NURSES tried to send home a dying man who had slipped into a coma - telling his carers he was just sleeping.
Medics caring for Ronald Eaton at the Manchester Royal Infirmary even attempted to dress him for discharge before they realised he was unconscious.
A carer who accompanied Mr Eaton to hospital said she raised the alarm when she was unable to wake Mr Eaton despite 'jiggling' him and lifting his eyelids.
Mr Eaton, known as Ronnie, died three days later after never regaining consciousness.
Coroner Nigel Meadows said it 'beggared belief' that the nurses did not notice that the 76-year-old was critically ill.
Blunders
Mr Meadows blasted the hospital over a catalogue of blunders that contributed to his death.
He is to now to bring the case to the notice of Health Secretary Andy Burnham and the Chief Medical Officer, Sir Liam Donaldson, because he wants the lessons learned to be 'for national attention'.
Mr Eaton, who had significant learning difficulties, was admitted to the MRI on May 24 this year after collapsing at his home in Levenshulme.
His carer warned nurses he did not like bed rails and they should not be used.
Despite that rails WERE put around his cot – and Mr Eaton was found on the floor at 4.30am the next morning after having tried to climb out.
He suffered a 3-4cm cut to his head.
He was transferred to another ward the next morning, but regular checks on his condition were not carried out.
It was only at 9am that his carer, Laura Platt, noticed that he could not be roused.
Sleeping
She told ward staff – who dismissed her concern and said Mr Eaton was just sleeping.
It was only at 12 noon when a nurse who was attempting to dress him to go home realised he had slipped into a coma.
He was transferred to the specialist neurological unit at Salford Royal Hospital but later died.
At an inquest yesterday Mr Meadows recorded a catalogue of blunders that contributed to Mr Eaton's death.
He ruled that hospital staff:
Dr John Simpson, a consultant at the hospital, admitted that 'without question' doctors should have made regular checks on Mr Eaton after he fell out of bed.
He added: "There is no record of that in the notes."
The two nurses involved admitted they had never read the basic guidelines on the treatment of head injuries.
Lessons
And although the hospital insisted that lessons had been learned since Mr Eaton's death, the same nurses admitted in court that they had still not read the guidelines - six months later.
Mr Eaton's carers wept and mouthed 'thank you' to the jury after they passed a narrative verdict.
The jury found that 'inadequate knowledge' and 'failures of communication' by hospital staff had contributed to Mr Eaton's death.
A spokesman for Central Manchester University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust said: "We are extremely sorry for the death of Mr Eaton. We admit there were a number of failings in his care and we have the deepest regret that our normal high standard of care was not upheld."
They added that staff were being given training in the treatment of head injuries and the care of patients with learning disabilities.
Tweet

Showing comments 1 to 25 and replies | View All
citizen x, manchester (28/11/2009 at 13:55)
Stevedore, Quayside (28/11/2009 at 14:04)
macintosh, Alberta Canada (28/11/2009 at 14:23)
bren 2, bolton (28/11/2009 at 14:32)
Donald, manchester (28/11/2009 at 14:55)
I've still got a 'Free Deirdre Rachid' sticker on my truck (28/11/2009 at 14:56)
Englisc Stannes, North Manchester (28/11/2009 at 16:22)
Opinion Man (28/11/2009 at 16:23)
Amounderness Lad, Caithness (28/11/2009 at 19:26)
Who cares about common humanity when you might be criticised for not being able to tick all the right boxes to meet the great god of targets.
northred, prestwich (28/11/2009 at 19:35)
Rick Jenks, Bury (28/11/2009 at 20:00)
Rick Jenks, Bury (28/11/2009 at 20:02)
Britt/Canada (28/11/2009 at 21:01)
So did the so called nurses that are paid for by the tax payers to look after people when they are sick& what happened to the oath they take,,, Is the above statement some kind of spin doctoring "Learning difficulties",,,what the hell as it got to do with the treatment this senior citizen received sounds like the two -----s involved just did not care & wanted him gone,Both should be fired along with the supervisor who was in charge of this fiasco.
What is unbelievable is they did not know the basic treatment for head injuries,what kind of nurse-ing schools did they attend,sounds like some scene out of a "Carry on" movie accept this is a deadly scenerio that could effect anyone. FIRE THEM FOR THEIR TOTAL INCOMPETENCE!!! & why are their names not published???
meldroo, Oldham (28/11/2009 at 21:26)
meldroo, Oldham (28/11/2009 at 21:26)
Ran Droid, Manchester (28/11/2009 at 21:38)
Much as I hate to use the phrase, nursing needs to get back to basics and be about patient care first and foremost, not a political fix or a panicky solution to the working time regulations meaning a sudden massive reduction in hours for higher qualified staff.
Worse, any party pointing out the flaws in the NHS gets jumped on by Labour as being anti-NHS, if they put as much effort into fixing their messes as they do trying to spin out of them we wouldn't have the problems!
Hellas (28/11/2009 at 21:48)
If ever there was a need for a huge flashing sign stating 'BRING BACK MATRONS', it's now! How long does the NHS have to put up with poor standards in nursing and hygiene? Perhaps there's a death knell sounding for the future of this service - espeically with the closure of so many hospitals, A+E's, baby units, etc; the exodus of quality-trained English nurses and the influx of poorly-trained (but much cheaper) immigrant nurses. I would never, ever have a go at the nurses as they do a thankless, demanding, poorly-paid job, but something needs to be done NOW!
Perhaps the time has come to privatise all hospitals and this should stop people coming over to this country, bringing their family and getting free service. If ou have a job, healthcare is provided by the company. If you're out of work, then you earn credits until you get a job - no credits, no service. Can you imagine the uproar there would have been if this poor soul had been of a different persuasion!
By the way, was there any need at all to report this poor soul had 'learning difficulties'? Does it add to the story or take away from it if this unnecessary piece is omitted? Unnecessary journalism.
......and Solskjaer has won it! (29/11/2009 at 00:55)
This beggers belief
WARREN RUSSELL (29/11/2009 at 08:47)
ROBERT, HONG KONG
Tramtraveller, Bury (29/11/2009 at 10:09)
Mad Welsh Scotsman, Cadishead (29/11/2009 at 10:26)
Before critisising the nurses, look at what their bosses are doing to them piling more and more work, plus they have to take sh*t from drunks as well.
Nurses are more qualified these days, they used to do HND's but now they have to do a degree, a medical doctor is not the same as a PHD, and nurses take on some roles that traditionally, doctors used to do.
It's sad, what has happened and I would like to give my condolences to his family but please do not place the entire blame on the front line staff, look further up the ladder to the bean counters and pen pushers.
Luise, Sydney (29/11/2009 at 12:07)
to the point, bury (29/11/2009 at 12:17)
My wife was a nurse, 5 years training then a qualification, after exams to achieve SEN grade.
Head injury care training is so basic, even at first aid level.
Were they ‘nurses’ or auxiliaries if they were qualified then we are in deep trouble.
manchester girl (29/11/2009 at 13:33)
years ago nurses would hold your hand,wash you and make beds, that way they would notice any decline sooner.
my sympathy to Mr Eatons carers for his appauling treatment
mike356 (29/11/2009 at 15:41)