge of 15 hours a week of free care, for all three and four-year-olds, which will continue to be provided through schools and the private and voluntary sectors.

Parents will also get a monthly ‘Baby Express’ newsletter, giving advice on child development.

The proposals will go before town hall scrutineers for approval next week and the executive will be asked to endorse them later this month.

Comments

Login or Register to comment

Great news.

Some parents need help, provided by SureStart, from help and advice on breastfeeding through to mental health support. Plus giving mothers and fathers somewhere to meet other people going through the same thing at the same time.

All this provided cheaply at one point, saving money down the line on social services and the NHS.

Report This Reply

Quote ..."Bosses are planning to pull out of day care over the next two years .."

Quote ..."Already enough provision ib private sector ... over time we will no longer need to provide it ourselves"

So whats been saved, the buildings, that they are going to move job centre + and lord knows what else into, I'm sure the breastfeeding mums will love that in your local Sure Start.

I can see it now the doorman will be asking signing on or lactating???? Priceless.

They wanted the services, the childcare not the Sure Start CONcept.

Report This Reply View reply

This is fantastic news.Well done to all involved.

Report This Reply

'The £3m cost of keeping the provision going will be met by moving other services – such as Jobcentre Plus, youth and midwifery services – into Sure Start buildings, allowing the council to close other sites.'

So it could be argued then, that these 'savage Tory cuts' will lead to a leaner, fitter & more efficient provision of services by the council.

I'm not arguing that but you could I suppose.

Report This Reply

Isnt it time we stopped funding playground and lunch time assistants at schools and centres like this and let the mums who use these centres and whose children stay for school lunches who arent employed be used as volunteers the salaries saved will Im sure fund after school activites and help fund sure start centres amd put back into underprivileged areas.

Report This Reply View all 7 replies

i am amazed that you have published this without all the fax, Sure Start building are to remain open, but there will be no provision's for children under 5 inside them, The so called out reach team of 52 people will only be working along side health, to support the work load of the health team, e.g under paid support working with complex families, out of the 4,700 people responded to questionnaires 68% requested that Manchester city council should remain as a provider for day care (what was the point in the consultation if they do not listen to the people of Manchester) . However plans to end council-run daycare for under-fives will go ahead, the issue still remains that children with special educational need's are not wanted by the private sector which will leave a big gap in support needed, parents will be told last about there day care centre closing, Mike Livingstone, director of children’s services, said: did say "Our analysis shows there is already enough good quality and affordable daycare provision". although the person doing the research is paid by MCC, there will be 100 job's in children's services once the reconstruction goes ahead. i do feel that MMC have wasted money and need to learn by there mistakes, But at what cost!!






Report This Reply

City centre read what I said. I said the mums who do not work. As for sacking people I didnt say that either. Natural wastage mean that people change jobs and empoloyment therefore let unemployed mums replace them on a volutary basis. If they are not working and sometimes claiming benefits they will not then be forced into work that is impractical when they have a young family ie; school holday care etc. Surely it makes sense, young mums with infants in nursery or school take these jobs so that when schools are closed they then have holidays with their children.

Report This Reply View reply