A MOTHER-of-three died in 'an incredible mishap' when she was hit by a shard of glass from a bottle thrown by a family friend.
Neil McNulty, who was out celebrating his 19th birthday, threw the bottle towards a pub doorman but it smashed against a pillar and flying glass severed Emma O'Kane's carotid artery and jugular vein.
Emma, 27, a mother of three who used to work as a barmaidĀ at theĀ pub in Heywood, near Rochdale, with her boyfriend who, ironically, was also celebrating his birthday.
She collapsed in a pool of blood and died later despite the efforts of hospital staff to save her life.
McNulty was later arrested and admitted he had known Emma and her family since he was a child and had grown up with her sister.
He told police he was 'deeply upset and devastated' that his actions may have caused the death of someone he knew.
Now McNulty - who had no previous convictions - is awaiting sentence after pleading guilty at Manchester Crown Court to the manslaughter of Emma who had three children, Reece, aged six, Jack, two and one-year-old Ellie-Mai.
His plea of not guilty to murder was accepted by the Crown after Mr David Steer QC, prosecuting told the court that Emma's death was 'both tragic and unpredictable'.
Mr Steer said it was accepted there was no intention to kill and the plea to manslaughter was accepted after considering the case with Emma's family, the police and senior members of the CPS.
Mr Steer said: "We have weighed in the balance the overall demeanour of the defendant, the level of violence before throwing the bottle, the fact he never attempted to use the bottle as a weapon prior to throwing it and, moreover, he did not break it before throwing it."
He said the odds of Emma suffering the injuries in the way she did were 'heavily stacked' and the reasons behind the Crown's decision had been explained to her parents and her partner, who tried desperately to help when she was injured.
McNulty, of Peel Lane, Heywood, was remanded in custody until April 7 but Judge Michael Henshell warned him the 'inevitable' sentence would be custodial one.
The judge had heard how Emma was tragically killed while out with her boyfriend, Michael Shepherd who was celebrating his 38th birthday.
They were in the Queen Anne Hotel, on Market Street, Heywood in the early hours of December 27 when a man who was injured and bleeding was turned away from the pub by a doorman.
McNulty then joined in the incident and eventually the bar manager and two doormen went outside.
McNulty started shouting threats before stepping back into the road and throwing a bottle.
One of the doormen standing next to the open door ducked and the bottle flew passed him, smashed against a pillar and a piece of broken glass hit Emma in the neck.
After Emma's death her heartbroken boyfriend described her as 'an angel' and said they planned to get married next year. "I can't believe she's gone", said Mr Shepherd.
"Something like this just doesn't happen to someone like her. He has taken away a wonderful woman.
"She was the love of my life and kind hearted. She really was an angel and now my soul mate's been taken away I wonder what we're all going to do without her."
You need Flash player 8+ and JavaScript enabled to view this video.
Tweet



Showing comments 1 to 25 and replies | View All
andanotherthing, Mcr (17/03/2009 at 12:27)
dessie, manchester (17/03/2009 at 12:32)
Peregrine Spanswick (17/03/2009 at 12:40)
Mad Welsh Scotsman, Cadishead (17/03/2009 at 12:48)
Bean of the yard, stalybridge (17/03/2009 at 12:51)
Mad Welsh Scotsman, Cadishead (17/03/2009 at 12:59)
Pushkin (17/03/2009 at 13:16)
Bejjy ex Salford now Malta, Malta (17/03/2009 at 13:26)
Given that McNulty has pleaded guilty to the charge of manslaughter he will probably get less than the 5/6 years that you suggest. And whats the betting that before sentencing, McNulty's lawyer (probably paid for by legal aid) will relate in mitigation to the sentencing judge some tear jerking story about what a terrible upbrining, etc, etc, and how the education system has failed McNulty. As usual, everyone and everything is to blame rather than the culprit.
jem8805 (17/03/2009 at 13:29)
cusco, sale (17/03/2009 at 14:07)
20 YEARS TAKE THE PRISONER DOWN - NEXT CASE!
Bobby Johnstone's left kneecap, Hong Kong (17/03/2009 at 14:12)
Jay B, oldham (17/03/2009 at 14:15)
making an example and lock him up and giving him no comforts at all!
prison is prison! not a holiday camp!
Angie33 , Manchester (17/03/2009 at 15:02)
The first real problems I noticed were in the early 80's.16yr olds leaving school were unable to get jobs or training.Next thing as they couldnt contribute to the household they were thrown out and ended up in council flats.Thousands just to get some benefits and flat would be unoccupied or they and their mates lived there causing havoc all around.Along with this went drinking on the streets.
At that time although I lived on a large estate I only ever knew 1 person who had been a heroin addict.Within a few years there were many.
Some of those 16 yr olds never worked as by the time they were older they were addicts or in prison.Its gone on from there.
Sarah_Sarah, Oldham (17/03/2009 at 15:08)
dessie, manchester (17/03/2009 at 15:12)
'he didnt mean to throw a bottle through the pub window!!!'
you may aswell say that he should walk away with no punishment!! throw the key away and if you do the crime do the time in my book
Ms B, Manchester (17/03/2009 at 15:14)
Formerly Aussie Blue - Back In Manc, UK (17/03/2009 at 15:23)
Would he be so devastated if he had killed the poor doorman he has agreed he was aiming at?
No sympathy at all.
Angie33 , Manchester (17/03/2009 at 15:24)
steve grimsley, Macclesfield (17/03/2009 at 15:26)
andanotherthing, Mcr (17/03/2009 at 15:33)
A few points. He is not a boy, 18 makes you an adult. A deliberate action, lobbing a bottle in to a crowded pub, is not an accident. Punishment is what you get for doing wrong....you get it?
Bejjy ex Salford now Malta, Malta (17/03/2009 at 15:36)
You have just given every legally aided paid for lawyer in Greater Manchester a tear jerking plea of mitigation that they can put to a sentencing judge before the judge passes sentence on yet another thug such as McNulty who has murdered, manslaughtered, raped or violently assaulted someone.
Sarah_Sarah, Oldham
"it was an awful ACCIDENT", dear or dear oh dear. I hope you made that statement with tongue in cheek. No one in their right mind throws anything into a crowded area where it could seriously injure and, in this case, kill someone. Whatever McNulty's motivation was in committing this act he deserves everything that is coming to him which, as I said earlier, will probably be not very much given the inconsistencies of sentencing in the Criminal Justice system.
Guten Tag, Deutschland,, Manchester (17/03/2009 at 15:37)
Jay B, oldham (17/03/2009 at 15:49)
im shocked that you live in the same town as me!
that sort of attitude is whats lead us to where we are today!
in a right mess with lawless kids and young adults!
so if i was to accidently throw a bottle into your house and either killed or injured you or a relative you'd still think it was an accident?
come back to earth!
Bean of the yard, stalybridge (17/03/2009 at 15:55)
Sarah_Sarah, Oldham (17/03/2009 at 16:04)