A MAN continued to claim benefits despite banking £300,000 from the sale of his market stall.
Munir Ullah, 67, splashed out £187,000 in cash on a new detached house after the windfall.
He also used the cash, from the compulsory purchase of his family's fabric stall in Droylsden, to renovate two terraced houses.
But despite owning three homes, Ullah continued to claim council tax benefit and pensions credits.
He was overpaid more than £6,300 over two-and-a-half years after he failed to notify benefits officers of his change in circumstances, Tameside magistrates heard.
Ullah was fined £5,000 after admitting dishonesty charges. He was also told to pay court costs of £150.
Now Tameside council's deputy leader Joe Kitchen has called for a tougher sentence.
Coun Kitchen said: "Sometimes with benefit cheat cases, and certainly with a case as serious as this, I feel magistrates ought to consider a custodial sentence or even send it to crown court for a judge to look at.
Stealing
"With all that money in the bank, this person must have known he was not entitled to benefits. He was stealing from the public purse, from people on benefits who genuinely need the money."
Ullah made his benefit claim while living with his wife Fauzier Munir at a terraced house in Katherine Street, Ashton under Lyne.
Tameside council began an investigation when they were told major work was being carried out at the property and the one next door, which was also owned by the couple.
Investigators found the couple no longer lived in Katherine Street but had moved to the detached house on Manchester Road, Audenshaw.
Ullah, who is retired and suffers from angina, said: "It was an honest mistake and one I'm sorry for.
"I didn't realise that property counted as capital, it was a lack of knowledge. It wasn't intentional.
"We're respectable people. I've been in Britain for more than 40 years, since 1963, and have worked hard all that time.
"Our circumstances changed when our shop was bought by compulsory purchase order and I didn't inform the benefits people.
"It was my fault. I'm paying the fine now and hopefully that will be the end of it."
Between August 2004 and April 2007, he was paid £2,050 in council tax benefit and £4,260 in pension credits, a total of £6,310.
To report benefits cheats, call the National Fraud hotline on 0800 3286340.
Tweet

Showing comments 1 to 25 and replies | View All
Voice of Sanity (25/02/2009 at 07:23)
gladys rowbotham, Manchester (25/02/2009 at 08:08)
"It was my fault. I'm paying the fine now and hopefully that will be the end of it."
Hopefully not, Munir.
I trust the Council will now take action to recover overpaid benefits.
The Inland Revenue will certainly be interested in your new-found capital and will be claiming tax on your rents - for the past 4 years!!
Bean B4, manchester (25/02/2009 at 08:34)
Jay B, oldham (25/02/2009 at 09:22)
if you havent paid into the system then shouldnt be able to take out of it!
i would rather see the whole benefits system scrapped! it would save the tax payer millions which could be put to better use!
but thats too much a touchy subject for our polititians to tackle!
at the current moment the system rewards the lazy, imorral and irresponsible people of our country and we the tax payer are punished for these lot by paying for them all to carry on like this!
Something needs to be done! and soon!
chris (25/02/2009 at 09:27)
he is still better off after all of this.
he should be made to repay the benefits + interest and then he should be served a punishment....large fine or a prison term.
what is the point in working hard and paying your taxes?
Ace Shakespeare , manchester (25/02/2009 at 09:30)
Edina Clouds, GREAT Manchester (25/02/2009 at 09:46)
It should be repaid in full + the fine all at once direct from his bank account as this is proceeds of crime.
I'll bet Tamesides council tax goes up by more than 3% this year.
Ace Shakespeare , manchester (25/02/2009 at 10:48)
Jomov (25/02/2009 at 10:54)
He has been in this country long enough to know the score, he just jumped on the bandwagon...and you know what, why not? Everyone else is and I am feeling left behind!
Soft touch Britain does it again...
David of Ashton, Ashton (25/02/2009 at 11:22)
MPs gravy train, UK (25/02/2009 at 11:35)
Somebody needs to tell this man what honest means. He was already on some benefits for council tax and tax credits when he was running a business worth hundred of thousands of pounds too. If it was worth that much it must have been quite profitable.
The decent people get taken for a ride again.
Billbob, Dukinfield (25/02/2009 at 12:05)
How did he get it in the first place. Having his own business
The Seeker, Eccles (25/02/2009 at 12:12)
donald duck (25/02/2009 at 12:14)
Guten Tag, Deutschland,, Manchester (25/02/2009 at 12:38)
JTC Formerley JimC (25/02/2009 at 12:50)
selfexiled (25/02/2009 at 12:57)
Pippa, Manchester (25/02/2009 at 13:04)
Miller and Wigley. Hulme , (25/02/2009 at 13:12)
trainman (25/02/2009 at 13:17)
Bean B4, manchester (25/02/2009 at 13:24)
lizard (25/02/2009 at 13:55)
Frostee, Oldham (25/02/2009 at 13:56)
The benefit system needs a complete overhaul, it is too slanted towards the feckless and the crooks. Last night Sky News shown a news report of thousands of possible illegal immigrants along the coast of France all trying to get into Britain and even complaining because stricter policing has made it more difficult. And why are they trying to get here rather than staying in France? Because this country is an easy touch for free loading benefit cheats.
dave pickup (25/02/2009 at 14:22)
andanotherthing, Mcr (25/02/2009 at 14:48)