GORDON Brown has been told to bring our troops home by the sister of a Manchester soldier killed in the War on Terror.
Karla Ellis, 28, told the Prime Minister the Government's strategy in Afghanistan was not working and instead called for Britain to pull out of the war-torn country.
Her brother,
Private Lee Ellis, 23, a father of one, was killed by a roadside bomb while serving with the 2nd Battalion, The Parachute Regiment, in Iraq in February 2006.
Ms Ellis, who is now active with a number of groups raising cash for injured soldiers and their families, spoke at a question-and- answer session with Mr Brown with a live audience, organised by Key 103, a radio station based in Manchester.
"How many of our under-equipped soldiers have to die before the powers that be do the right thing, instead of trying to save face, and bring them home?" Ms Ellis said.
The Prime Minister said he too wanted to see troops return home but, since 2001, three-quarters of terrorist plots against the UK had been traced back to the border area of Afghanistan or Pakistan.
Weapons
"I want to get our troops home as quickly as possible," he said. "The way we can do it is to train up the Afghans themselves. The Taliban have access to weapons they can use indiscriminately against you or me on the streets of cities in Britain. What we are facing in Afghanistan is an insurgency, it is guerilla warfare."
Mr Brown said the country needed a stronger army and police, and corruption had to be tackled and the recent election, beset by claims of vote-fixing, was "less than perfect".
Ms Ellis, from Wythenshawe, Manchester, told him: "I don't think that strategy will work. You can't trust these people."
Mr Brown told her that, by getting UK troops to train the local army and police, they are helping the Afghans themselves to defeat al Qaida and the Taliban.
Tweet
Dead soldier's sister tells PM to pull troops out
November 05, 2009
Private Lee Ellis was killed by a roadside bomb while serving with the 2nd Battalion, The Parachute Regiment, in Iraq in February 2006.

Showing comments 1 to 16 and replies | View All
vinay, rochdale (05/11/2009 at 21:47)
Stella Ridgway (05/11/2009 at 21:49)
Stella Ridgway; Greater Manchester Stop The War Coalition
Local lad, outsidethebox (05/11/2009 at 22:24)
Joe Pub, Manchester (06/11/2009 at 03:13)
With all this training whats to prevent these persons to turn on our troops.
Lovable Blue Frog. Any pond life around here by any chance?, Manchester (06/11/2009 at 10:27)
The issue is does Al queida and the taliban have an ideology whereby they just don't want interference in their back yard as they call it, or do they have a plan for dominance in the long term?. It seems they are against capitalism?
vanessa arif (06/11/2009 at 11:26)
Jiggerz, Mancunia (06/11/2009 at 12:40)
PW, Manchester (06/11/2009 at 13:11)
The answer to terrorism is in strengthening our borders, and vigorously vetting those who want to come here, throwing the bad ones out - you know the ones who want their babies to be suicide bombers etc.
Lovable Blue Frog. Any pond life around here by any chance?, Manchester (06/11/2009 at 14:27)
If you are in an Army that is going out to fight for an unjust cause basically glory hunting mercenaries who like to tell tall tales, then you don’t get any sympathy.
Parents of people who think of joining Armed forces should have the wisdom to know whether their country is largely based on colonialism and oppression, and if you are aware that they fight unjust wars don’t come crying.
Vote for David, anywhere else but manchester please (06/11/2009 at 21:40)
ENGINEER, Heywood (06/11/2009 at 23:34)
I 'm not Jeremy Kyle or Jeremy Springer or Columbo. I 'm just lipstick, powder and paint, Manchester (07/11/2009 at 11:03)
6/11/2009 at 23:34
You have got it wrong! where did I say that the people fighting for this country today are mercenaries.
Think about it hard, if you fight as a defender you are a hero.
If you fight as an oppressive force picking on innocent people and looting under the shirt and tie brigade then you are the biggest coward in the world and it is people like that that I would have no problem putting down to rest in my pond.
I implied the two sides of the coin scenario and gave my view where I stand with cowards.
I am not brainwashed it is that simple.
Fozz (08/11/2009 at 12:55)
cutiepie, Manchester (09/11/2009 at 08:05)
Angie33 , Manchester (09/11/2009 at 09:24)
citycentre, manchester (09/11/2009 at 12:05)
Not really. I think the argument for withdrawal from Afghanistan would be that the British troops there seem to be attempting to achieve a number of, often contadictory, aims (Is it defeat the Taliban/Al-Queda, stop the drug trade, bring democracy, improve the lot of the ordinary Afghan?) and are actually achieving none of them at great cost.
The argument for not leaving would be that non of the aims have been met, and an immediate withdrawal following by a Taliban resurgence would allow them to claim that they had defeated the mighty UK and US armies.