In the past a simple T-junction marked the point in Middleton, Rochdale, where Clough Road and Boarshaw Road meet - with nothing more than a give way sign to regulate the traffic.
But now motorists making their way through this quiet residential area have to negotiate two separate roundabouts just 10 yards apart.
The new road layout allows traffic to move to and from Clough Road, Boarshaw Road and Boarshaw Clough.
Council officials said the changes were necessary to cope with the anticipated increase in traffic that will result from a new housing development on Boarshaw Clough, which is being built.
They said they favoured the installation of traffic lights but the Planning Inspectorate gave the go-ahead to the roundabouts at the request of the developers, Lancashire-based Paddle Homes.
Confusion
Bemused residents say the new layout causes confusion and the roads are so narrow lorry drivers have struggled to get round.
Zena Stock, who lives near the junction, said: "I can't see the point of building the roundabouts considering it is such a narrow road. It was fine the way it was and building them has just made it more confusing.
"The roundabouts are right next to each other and it just looks funny. Large wagons struggle to get round them. It's just silly and pointless."
Motorist Ethan Worrall, 25, from Middleton, agreed.
He said: "No one can see the point of having them there, so close together. Buses sometimes struggle and taxi drivers are always talking about them."
Denise Hill, landlady of the nearby Cotton Tree pub, said the roundabouts have already become quite a talking point.
She said: "Taxi drivers are saying that there is going to be an accident, although nothing has happened as yet. A lot of people are talking about them."
Glyn Henry, of Rochdale council, said: "Traffic management is necessary to handle the extra vehicles expected once the Boarshaw Clough housing development is completed. These two roundabouts were installed by the developer to control traffic in place of the previous T junction.
"Rochdale borough council requested that traffic lights were installed to deal with the traffic generated by the development. The developer appealed to the Planning Inspectorate and the council's requirement was overruled in favour of the developer's mini roundabout scheme."
Andrew Howard, head of road safety at the AA, said a succession of multiple roundabouts is not that rare and that the layout even appears in a Highway Code illustration.
He admits such road layouts can cause confusion, but he says this can actually slow traffic, as motorists ponder the impending junction.
"This is not terribly unusual," he said. "One of the great plusses of mini-roundabouts is that it creates uncertainty and makes people slow down. There are occasions where uncertainty can make people drive more safely."
Paddle Homes Ltd were unavailable for comment.
You need Flash player 8+ and JavaScript enabled to view this video.
460
275
0
false
Tweet

Showing comments 1 to 25 and replies | View All
Rammylad (02/09/2008 at 08:25)
No doubt somebody will be here telling us this is good road planning and they are not incompetent.
Jay B, oldham (02/09/2008 at 08:34)
what a load of twaddle! its staring you in the face and you still waffle on that we need the con charge to cure this problem.
no we dont, we need sensible road layouts to keep the flow of traffic moving.
Longshots Wife (02/09/2008 at 08:37)
alec dicks, manchester (02/09/2008 at 08:47)
MPs gravy train, UK (02/09/2008 at 09:48)
Michelle Ryan, Middleton (02/09/2008 at 10:02)
selfexiled (02/09/2008 at 10:10)
Ace Shakepseare, manchester (02/09/2008 at 10:38)
AlexisV (02/09/2008 at 10:45)
Fedup, Mersyside (02/09/2008 at 11:22)
Bean B4, manchester (02/09/2008 at 11:23)
The Gardeners Arms, on the other hand, is a complete shambles. Everyone ignores the lights, ignores the lanes etc. Not long before there is huge accident.
Miss M, Manchester (02/09/2008 at 12:00)
Trudy, Bolton (02/09/2008 at 12:27)
Polky (02/09/2008 at 13:13)
Was there answer to the confusion to take it out and put a sensible junction in it's place?
No.
Put a 20Mph speed limit on it.
We need to start getting a grip of the people who are wasting our hard earned taxes on these unnecessary, politically correct traffic calming measures.
stivh, Urmston (02/09/2008 at 13:20)
I bet the postman enjoys parking his van 30 metres down the road when he collects the mail- Not !
Fran M (Permissum Populus Constituo) (02/09/2008 at 14:43)
Total idiocy. It looks like something a child would dream up.
Terry Mahon, West Yorkshire (02/09/2008 at 14:43)
Hannah Barbera, Salford (02/09/2008 at 15:06)
Twin mini roundabouts are not uncommon and not particularly confusing either. For those who call this complicated would no doubt also struggle with a child proof lid on a bottle of asprin.
What a load of whingers.
Polky (02/09/2008 at 15:25)
Whoever paid for it, nothing gets done to the road without the permission and approval of the local council.
If that were the case, I could buy my own tin of dulux and reek havoc on Rochdale!
StanF, Leigh (02/09/2008 at 15:31)
Hannah Barbera, Salford (02/09/2008 at 16:21)
"The council said they favoured the installation of traffic lights but the Planning Inspectorate gave the go-ahead to the roundabouts at the request of the developers, Lancashire-based Paddle Homes."
So the council experts didn't want it and preferred a signalised junction. For some reason the traffic experts were over-ruled probably by politicians. But the traffic planners are getting the blame for something they didn't do. The point i was making is that it hasn't cost the taxpayers anything.
Polky (02/09/2008 at 16:26)
It's because, be they politicians or road planners, they are still working for the council.
I don't care who paid really, as it's only the tip of the ice berg so far as costs go.
Hannah Barbera, Salford (02/09/2008 at 16:39)
you do care who paid because you said "We need to start getting a grip of the people who are wasting our hard earned taxes on these unnecessary, politically correct traffic calming measures"
GENERAL HUGO WRIGHT-WONG, KNUTSFORD (02/09/2008 at 17:42)
Ewan Oosami, Halifax (02/09/2008 at 21:11)