TWO teenagers were jailed for life today for brutally murdering a young woman in a park because she was dressed as a Goth.
Sophie Lancaster, 20, was kicked and stamped to death as she begged the pair to stop beating her boyfriend in Bacup, Lancashire, last August.
Ryan Herbert, 16, of Rossendale Crescent, Bacup, who admitted murder, received a 16-year minimum term.
His accomplice Brendan Harris, 15, of Spring Terrace, Bacup, Lancashire, who was convicted after a trial last month, was given a minimum of 18 years.
Passing sentence Judge Anthony Russell QC said: “This was feral thuggery.
“It raises serious questions about the sort of society which exists in this country at the start of a new millennium which was heralded with such optimism.
Gap-year student Miss Lancaster cradled her boyfriend, Robert Maltby, 21, in her arms as she begged the two to stop beating him in Stubbylee Park last August.
Her plea was ignored as Harris delivered a flying kick to her head and Herbert volley-kicked her in the face “like a ball in flight”.
The injuries to both victims were so severe that paramedics could not tell which sex either was. A clear footwear pattern was visible on Miss Lancaster's head.
Both fell into comas but Miss Lancaster never regained consciousness and died in hospital 13 days later.
Neither of the defendants knew the couple, who were both Goths, and the only motive was they simply looked different from them.
Sentencing them today, the judge told Harris and Herbert: “This was a terrible case which has shocked and outraged all who have heard about it.
Wild animals
“At least wild animals, when they hunt in packs, have a legitimate reason for so doing, to obtain food.
“You have none and your behaviour on that night degrades humanity itself.”
Three other teenagers who took part in the initial attack on Mr Maltby can now be named for the first time after the judge lifted an order banning the press from identifying them.
Brothers Joseph, 17, and Danny Hulme, 16, both of Landgate, Whitworth, near Bacup, and Daniel Mallett, 17, of Rockcliffe Drive, Bacup, all pleaded guilty to grievous bodily harm with intent on Mr Maltby. They did not take part in the attack on Sophie, the court was told.
Judge Russell jailed Mallett for four years and four months and the Hulme brothers for five years and 10 months each.
There was no reaction from the defendants but Hulme's mother left the court in tears.
Judge Russell said both victims were totally innocent and were subjected to cruel and sadistic behaviour.
He described the Goth community as “perfectly peaceful law-abiding people who pose no threat to anybody”.
He added: “The intolerance you displayed in this case is shocking evidence of the attitudes of some of our people.
“I am satisfied having heard all the evidence there was an intention by each of you to inflict severe pain and suffering.
“This was a hate crime against these completely harmless people targeted because their appearance was different to yours.”
He described Sophie as a caring young woman who wrote poetry and read books and had charmed many people.
“Her tragic fate has touched many hearts,” he added.
Earlier today the judge heard that Mr Maltby, who was not in court, now finds the world a “terrifying place” and still suffers long term physical and emotional damage.
A statement from him was read out by Michael Shorrock QC, prosecuting.
“There has been a huge change in my behaviour and outlook,” Mr Maltby said.
“Before all this happened I was settled into a life quite independent. My life was set up and I had control over everything.
Regressed
“Now I have regressed to being something similar to a child. I really just like to think I'm now only eight-months-old. I'm finding the whole world a terrifying place.
“I'm aware this is terribly cowardly but I don't know how I'm supposed to cope.
“I still feel guilty about what happened to Sophie and feel responsible for her death. I'm a much more pessimistic person and have become introverted since the assault.”
His mother, Tracy, told the court: “He's gone from someone fiercely independent to someone who barely leaves the house.”
Sophie's mother, Sylvia, 52, along with Mr Maltby's mother, father and brother, and 15 other friends and relatives, some in Goth clothing, sat in the jury box and seats alongside it.
Across the courtroom sat the families of the defendants, with police and security standing guard close by.
Judge Russell warned that anyone who disturbed the court would be arrested and ejected.
Following the verdict last month, Miss Lancaster's mother said society needed to reflect on what had happened and make changes to prevent similar deaths.
She said she was uncertain she could continue her job as a youth worker - ironically trying to prevent teenagers following a life of crime.
She added: “To choose to beat and stamp a young girl to death just because she looks different and show no remorse afterwards is just so sick. I feel nothing but contempt for them.”
Detectives investigating the murder criticised the conduct of the defendants and their families throughout the criminal proceedings as “appalling”.
Harris and his mother were said to have been “laughing and joking” when they were first interviewed about the assaults.
Both the teenage killers had been drinking heavily on night of the attack.
The judge told the defendants today that he “noted the swaggering manner that some of you have displayed” in court.
“I noticed the wink that one of you exchanged with the public gallery when the murder charge was not proceeded with against you and that one of you thought it appropriate to shout out 'love you mum”'.
Hollow
He added: “You have shown little genuine shame or remorse for your actions and I regard the sentiments of regret you have sought to put forward to the Youth Offending team and through your counsel as hollow when put into the overall context of this case.”
The court also heard part of the victim impact statement from Sophie's mother today.
It read: “Their actions are so heinous I can't bring myself to think about it. My daughter's last moments on earth must have been a living hell.
“Not only did she witness Robert being kicked and stamped upon, but she died not knowing whether Robert lived or died after the vicious attack on him.”
The Goths in court to give support to Sophie and Robert's families today, around 30 in total, gathered on the court steps, amid a heavy police presence, while the defendants' families left the building without comment.
Afterwards the Chief Crown Prosecutor for Lancashire Robert Marshall described the case as “truly shocking”.
