Neglect 'significantly' contributed to the death of an 11-year-old boy from an asthma attack at school, an inquest jury has ruled.
Sam Linton was left to sit in a corridor at Offerton High School, Stockport, struggling to breathe. He was wheezy and continuously using his inhaler – but the school failed to call an ambulance. He was eventually taken to Stepping Hill hospital but by then he could not be saved.
An inquest jury ruled Sam's death was a result of natural causes but it could have been prevented if prompt emergency treatment had been sought.
They took just under two hours to return their verdict and highlighted the failures of unnamed members of staff and medical procedures at the school.
The jury said Offerton High School had:
- failed to implement an integrated asthma policy in school
- failed to ensure members of staff were trained to deal with children having an asthma attack
- failed to keep an up-to-date health care plan
- failed to monitor Sam's condition when they saw him using his inhaler in the corridor between 12.20pm and 3.15pm on December 4, 2007.
All of these failures were found to have caused or significantly contributed to Sam's death.
Fighting back tears Sam's mother, Karen Linton, said: ““I'm angry, I'm very angry and I don't know how to express it at the moment.”
In a statement outside court family representative Jonathan Betts, or Irwin Mitchell solicitors, said the school had shown 'a complete absence of common sense in the event of a child suffering from an asthma attack'.
He said: “The fact that no one called an ambulance during the hours that Sam was suffering from a prolonged asthma attack is astounding and deeply troubling.
“The inquest has confirmed our worst fears about the way Samuel's asthma attack was handled at school. When you send your children to school you believe they will be looked after and cared for. Their safety and welfare is very important and we want to let others know that if they have concerns like this they should speak up before it's too late.
“We did everything we could to protect him and he will always be in our hearts.”
Karen and husband Paul added in a statement: “Samuel was a wonderful son and his loss has been devastating.
“The inquest highlighted what happened at school that day and the thought that his death may have been prevented is too much to bear.”
A spokesman for Stockport Council and Offerton High School said: "The death of a young person is an occasion of profound sadness and we extend our deepest sympathy to Samuel's parents and family.
"The school and local authority will continue to take steps to address the issues identified from Samuel's death.
“We are now considering the inquest verdict and the recommendations of the coroner as a matter of urgency and will take all necessary actions identified and needed.”
You need Flash player 8+ and JavaScript enabled to view this video.
Tweet

Showing comments 1 to 25 and replies | View All
andy (17/03/2010 at 20:10)
My deepest sympathy to Samuel's family, I cannot even begin to imagine how they must be feeling.
Alan (17/03/2010 at 20:35)
My thoughts are with the lads family, such a sad loss. R.I.P.
Knowsleyman, Paphos (17/03/2010 at 20:44)
blizzard, Midlands (17/03/2010 at 20:46)
Esso Blue. Dark Flow/Dark Energy/Dark Matter/ Invisible, Manchester (17/03/2010 at 20:55)
Is It Me? (17/03/2010 at 21:07)
Kayo Niko (17/03/2010 at 21:08)
julie broughton (17/03/2010 at 21:08)
cazza cazza (17/03/2010 at 21:17)
I have a family member at a primary school in Stockport and have experienced at 1st hand how little many school staff know about asthma. I hope the recommendations are put into place ASAP .
scram, manchester (17/03/2010 at 21:18)
As a childcare worker I took personal responsibility to attend an NHS training course to enable me to respond to this common medical emergency, after witnessing my own child struggling to breathe with Asthma. EVERY person who works with children should know how to respond safely... do you???
We seem to be met with so many arrogant 'professionals' who are putting their own beliefs before the lives of others, humility is an admirable quality that we all need to learn.
emma (17/03/2010 at 21:28)
steve wilson (17/03/2010 at 23:17)
steak, Manchester (17/03/2010 at 23:40)
Bemused of Tameside., Dukinfield (17/03/2010 at 23:52)
The fact that a high school did not deal with Samuel's attack properly is very very worrying.
Deepest, heartfelt sympathy to the Linton family and a huge what on this holy earth were you thinking to the authority whose care he was entrusted to.
My heart goes to you Karen, Paul and all your family. x
SteveDB (18/03/2010 at 00:01)
Jamie Taylor (18/03/2010 at 00:44)
TheLimey, Southern California (18/03/2010 at 02:56)
thoughtful, East of Manchester (18/03/2010 at 08:51)
We have heard the calls from the lefties about corporate manslaughter, but this does not extend to the public sector - it should do. It is difficult to believe that an adult could disregard the pleas of other children, to help or call an ambulance, and such a failure to follow proceedures, should have seen those responsible locked up for a long time.
But it's the public sector, and as per usual the no blame culture means that there hasn't even been any disciplinary action. No doubt we see some public sector sycophant sitting down in front of cameras to say the same old script - "lessons have been learned", "working practices changed", "implementation of new policies", "No excuses".
These phrases have been heard so regularly at public sector reviews/reports that they have become risible, and of course despite all the bluster they are in essence - meaningless. Nothing ever changes, which is why we continue to need them.
Red Manc, yes we do exist, Salford (18/03/2010 at 09:42)
local_lass, Burnage (18/03/2010 at 09:46)
You shouldn't need policies specific for asthma or any other illness. Children diagnosed with asthma shouldn't necessarily need any different reaction to any other person suffering with breathing difficulties.
Surely its obvious - a child struggling to breath and you call their parents and/or an ambulance depending on the severity. Either of which would have resulted in much earlier intervention in this case.
She's a Weapon..., Manchester (18/03/2010 at 09:57)
How absolutely stupid do you have to be to see a child with asthma struggling to breathe and not do anything about it? Not only that, but the children here knew something was wrong and yet the situation was still ignored.
If my child went to that school I'd seriously think about whether I'd want to entrust the care of them to somebody who is obviously an idiot. In fact, that's an insult to idiots but I really am struggling to find words to describe this woman. I wouldn't go so far as to say evil but she's certainly incredibly arrogant and that arrogance has cost a child his life.
I'm totally in agreement with the comment about corporate manslaughter. If Sam was in work experience and this happened, the company would be hauled over the coals - this woman should face the same fate.
blueballs (18/03/2010 at 10:20)
moss side brian (18/03/2010 at 10:31)
no accident procedures were in place,he was told to see a first aider,who sent him home on his own,the school did not record the accident..luckily in this case my son was ok ..but i had a meeting with the headmaster and advised him the procedures that should be in place and what should have been done to protect the safety and welfare of his pupils,but as usual in these cases when you advise or question these arrogant headmasters and teachers( who are so called educated)..they dont want to know...i reported it to the local authority and the health and safety executive and they ignored me as well. ???? ..whilst these future teacher and headteacher are at university they should do a extra year being educated on safety and welfare of pupils and common sense which most of them lack.
my deepest sympathy go out to samuels parents and family and i hope someone is prosecuted for this..so as not to happen again in future
Blunt (18/03/2010 at 10:35)
PW, Manchester (18/03/2010 at 10:50)
I too have felt so weak that even standing up is impossible. How that lad must have felt is too awful to contemplate. Grey face and blue lips would surely alarm anyone.