THREE bosses of one the region's most high-profile petrol station and newsagent chains have been jailed for a multi-million pound tax fraud .
Bolton-based Aleef Garages Ltd has a turnover of £92m with 60 shops across Greater Manchester, Merseyside and Lancashire. But "criminality crept into every area of the business" according to
HM Revenue and Customs
(HMRC) following their massive five-year fraud investigation.
Company directors secretly built up a huge nest egg of undeclared cash by using two tills in their shops - while only declaring the contents of one to the taxman.
In a complex £5m tax-dodging scam they used a Muslim charity to launder their undeclared income. Meanwhile, they kept a bogus payroll that allowed shop managers to falsely claim family tax credits.
Three brothers, Mustaq Hussain Patel, 53, of Canterbury Grove, Bolton, Iqbal Ahmed Patel, 51, and Mubarakali Ahmed Patel, 55, both of Headingley Way, Bolton, were jailed for three years after pleading guilty to conspiracy to cheat the Inland Revenue at Liverpool Crown Court yesterday.
The men have been ordered to pay back the money, plus £500,000 costs, and each has been banned from being a company director for ten years.
The court heard the men cooked the books to hide their fraud.
An 'unofficial' set of accounts allowed the trio to keep track of all their money. Meanwhile an 'official' set, prepared for their accountants, played down their income so they could pay less tax. The untaxed income was then used to fund the family's lavish lifestyles.
Much of it was siphoned into a cash fund which was paid into their father Ahmed Patel's bank account and the charity he ran, Great Lever Muslim Society. The money was then paid back out to his sons, sometimes using accounts kept in the Channel Islands.
The company paid its employees low wages which they declared to the taxman. This meant that workers could claim family tax credits on the side - when all the while the bosses were topping up their wages from their undeclared nest egg.
When the company, which employs around 250 people was raided, it also emerged that some of the workers were not on the payroll.
The investigators also found that a number of Aleef's shops were franchises where self-employed businessmen were disguised as employees.
This meant Aleef failed to declare the franchise payments it was receiving. The franchise managers were also in the money because they avoided self-employment taxes.
Six other conspirators - who are not related to the three brothers - also pleaded guilty to cheating the Inland Revenue and were sentenced alongside them.
Wages clerk and company PA Nichole Marie Patel, of Lever Edge Lane, Bolton, was handed 240 hours community work. She received a confiscation order of £36,500 and will face six months in jail if she doesn't pay up within 12 months.
The 34-year-old was Mustaq Patel's personal assistant and kept the bogus payroll which allowed directors to defraud the taxman and workers to falsely claim low-income benefits.
Inayat Patel, 34, of Leach Street, Bolton, ran an Aleef newsagents' franchise in the Arndale Centre in Manchester city centre. He got four months behind bars and faces a confiscation hearing next month.
Randal Street
Franchise manager Hanif Mahmet Patel, 46, of Randal Street Bolton got eight months. He ran two newsagents at St Peter's Square and Bridge Street. He received a confiscation order of £90,000 and will get an extra 12 months inside if he doesn't pay within a year.His business partner Usman Abdullah Patel, 45, of Leach Street, Bolton, got eight months and was ordered to pay £80,000, also with an extra 12 months inside if he doesn't pay.
Javeed Bashir, 48, of Castle Street, Bolton, ran a shop on Piccadilly. He got 200 hours community service and a £15,000 order. If he defaults he will get four months behind bars.
Franchise manager Ibrahim Vali Patel, 55, of Sunninghill Street, Bolton, got eight months jail. He ran a store next to Piccadilly train station. He has been ordered to pay £79,000 and if he fails he will spend an extra year behind bars.
Sentencing, His Honour Judge Swift said the fraudsters had participated "in a fraud on the community as a whole".
Steve Armitt. group leader of HMRC Criminal Investigations, said `the investigation was made all the more difficult because of the closed ranks of the employees involved, some of whom are close family members.
"It was cheating on a grand scale, and it deprived the Revenue of a great deal of money. Those involved tried to make it as difficult as possible for the cheating to be discovered."
The business was started by the father of the three jailed directorsAhmed Patel, 78, twenty-five years ago and has grown to around 29 garage forecourts and 26 newsagents across the North West.
