News

Opinion: Paul Taylor

Most of us have a pretty limited knowledge of ape behaviour.

You may have had your wing mirror removed by a truculent baboon in a safari park. You may have seen someone on You’ve Been Framed having their Strawberry Mivvi nicked by a Gibraltan macaque.

Other than that, you may think of most of our primate cousins as uncomplicated critters who spend half their time swinging through the trees and the other half scratching their backsides.

You certainly would not have credited the average chimpanzee with superhuman compassion.

But that all changes with the revelations surrounding Pansy, a chimp in her fifties, who died of old age at Blair Drummond Safari Park, near Stirling in Scotland. As Pansy’s life ebbed away, scientists kept video cameras running, capturing behaviour never before observed in a chimp group.

Pansy lay down in a nest and the group gathered round to groom and caress her. At the end, the apes crouched down to study her face intently, then shook her gently, perhaps checking for signs of life.

After her death, an adult female sat with Pansy and held her hand, and her daughter stayed with the body all night.

Here was proof that chimps – our nearest relative in the animal kingdom – are also capable of that complex human quality, empathy.

But is empathy such a given even for human beings?

Another bit of candid camera footage holds a devastating insight into animal behaviour.

On Sunday April 18 at 5.40am, a CCTV camera in the Jamaica district of Queens, New York, captured a woman walking along the pavement, followed by a man. What happened next was off-camera, but it is assumed that the man attacked the woman, and a 32-year old Guatemalan homeless man called Hugo Tale-Yax came to her aid.

The man is seen running back in the direction from which he came, followed seconds later by Hugo, who falls onto the pavement and lies, face down, in a growing pool of blood from several knife wounds in his chest.

It is well over an hour before anyone calls the emergency services, during which time 25 people walk past Hugo, look at him, but do nothing to help.

One man – with a lack of empathy that would shame a chimp – takes a picture of the fallen hero on his mobile phone. Another passer-by shakes Hugo, lifts his arm then walks away.

A wake was being held for Hugo today.

I was in conversation earlier this week with Malcolm Gladwell, a staff writer for the New Yorker magazine and an acclaimed author at the popular end of social science. Raised in Canada, he says he is ‘fascinated and appalled’ by the USA.

But he added: “New York is not America. New York is a principality, a duchy within the larger kingdom. It’s a fascinating place for both good and ill.”

He neglected to mention that New York can also sometimes be a place less civilised than the Planet Of The Apes.

Laughter is the best medicine ... for some

I AWAIT scientific proof that many a mickle makes a muckle, fine words butter no parsnips and that we should beware of Greeks bearing gifts.

But at least one old proverb seems to be true... laughter really is the best medicine.

A good chuckle unleashes the same chemical changes in the body as a bout of exercise, according to a researcher in California, who goes by the eminently titter-worthy name of Lee Berk.

It is tempting to think that, instead of going jogging, you could sling on a Ricky Gervais DVD. But before you embark on a ‘giggle yourself thin’ diet, you should know that the hormonal change which both laughter and exercise provokes in the body also enhances your appetite. What we need then is mirthful mass medication. Talking of which, Peter Kay last night launched the most concerted assault yet on the nation’s funny bones, with a tour which has sold 750,000 tickets at £35 each, totalling £26,250,000. There’s a man who is laughing for sure... all the way to the bank.

Comments

Login or Register to comment

I'm probably tempting fate here by stating this, but...

Watching the chimps' reaction and concern for their old, dying relative/friend, reminded me so much of the demise of my late mother, who died just last year.

The hand holding, concern for her breathing, making her comfortable, and the genuine compassion exhibited by these, our fellow primates, both saddened and gladdened me.

Saddened me, because I know how badly treated many of these creatures are, both in captivity and in the world.

Gladdened, because it is pleasing - even reassuring - to see that the world is not a two-dimensional entity, with (some) animals able to demonstrate how little - or far - 'man' has evolved. And the distance 'we' still have to travel.

I was incredibly touched.

Report This Reply

Laura - have to agree. It was a lump in the throat moment.

I also liked your post as it threw up similar memories of my own.

There you are, we don't have to be at loggerheads on every topic!

Report This Reply

When I started work in 1950 I was introduced to a man in his 70s still working who had been all over the world. Naively I said. What is it like abroad? He rolled his eyes. Not like here
If you fall down in the street in America or Russia people don't stop and help you like they do here.They just walk over you. I am not sure that still applies here.I would not like to take my chances.
There is a theory that souls are recycled. People claim they can trace people through history with the same characteristics. Right or wrong who knows. It just occurs to me that there has been such a massive increase in population from 2 billion in 1900 to nearly 7 billion now they must be having an awful job finding enough souls to go round which could account for the number of callous soulless people you come across.

Report This Reply

Even laughter can be brought down to earth by fellow humans because they don't like it. Just like the old lady who had the door slammed on her arm.

The idea is knowing how to do it in a largely negative world; being able to breeze it no matter what is in front of you. The world is largely messed up now,everyone or nearly everyone is at it; people are changing for the worse. Leaning how to blow hot most of the time. We can all laugh but its about keeping the mind happy all the time 99.9% hot and only 0.1% cold is allowed. Some blow hot for the camera then blow cold the rest of the time 99% cold 0.1% hot isn't good enough.

Understanding the world and peoples minds goes some way to a relaxed mind. You have to find the right pattern of thinking and it should be all good.

I'm not perfect but the mind has ways of of seeing things for the better for oneself. All you do is apply the thinking to others and see what happens. It may not work for everyone because some may be missing certain emotions, maybe some need certain emotions teasing out. Its knowing how to work to tease them out with the right thinking,perhaps.

One day I might need a guinea pig. I am my own guinea pig and its working for me.

Report This Reply

I'll say it again. Lack of empathy is the root cause of many of our own problems in society.

Report This Reply

The modern world is largely suppressing the right emotions. People find it hard to deal with.

Work related stress? pushed to the limits by juggling work and people.

Stress is the elastic band that you have to stop from snapping.

Report This Reply