Mr Marshall said: “Very occasionally, in spite of all the tragic and distressing cases that the CPS has to deal with, we come across a case that stands out as truly shocking.
“The murder of Sophie Lancaster and the vicious attack on her boyfriend Robert Maltby stand out for their utter pointlessness and sheer brutality.
“Worse still, it seems very likely that the attack started as a form of amusement for those involved.
“There is no doubt that Brendan Harris and Ryan Herbert attacked Miss Lancaster and Mr Maltby simply because the couple were Goths and dressed differently.”
He added: “We can only try to imagine the loss felt by Miss Lancaster's family, who have conducted themselves with outstanding dignity and restraint throughout this difficult case.
“The final words must be our heartfelt sympathy for them.”
Outside court, Miss Lancaster's brother, Adam, 23, said: “We would like to thank everyone for their support.
“Although the sentences seem fitting and appropriate, no sentence is long enough to compensate for the loss of Sophie.”
Miss Lancaster's mother, Sylvia, added: “Justice can never be done because it will never bring her back.”
What do you think? Have your say.
You need Flash player 8+ and JavaScript enabled to view this video.

Showing comments 1 to 25 and replies | View All
bluelight, Levenshulme (28/04/2008 at 15:10)
No wonder our most promising young talents flock to London instead of trying to change things here.
ace, manchester (28/04/2008 at 15:49)
John-Thai sandwich brigade (28/04/2008 at 16:12)
it's a human trait, to gang together and destroy anybody else who can be regarded as different.
and of course, we are all different in each others eyes.
therefore everybody gets attacked by some-one.
it's nothing new in this world, I'm afraid.
RIP and I hope Robert can find peace in his mind and soul to live again.
ace, manchester (28/04/2008 at 16:28)
alvinlwh (28/04/2008 at 16:37)
Bigfish (28/04/2008 at 16:40)
A minimum of 16 and 18 years is hardly a few years though is it. Some killers get joke minimum sentences.
I hope her boyfriend can now start to piece his shattered life together again now
Octavius Tinsworth Ace (28/04/2008 at 16:41)
Frankly there is a geographical variation in tolerance but I'd say it tends to be more between small towns and large cities than it is between north and south. This sort of thing would be far less likely to happen in the more cosmopolitan parts of Manchester than in somewhere relatively remote like Bacup, and I've been to similarly hostile towns in the southeast. It's certainly not exclusively a northern problem.
Phil Hulme (28/04/2008 at 17:02)
ace, manchester (28/04/2008 at 17:03)
16/18 years could really mean they could be walking the streets in less than ten years or even less if we have a change of government? And while these monsters are in prison they will receive most things they want TV,games,most of the comforts that most people would have to work hard for.and most pensioners cannot afford..we live in a stupid country with a stupid legal system.
Elljay (28/04/2008 at 17:05)
My thoughts and prayers are with Robert, his family and Sophies family at this time, may you find the strength to build your lives up again, and find some comfort in the fact these low lifes are off the streets.
SteveDB (28/04/2008 at 17:12)
Grief Tourist, Tameside (28/04/2008 at 17:12)
Bigfish (28/04/2008 at 17:12)
We all know about your liking for capital punishment etc.
As I say - Personally, I think the judge has done a good job in this case when you consider it to other joke sentences that have been handed down in the past
ace, manchester (28/04/2008 at 17:15)
He was jailed for 19 years in 1989 for killing Jason Swift, 14, but freed after nine years
ace, manchester (28/04/2008 at 17:22)
That is the problem they dont find it boring inside,they get entertained by the system,TV,Games consoles,education,gyms and other things to help them get through? Who helps the family or the freinds of the victim get through???Answer NOBODY.
Bigfish (28/04/2008 at 17:27)
Of course they need gyms etc. What do you suggest we do to prisoners (apart from kill them)?
Guten Tag (28/04/2008 at 18:26)
Mike, Manchester (28/04/2008 at 19:07)
The Rt Hon Dr Rev MC Spanner MP QC FCA FRICS JP OK (28/04/2008 at 19:20)
Do you have your replies set to auto because it's he same old tosh over and over and over again. Maybe these criminals should have been birched as kids
New Political Party - Blah Blah Blah.
I think the judge has done the right thing here. LIfe sentences with a (get this - ace) MINIMUM 16 and 18 years. That means the equivalent of their life to date.
Even if we reintroduced the death penalty, which I favour in cases like this, the two of them were under the age of 18. One was even under 16, so the Death Penalty is a bit too far here.
I also feel that the parents of these thugs should be made to hand over the worldy pssessions to be auctioned as compensation. People who raise murderers should pay society.
I hope her family find peace and her boyfriend can rebuild his life.
mel c (28/04/2008 at 19:55)
Heartfelt sympathy to Sophie's family, Robert and all their family and friends
Peter Beagrie`s beagle (28/04/2008 at 20:01)
Years ago life meant life and people wonder why the little darlings that wander our streets wreaking havoc are allowed to get away with it????
The parents of these scumbags should hang their heads in shame!
RIP and God bless both families of the victims.
Andy139 (28/04/2008 at 20:31)
I hope that their deserved time behind bars is a living hell. Maybe they will get treated by the other prisoners with the same respect they gave Sophie and her family.
It would be good, like others have stated, if there could be some financial compensation to the families, but I doubt the scum's families could scrape enough cash together to make it worth while.
ace, manchester (28/04/2008 at 23:56)
Felix, manchester uk (29/04/2008 at 03:11)
Alan Crump, usa (29/04/2008 at 06:31)