Family members are avid cricket fans who hobnob with international players and drive a fleet of top-of-the-range Mercedes cars with personalised numberplates.
Ahmed Patel is still running the charity. A spokesman for the Charities Commission said they would "look to ensure that the charity is administered properly going forward."
The business, Aleef Garages Ltd, has been left in the hands of a younger generation of the family.
Anis Patel, 29, said: "It is business as usual for us. It's been a long process so we have prepared for this rather than bury our heads in the sand. The company is fine as a legal entity - it is three former directors who have faced charges.
"The uncertainty that was present has been removed and we will carry on business using rigorous new accounting procedures and a fully transparent auditing process."
Tweet
Aleef bosses jailed for fraud
November 14, 2007
Aleef newsagent on Oxford Street near St Peter's Square

Showing comments 1 to 25 and replies | View All
gladys rowbotham, Manchester (14/11/2007 at 08:04)
Shame on the guilty!
Trudy, Bolton (14/11/2007 at 09:09)
Ms D, Manchester (14/11/2007 at 09:37)
Blue Chris, On The Blue Moon (14/11/2007 at 09:57)
At the end of the day you WILL get caught one day, whether you be fraudster, drug dealer, what ever, you WILL get caught !!!
Mark Johnson (14/11/2007 at 10:34)
ace, manchester (14/11/2007 at 10:50)
Si B1 (14/11/2007 at 11:25)
Yas from London, London (14/11/2007 at 11:35)
Laura Norder, Didsbury (14/11/2007 at 11:50)
I'm sorry that people will lose jobs when - not if - this sorry 'house of cards' (not to mention flowers, barbecue sets, cuddly toys, sweets and ices) comes crashing down - but maybe they will find employers that don't fleece them, and the rest of us decent people that pay our way.
As an apologist for these criminals, you do yourself no favours... so I hope your books are in order.
dont believe evrything you read in the papers (14/11/2007 at 11:57)
Yas from London, London (14/11/2007 at 12:24)
A Realist, Manchester (14/11/2007 at 12:25)
Rachel, Manchester (14/11/2007 at 13:12)
Shamas (14/11/2007 at 13:33)
It's good to see they are doing their job, well.
Laura Norder, Didsbury (14/11/2007 at 13:36)
You imply the Revenue could have had the case dealt with sooner? But do you seriously believe these criminals were the only people HMRC had under investigation at the time? Of course they were not, and the fact remains that the Aleef fraudsters had plenty of time to get their house in order.
I'm equally sure HMRC don't need your sympathy., perhaps you should save that for the overwhelming majority of the British public that has no alternative but to pay when the taxman calls.
The entity that is Aleef Garages Ltd - which YOU obviously have a brief to defend, (if your over-defensive comments are anything to go by) - is now seen as 'flawed goods', and if you are the sole practitioner of their PR i attempting to repair 'the brand', maybe it's time they pulled the shutters down for good.
123 (14/11/2007 at 13:57)
Womble, Westhoughton (14/11/2007 at 14:24)
Yas from London, London (14/11/2007 at 14:29)
I do not mean to rattle your steel cage with my justified comments and so to speak bring out the 'best' in you but rather hope that readers can digest simply there are two sides of every story, papers usually tell the other side, what they want you to hear and everyone deserves a second chance even my intellectually challenged friend.
Spiker The Blue, Gorton (14/11/2007 at 14:36)
They are criminals who cheated everyone do not stick up for these people.
mx5er, South Manchester (14/11/2007 at 14:38)
Laura Norder, Didsbury (14/11/2007 at 14:42)
If the media - as you imply - have it all wrong - then the Aleef defendents will still be on the streets going about their lawful business I presume? Oh! They're not.
Fact is, they're still costing taxpayers money as they are currently being housed at our collective expense. I won't hold my breath for the appeal as no doubt the moneys they have salted away, will enable them to continue to cock a snook in our direction.
Beaufort (14/11/2007 at 14:48)
What we need is rewadrs given to people who inform on their employers, family, friends etc under anomisity. This way we get the cheats.
Yas from London, London (14/11/2007 at 14:54)
Laura Norder, Didsbury (14/11/2007 at 15:09)
Fortunately I have neider need nor wish for another career as my colleagues require me to continue running a robust and successful business, that allows them and their families to prosper.
better off red (14/11/2007 at 15:12)