A MAJOR crackdown on disabled badge cheats has led to seven people being hauled before the courts.
Manchester council launched the operation to catch motorists misusing Blue Badges to park in the city centre.
They accused 17 drivers of the cheating the system and yesterday six of those pleaded guilty at Manchester magistrates' court.
The court heard how almost all had used a badge which had been licensed to a family member.
Hotel worker Kathryn Davies broke down in tears as she admitted using her mother's disabled parking badge to get to a meeting on time.
Davies, 25, who works at Manchester's Hilton Hotel, of Castle Hill Drive, Blackley, was caught using the Blue Badge in a pay and display parking bay on Deansgate.
Prosecutor Malcolm Hope told magistrates: "The Blue Badge system was introduced to enable those with disabilities to enjoy greater freedom than they would otherwise. When the scheme is misused, of course, it devalues the principle it exists for."
Her Kia car was impounded and when she picked it up she gave officials her maiden name instead of her married name and claimed the misuse of the badge was a 'complete mistake'.
Sorry
Davies told magistrates: "I'm deeply sorry for what I did. I completely understand the seriousness of the offence because my mother is severely disabled.
"It was completely wrong. I would never do it to gain benefit. It was a very, very foolish thing. I'm deeply, deeply sorry."
She was handed a 12-month conditional discharge and ordered to pay £286 prosecution costs.
Student Lisa Dempster, 19, of Bill Williams Close, Openshaw, pleaded guilty to misusing her grandmother's Blue Badge to park in a pay and display bay on High Street.
Her grandmother was nowhere to be seen - badge holders must be present - and she told a parking attendant: "I'm just shopping for her because she's at home."
She said she had not realised she was committing an offence and was fearful for her future as she would have to tell staff at the university where she is studying.
Dempster was fined £65, told to pay a £15 government surcharge and ordered to pay £30 prosecution costs.
Kauser Ghani, 52, of Denham Street, Longsight, who was caught using a doctored Blue Badge, admitted fraudulently using the badge on Nicholas Street, Manchester.
She was spotted parking her silver Peugeot in a pay and display bay with a badge whose expiry date had been changed to 2008 when it should have been 2005.
The badge had belonged to her sister and the court heard that it was one of two of her badges which had been previously reported lost or stolen.
Doctored
The defendant, who is on benefits, insisted she had not doctored the badge herself although she admitted she knew it had been altered.
She was handed a 12-month conditional discharge and ordered to pay £340 full prosecution costs.
Maxine Lees, 35, of Greengate East, New Moston, who admitted using her husband's grandmother's Blue Badge on successive days in May on Byrom Street.
She told magistrates: "We do take nanna shopping because she's disabled. That's really all I can say. Just in this occasion she wasn't with me but I still used it."
Lees was fined £120 and ordered to pay £200 prosecution costs.
Tasmeen Bibi Hussain , 49, of Mornington Crescent, Fallowfield, admitted misusing a badge after she was caught parking her Toyota in pay and display bay on King Street in city centre Manchester.
The badge was registered to her mother whom she admitted she had just dropped off at the Manchester Royal Infirmary before travelling into the city.
Hussain, who is on income support, was fined £35 and ordered to pay £100 prosecution costs.
Julie Seaton, 50, of Aylesbury Grove, Middleton, who admitted misusing a badge, was caught using her mother-in-law's Blue Badge when she parked her Seat Ibiza in a pay and display bay on York Street in city centre Manchester.
Seaton, who said she did not realise she was breaking the law, was fined £175 and ordered to pay £303 costs.
Roberto Polacco, 41, of Zinc Court, Prestwich, admitted using his mother's badge to park his Honda car on Thomas Street in the city centre.
The defendant, who said he had dropped his mother off earlier, was fined £35 in his absence and ordered to pay £120 towards costs.
A further ten people had their cases adjourned or pleaded not guilty and will now face trial.
Tweet
Crackdown on disabled badge cheats
September 11, 2008






Showing comments 1 to 25 and replies | View All
S P In exile, Tameside (11/09/2008 at 06:23)
Come on pull the other one if your not disabled then you cannot use the blue badge what part of disabled did she not understand.
I am glad there has been a clamp down on the misuse of these blue badges, I am disabled and I have a blue badge and it is infuriating when able bodied people use the disabled bays.
