A MAN who posed as a doctor and charged hundreds for cures has been convicted of deception. Gurmukh Singh treated several patients for the skin condition eczema.
Minshull Street Crown Court heard 48-year-old Singh from St John's Road, Old Trafford, claimed to be qualified in a form of medicine called Ayurveda which is a traditional Indian system of medicine, recognised by the World Health Organisation.
But his claims were revealed as false after an investigation was launched by the Oldham Primary Care Trust in 2005, Greater Manchester Police and the Medicines Health and Regulatory Authority.
The investigation found four families had taken their children to "Dr Singh" for help with eczema and had paid him more than £2,000 for creams he said he imported from India. Tests showed the cream contained antihistamines and prescription only steroids.
On at least one occasion, a man who paid £800 to Singh for treatment saw his eczema get much worse. In parts, his skin went black and peeled off.
When Singh was arrested at his home in May last year, he said he only kept a small amount of the money he charged and sent the rest back to India.
Investigations revealed that some of those treated had seen an improvement in their condition. But they had been overcharged by someone unqualified to treat them.
Deception
Singh admitted four counts of deception.
Detective Sergeant Lindsey Curry said: "This man abused one of the most sacred positions of responsibility in a community. He may well have had genuine intentions to help people, but he was unqualified to do so, and massively overcharged for his services. In some cases, the conditions of the people who went to see him actually got worse, and all of them ended up well out of pocket. As well as claiming disability benefit, Singh was earning hundreds of pounds out of his patients. The amount of medicine he had in his house suggests that he had no intention of stopping." A spokesperson for the Ayurvedic Practitioners Association (APA) said the case illustrated the need for statutory regulation of those practising traditional medicines as soon as possible.
He said: "Fortunately, all professional Ayurvedic associations in this country have been actively engaged in the process of statutory regulation, which has Department of Health backing and is currently anticipated to commence in 2009. "Once implemented, the regulation of Ayurveda and other traditional medicine systems by the statutory council will ensure that only fully qualified professionals who abide by strict codes of conduct and ethical practice have access to protected practitioner titles.
"This will provide safeguards for the UK public, so that such unfortunate events will not occur in future. Until 2009, voluntary regulation bodies like the APA ensure that their members are adequately trained and also adhere to appropriate codes of professional practice."
Singh is to be sentenced in January.
What do you think? Have your say.
Tweet
Bogus doctor convicted
December 10, 2007

Showing comments 1 to 1 and replies | View All
APA (16/12/2007 at 18:26)
Ayurveda is a prevention-oriented traditional medicine and one of the most ancient, time-tested systems of natural health care in the world. It originated in India, but is becoming increasingly popular in the UK and other Western countries for its comprehensive yet easy-to-apply approach to health as well as for the safety and effectiveness of its treatments.
On 10 December 2007, Mr. Gurmukh Singh of Old Trafford was found guilty at Minshull Street Crown Court of illegally administering prescription-only medicines to the public while falsely claiming to be a qualified Ayurvedic practitioner. This case highlights once more the precarious situation in a sector as crucial as public health where alternative and complementary medicines are not adequately recognised by UK Government authorities.
Although Mr. Singh is a layman with no recognised medical training of any description, many people fell for his deceptive claims and agreed not only to receive treatment from him but also to pay extortionate amounts of money for his ‘visits’. This is clearly indicative of an existing lack of public awareness as to how to identify qualified practitioners of traditional systems of medicine (Acupuncture, Ayurveda, Chinese Medicine, Herbal Medicine, Tibetan Medicine etc.) or how to verify qualification claims with the help of professional associations.
Such public awareness can only develop when authorities appropriately recognise and statutorily regulate alternative and complementary health care professionals, so that the public can be effectively safeguarded through disseminated information about available health care options and through education on how to make informed health decisions.
Fortunately, traditional systems of medicine like Ayurveda are now in the final stages of statutory regulation in the UK and the Department of Health envisages its implementation by 2009. Until then, the Ayurvedic Practitioners Association (APA) and other voluntary regulation bodies united in the European Herbal and Traditional Medicine Practitioners Association (EHTPA) continue to fulfil their responsibilities for public safety by ensuring that all members are adequately trained, fully qualified and also adhere to strict codes of ethical conduct and professional practice.
In addition to qualification and regulation of practitioners, Mr. Singh’s case also highlights another important issue concerning public health and safety: quality standards of traditional medicinal products. Apparently, Mr. Singh used Ayurvedic medicines that were adulterated with prescription-only substances (steroids and antihistamines), which is illegal in the UK and also in India were the medicines had been manufactured. In order to protect the public from illegal or contaminated products, the APA has introduced an Approved Suppliers Scheme and is working closely together with the Ayurvedic Trade Association (ATA) to ensure that suppliers of Ayurvedic products in the UK have appropriate quality assurance procedures in place.
For more information or enquiries, please contact www.apa.uk.com