NEARLY £3m of taxpayers' money was spent by council bosses in Greater Manchester on mobile phones for councillors and staff last year.
The M.E.N. can reveal the full extent of their bills today using figures obtained from the region's 10 local authorities under the Freedom of Information Act.
Every council in the region spent at least £154,000 on the mobile phone calls and handsets of more than 25,900 councillors and staff.
Taxpayers in Manchester faced the largest bill, with the council spending more than £736,000, which included more than £539,000 on voice calls and more than £141,000 on data sticks and mobile internet services including Blackberrys.
One council, Oldham, paid £810,973 to its mobile phone supplier. But £539,000 of this was a one-off grant for a `Computers for Pupils' project - to provide computers and broadband for disadvantaged children.
It said £271,973 was spent on phones held by staff. Fourteen of its councillors had Blackberry mobiles.
Bolton council's £354,399 bill included more than £4,900 on phone repairs and more than £1,600 on accessories.
Salford council said it had claimed back around £14,500 of its £307,000 bill from staff who had made personal calls.
News of the figures has led to calls for town hall bosses to impose tighter controls on mobile phone use and to ensure they seek `value for money' from mobile phone companies.
Councils' responses
All 10 authorities have defended mobile phones as a `necessary tool' for helping officers and councillors communicate..
Coun Bernard Priest, from Manchester council, said `effective communications' were `critical' to the way services were delivered. He said the council `regularly reviews' the cost of mobile phones and has guidelines to prevent misuse.
Bolton council said mobiles were a `necessary tool' for a `large number' ofstaff. A spokeswoman said the bill had been reduced from the previous year and that the issuing and use of mobiles was `closely monitored'.
Alan Westwood, from Salford Council, said mobiles were `crucial' to the council's work and that its call rates were `discounted'. He said mobiles `saved time and money'.
A spokeswoman for Tameside council said it had recently negotiated a new contract, which would save on monthly fees and call charges. The council said its councillors paid their own phone bills.
Pam Smith, from Rochdale council, said mobile phones were `vital'. She added: "We regularly review contracts to make sure we're getting the best possible value for money."
A spokesman for Stockport council said it `always strives' to get the `best possible deal' and to keep costs to a minimum.
Wigan council said mobiles allow councillors and staff to work more `effectively'. A spokesman said: "Requests for mobiles have to be justified operationally."
Mark Sanders, from Bury council, said mobiles are provided to front-line staff and those who work away from the office or out of hours. He said contracts and spending were constantly reviewed to ensure `best value for taxpayers'.
Coun Alex Williams, from Trafford council, said having staff available on mobiles benefited residents.
He said many staff with mobiles were based in the community, adding that the council regularly sought tenders for its mobile phone contract.
Coun Lynne Thompson, from Oldham council, said all expenditure was `monitored closely' to provide `value for money'. She said phones were only given to staff who needed them and that its phone contract was `good value'.
Taxpayers' Alliance
Mark Wallace, campaign director of the Taxpayers' Alliance, said the £3m bill was `staggering'.
He said: "There may be a case for some staff requiring phones, but these figures suggest the number has got out of hand.
"With taxpayers suffering because of the recession, local councils have got to start tightening their belts and rein in this kind of spending.
"This is a massive bill and I'm sure the public in Greater Manchester would like to be reassured that it is being properly audited."
Tweet

Showing comments 1 to 13 and replies | View All
Deejay, Bury (25/09/2009 at 07:59)
If you look at the average mobile phone bill for an individual being £40 per month - or £480 then these figures don't seem so unrealistic. Are we really saying that £30 a year for use of a blackberry is excessive??? Mobile phones are essential to communicate immediately and allow people to do their jobs. Who in business doesn't have one today? As for blackberries and data sticks - if you expect a workforce to be mobile and work rather than being desk tied - then £8 per month is hardly a lot to ask for someone to use a blackberry.
I know - lets take anything off them that causes us, the taxpayer, to have to pay - so no mobile phones, no computers, no vehicles to collect waste etc etc - How quickly do you think people will complain?
Rt Hon Dr Rev MC Spanner MP QC FCA FRICS JP OK (25/09/2009 at 08:22)
He said: "There may be a case for some staff requiring phones, but these figures suggest the number has got out of hand."
I have a lot of time for the Taxpayers Alliance but on what basis is this staggering. I work in a business with staff and our bills are £600k per annum. This is hardly wasteful. Are the Taxpayers Alliance suggesting that Councils use plastic cups & string or carrier pigeons
Henry Piggot-Smythe, Prestbury (25/09/2009 at 09:06)
Jay B, oldham (25/09/2009 at 10:10)
sounds like council staff get other perks as well.
Pot, Higher Blackley (25/09/2009 at 10:33)
Jiggerz, Mancunia (25/09/2009 at 12:13)
Wes Brown (25/09/2009 at 13:22)
They never get rid of dumped cars, pot holes, broken street lamps or rubbish quickly - if they didn't have mobile phones, are they saying there would be a worse delay?!
Most companies now offer free calls and texts, can't council staff use their own phone to send a free text or a quick free call? Or even encourage staff to use their old phone for work?
I wonder what the mountain of phone chargers looks like ..... LOL!! Probably will be a work of art in URBIS before you know it!
moaning bugger, reddish (25/09/2009 at 15:31)
laddy, manchester (25/09/2009 at 16:30)
needs no excuse to use money unwisely. They've been doing for god knows how many years
salfordrat (25/09/2009 at 23:41)
Joe Pub, Manchester (26/09/2009 at 14:30)
Plastic cups and string would be to technical for these people, they will be wondering how to plug the in, never mind it would be amusing watching the try.
Joe Pub, Manchester (26/09/2009 at 14:39)
Plastic cups and string would be to technical for these people, they will be wondering how to plug them in, never mind it would be amusing watching them try.
Council Employee, Greater Manchester (28/09/2009 at 11:50)
I was given a mobile phone when I started at the council 6 years ago. Nokia 3310- you know the one- very popular in the late 1990's or early 2000's. Most of my colleagues have the same handset still. I never used it as it would mean carrying two phones around, so I choose to use my own mobile for the few times I have needed to use a phone whilst out of the office. I know a lot of my colleagues do the same. I've never claimed for my work calls on my mobile because it would be petty. I also don't claim my occasional tram fare or car park ticket for the same reason. I just want to get on with my job without filling in forms to claim back bits and bobs here and there. Maybe I should as I have just been informed that my well-below than national average wage is going to be reduced by 1500 pounds.