I am disabled through no choice of my own I would swap my disability tomorrow with any of these arrogant cheats, and then they would know first hand what it is like to be disabled. Let’s see more in the courts till the message hits home.
thehorse (11/09/2008 at 07:41)
A BLUE BADGE SHOULD HAVE THE PHOTO SIDE SHOWING,THEN IF PERSON IS DIFFERENTN THEY CAN BE CHALLENGED GO GET EM FFLOYD!!!
Voice of Sanity (11/09/2008 at 07:53)
MsD, Manchester (11/09/2008 at 08:17)
I am a driver and trying to park in Manchester is such a hassle, if I am shopping, I prefer to catch a bus. Are these people too good to do the same ?
Guten Tag (11/09/2008 at 09:17)
Guten Tag (11/09/2008 at 09:20)
badgeholder (11/09/2008 at 09:22)
MPs gravy train, UK (11/09/2008 at 09:26)
Mike S, Manchester (11/09/2008 at 09:29)
Tezza, Tyldesley (11/09/2008 at 09:33)
Most of these people are doing this so they don’t have to pay cut the free parking out and they have nothing to gain.
I do agree that disabled drivers should get both larger and designated spaces, but I still cant understand why if you can drive a car and then walk to the shops (or get in a wheelchair) you cant go to the payment meter?
All these people deserve what they get and we should see more of these clamp downs
Ace Shakepseare, manchester (11/09/2008 at 09:48)
Jomov (11/09/2008 at 09:50)
Melandra (11/09/2008 at 09:56)
jacko101 (11/09/2008 at 09:59)
You had that argument before and if you still don't get it, maybe you can 'be disabled' for a week and see what jobs you can do?
Do you not get the fact that some (not all, of course) disabled people find it difficult if not impossible to get a job?
Would you like to be disabled and see how you get on?
And you would take a way a very small 'token' of free parking?
How about you think about how being disabled changes your life and then think about whether they can have free parking or not.
And then think about whether you'd prefer to be disabled or pay for parking? Hmmm.... what a choice.
boothyboy, UAE, Dubia (11/09/2008 at 10:09)
Ace Shakepseare, manchester (11/09/2008 at 10:10)
CityCntr (11/09/2008 at 10:16)
Melandra
You both seem to convey a feeling of resentment to those disabled badge users, even if they are legitamate. I tell you what, you can have my badge so long as you take my disability to go with it. Perhaps then you would have a greater understanding of the dificulties that we face daily. Perhaps then you would have better empathy for people less able than yourselves. Perhaps then you wouldnt be so jealous.
Black Flag (11/09/2008 at 10:21)
What if the car is shared or the person with the badge is not the driver? The person with the blue badge may be blind and not be in the car for every journey.
What if the person has to hire a car in the event of a breakdown?
Not to mention the fact that making a disabled driver travel around with a "D" on their numberplate could make them a target for criminals who might view them as a softer target.
Donna. Harpurhey (11/09/2008 at 10:26)
this is how I see it (11/09/2008 at 10:29)
Ace Shakepseare, manchester (11/09/2008 at 10:42)
All blue badge holders should be designated for the badge and the car should be registered as a disabled car and the plate should have a blue "D" and as far as being a easy target im afraid everybody is a easy target so that dosnt hold water.If people want a blue badge with the benefits in afraid we will have to put up with some of these downfalls thanks to the scum who abuse it,along with the people who park in the disabled spaces.
Ace Shakepseare, manchester (11/09/2008 at 10:45)
Very well said ..
Andy, Stockport (11/09/2008 at 10:46)
jacko101 (11/09/2008 at 10:53)
Black Flag raised other points about your system that will not make it practical.
A lot of disabled people are not car owners and rely on friends and family to drive them places, how does having a blue 'd' on my car reg. (for eg) stop me from parking where I shouldn't if the disabled person is not with me?
And as for crime, if you don't know that criminals often (very often) look for the easy targets then you need to get out more.
Black Flag (11/09/2008 at 11:04)
Why don't you tell us why you think your idea would make the slightest bit of difference and also explain how you would deal with the issues you would create, such as:
-People being unable to use hire cars if they breakdown.
-Those people such as the blind or people with conditions that are so severe that they can't drive and have to travel in other people's cars. Often these people will rely on lifts from a number of different people.
Or, you can do what you always do when you come up with a stupid idea and just refuse to acknowledge the problems and plough on regardless.