News

Opinion: Paul Taylor

Paul Taylor

AS a 12-year old, I would often go around with a large sheath knife fixed to my belt. It was to help me do the things 12-year-olds did back then, like whittling home-made spears, or perfecting the art of dagger-throwing.

Today, the very idea of a 12-year old buying a knife would set health and safety bells ringing. Buying a small multitool in TK Maxx a few weeks ago, I was asked – at the ripe old age of 52 – whether I was 18 or over. The assistant confimed she had to ask this question even when it made absolutely no sense to do so.

I thought of my sheath knife, the air rifle I got for my 14th birthday, my bow and arrow, the various rope swings, the expeditions through a rat-infested disused railway tunnel, the lighted bangers we threw like grenades, the times we jumped off waterfalls into Pennine streams and all the trees I climbed – and occasionally fell out of – when I heard about a new book from America.

Fifty Dangerous Things (You Should Let Your Children Do) by Gever Tulley is an encouragement to us to allow children to explore by means of calculated risk. They include licking a 9-volt battery (honestly, who hasn’t?), breaking glass, burning things with a magnifying glass, deconstructing an appliance, squashing pennies on a railway track and learning dramatic sword-fighting.

Some of the “dangerous” things seem pretty tame. Number 41 in the list is “cross town on public transit”, which reminds me that by the age of ten I was daily catching two buses each way to school. Others, like number 39, “cook something in the dishwasher”, and number 46, “superglue your fingers together”, were not available to me because dishwashers and superglue were not around when I was a kid (though I feel sure I would have glued my fingers together, given the opportunity).

Even so I was able to tick off 35 of the 50 “dangerous” things on the list.

My own two boys – now 18 and 16 – have never been wrapped in cotton wool, but it’s unlikely they would have notched up as many as 35 of the 50. They have had ample opportunity for broken bones through skateboarding, and there was a swelling of fatherly pride when they dug a potentially lethal tunnel into a grassy embankment near our home. But more of their childhood has been spent indoors.

That is children’s choice today. Research has just found that youngsters between eight and 18 spend an average of seven hours a day in “electronic life”, using phones, iPods, TV and video games. And given the choice between a PlayStation and whittling a spear, I’m sure I would have made the same choice.

But there is more to the risk-averse climate of today than just the enticements of gadgetry. Paranoid parenting has undoubtedly stopped kids notching up as many of those 50 “dangerous” activities.

Perhaps this has been a reaction to the fact that my generation of parents is bringing up kids in the safest era human beings have ever known. Unlike those who grew up earlier in the 20th century, world war – and therefore bombs raining out of the sky - was not a consideration for us.

Old enemies like smallpox, polio, measles and the like had long been thwarted by public health. Growing up with “clunk-click” and all the other safety messages, we came to believe that almost all risk could be legislated out of our lives. And having dealt with the big things, the small things assumed huge importance. “Stranger danger” looms large. Swine flu – at which previous generations would have shrugged their shoulders – caused disproportionate worry.

We even start to fret about how our children play. We replace the Tarmac in the playground with bouncy rubber, and then we ask: should our children be climbing that tree, digging that tunnel or camping out in the garden?

The answer is yes. They may learn something.

Comments

Login or Register to comment

Steamed/Poached fish a la dishwisher is fantastic,and one has clean plates and cutlery ready for use on the fish.

Report This Reply

Ah happy days - the third paragraph is pretty much what I got up to, although i didnt have a large sheath knife. More a old blunt penknife that was neither use or ornament!

Report This Reply

The City centre is full of youths, skate boarding,skating,base jumping. They come from all over. One worries what they are doing to the pavements, but they are enjoying themselves and learning amazing skills.
I was in Lisbon a few years ago.One square was full of competitive courses. Well organised,but I wonder if they are not best left to organise themselves. Perhaps someone could sponsor them, for annual competitions

Report This Reply

At last a sensible, well-written Opinion. Brilliant and very true.

Report This Reply

Those were the days!

As a ‘kid’ the only drinks available (apart from tap water and milk) were laced with sugar and e-numbers.

Our parents put us in cots adorned with lead based paints.

Schools had Physical Education programs which didn’t exclude anyone! Remember the fat, wheezy boy with an inhaler? He was told to stop moaning and drag his backside around the ‘cross country’ course regardless of the weather just like everyone else!

A nutritious meal was classed as ‘sausage and mash’ or home made ‘meat and potato pie’. No a free range, organic Tofu in sight!

Being allowed to drink the head off my dads beer, but getting a ‘clout’ for stealing a bottle of old QC sherry (that no one drinks) out of the cabinet to share with my mates.

You still played competitive sports at school. If you didn’t make the team, you were told “TOUGH, live with it as life will be full of disappointments”!

Building dens, camping out and trying to start fires using two sticks of wood (which never worked).

Still playing ‘War’ or ‘Cowboys and Indians’ at 13 and no one thinking your immature.

When we fell off our bikes and hurt ourselves, we were shoved straight back on them and no teachers wanted your parents locked up because of the ensuing bruising on your knees!

The only fast food was ‘Fish and Chips’, a real treat once in a while!

Having respect for the local ‘bobby’, he knew your mother and father and he would give you a ‘clip’ if you stepped out of line.

Setting fire to the school chapel with a discarded cigarette, when caught this was put down to ‘mischievous behavior’ not vandalism. Being ‘cricket batted’ on the back side 6 times for smashing a window in the school pavilion. Parents not told and no black mark against me because teachers had the ability (and rights) to deal with issues in house!

Pen knives, standard issue for boys, yet no one got stabbed then?

Those were the days.............................................................

Report This Reply

I've still got my 6 inch sheath knife I won as a prize for inspection points when I was in the Scouts at the age of 12. The Scoutmaster took me to the sports shop to make my choice. I haven't handed it in on any amnesty, and won't.

Again, I don't remember any fellow Scouts being stabbed, although there were some mishaps in games of 'Split the Kipper'. We were told to wear steel toe-caps to avoid problems in that department. Different world altogether - AND BETTER!!!

Report This Reply

For once I actually agree, kids these days are too often wrapped in cotton wool and not allowed to go out and just be kids.

Report This Reply

When I was a kid I liked to sneak into the church and fill the candle displays with candles and light them all. The displays looked so nice all lit up.

Report This Reply