Nick Hogan, former landlord of The Swan Hotel and Barristers Bar in Bolton, was found guilty in January of failing to prevent people from smoking on his licensed premises on four separate occasions last July.
He is appealing against conviction and sentence on three of the charges, on the grounds that he had not been aware, and could not have been reasonably expected to be aware, that individuals had been smoking in his pub.
Judgment in the case, which was heard at Bolton Crown Court, has been adjourned to a date yet to be fixed.
If the appeal is allowed, it could well have major legal and political implications, affecting thousands of other licensees.
Mr Hogan told the hearing he had not agreed with the anti-smoking legislation and believed it to be unjust.
He told the court that his stance had been to tell staff to explain the new legal position to customers, but said that if anyone lit up in his pub, they would not be thrown out.
Mr David Travers, prosecuting, said Mr Hogan had made his position clear when he hosted a protest meeting against the new law on the day it came into force last summer.
Mr Travers said it was `breathtaking' for Mr Hogan to claim he had not known people were smoking, when he had abandoned any responsibility placed on him under the law.
You need Flash player 8+ and JavaScript enabled to view this video.
460
275
0
false
Tweet

Showing comments 1 to 11 and replies | View All
Good Cop Bad Cop, Salford (24/07/2008 at 08:42)
Pubs,bars, clubs etc that wished to be smoke free would still be as busy and collect a trade the same as those that wished to provide a smoking enviroment.
Lets face it non smokers would go to the non smoking bars, as a smoker myself, going to one of the non smoking bars whilst on a pub crawl, I would be able to manage not having to light up for the duration of my time in there.
It wont be long before Pubs will be prohibited from selling Alcohol and will have to sell health drinks and bottled water.
Message to the govenment, people who go to pubs are not all binge drinkers and raving alcoholics!!!
alvinlwh (24/07/2008 at 10:19)
Dave (24/07/2008 at 10:46)
Princess_Pam, Crumpsall (24/07/2008 at 11:18)
Councillor Allheart, in a black cab (24/07/2008 at 11:22)
Meanwhile the economy ran aground.
jomov, Manchester (24/07/2008 at 11:44)
Doesn't say much for Labour really...longer licensing? Very contradictive considering they are urging people to drink less.
ace, manchester (24/07/2008 at 14:00)
Marc (24/07/2008 at 14:23)
jomov, Manchester (24/07/2008 at 14:28)
ace, manchester (24/07/2008 at 15:01)
Pubs in levenshulme shutting down? What about the blue bell,theve just done that place up and re-opened it.What went wrong with a lot of pubs ,is they never came up to modern standards expected nowadays.SNUGS? they went out in the 1950s/60s ..I bet you wear a hair net as well .
Marc (24/07/2008 at 15:18)
haha, only while i'm waiting for my blue rinse to dry, ace.
pubs still have snugs, its a fact. theres a pub in my hometown called The Globe - its got the snuggiest snug i've ever been in. want to meet up there for a drink some time? you can bring your birch if you like...