TOP Tories will today paint Manchester as a tale of two cities - a booming centre surrounded by areas riddled with debt, disease and drugs.
Conservative leader David Cameron (pictured) and former leader Iain Duncan Smith will begin a regional tour in the city calling on THE town hall and Whitehall to join forces to tackle the 'social breakdown' in the city.
Meeting at the Barnabus project, which helps the homeless, drug addicts and prostitutes, they were expected to point out that fewer than one in three Manchester teenagers get five or more good GCSE passes.
Mr Duncan Smith, author of the 'Breakthrough Manchester' report, disagrees with plans to force teenagers to stay in school or training until 18.
He said: "People tell me it is difficult to persuade many children to stay in school beyond 12. They often play truant and go to homes where there is no culture of education.
"We shouldn't look down our noses at vocational training at school - so that youngsters can leave school with a trade such as bricklaying or plumbing."
He said he did not favour building a super casino to regenerate east Manchester, one of the top five most deprived areas in Britain. "This is a tale of two cities. After the IRA bomb the city has witnessed a real turnaround. It's a great story worth celebrating.
"But with one of the two cities forging ahead, creating jobs and wealth and another mired in a deepening spiral of social breakdown, bad schooling and crime, drug and alcohol abuse.
"We are forming policies to reverse the tide of social breakdown and ensure that everyone in Manchester and the rest of the UK will have a chance to play a full part in the life of the nation."
Mr Duncan Smith is recommending new 'pioneer' schools run by parents and voluntary groups, along with tax breaks for marriage and benefit reform.
Before David Cameron's arrival in the city Mr Duncan Smith rejected claims that this was a political stunt.
Labour
He said: "I'm happy to meet Labour councillors at any time.
"The message to Manchester is that this is part of a regional tour. We are trying to be upbeat - this is not Conservatives coming to Manchester to whack the council."
His report says that while the city centre is one of the most visited areas in England, beneath the glossy exterior lies a much bleaker day-to-day reality for thousands of residents.
"Deprivation, family breakdown and educational failure are contributing to the creation of a generation of youths lost to gangs, guns, crime and worklessness," says the report.
The key findings include: Manchester is at the bottom of the league table for truancy, only one school leaver in the city goes to university, two in five families with children are headed by a lone parent, compared with one in five average, Greater Manchester has the highest number of antisocial behaviour orders in the UK and there are seven gun-related incidents every day.
The bleak picture continues: Manchester's teenage pregnancy rate is nearly double the average, Greater Manchester has the highest number of children under 15 admitted to hospital for alcohol-related problems, and 22 per cent of Manchester's working age population are unemployed and on benefits.
Mr Duncan Smith concludes: "Manchester is one of the greatest cities in the UK and its economic rebirth over the last 15 years in enriching the lives of many of its two million citizens.
"But many others are being left behind. On just about every measure of social breakdown Manchester scores far worse than the national average and other big cities," added Mr Duncan Smith.
What do you think? Have your say.
Tweet
'The two sides of Manchester'
November 08, 2007

Showing comments 1 to 25 and replies | View All
Emjay See (08/11/2007 at 08:27)
Whereas look what Labour has done for Manchester. They are bringing the Supercasino to East Manchetser creating 3,000 jobs and they are fully funding the big bang metro link, on time, with no quibbles. What?
No Supercasino?
Big bang behind schedule and no plans for funding the Stockport link?
Even so not quite in the Thatcher league of destruction. Trusting the Tories to fix it is like asking Jack the Ripper to do a stint in A&E.
Chris, Irlam (08/11/2007 at 09:05)
Labour have had a decade to make things better, if they have not managed it then that is their fault and their fault alone!
Emjay See (08/11/2007 at 09:26)
you don't think that creating large regions with high and long term unemployment together with an out for yourself attitude has had any long lasting effects then?
Like those people affected didn't go on to have children and pass on the same attitude of dependence and low aspiration.
I can and do blame the Tories for this, in much the same way I blame the Norman invaders of 1066 in part for the class divide as well as the north south divide. Some changes to Society are long lasting and many of Society's ills today sit squarely at the door of the Tories. Unfortunately the solutions will not be short term. Certainly not solvable in 10 years when there is so much other stuff to sort out that the Tories also saddled us with. I.e. chronic underinvestment in infrastructure and public services.
Still I take your point in part, Labour have been a big disappointment and haven't really made a huge improvement to the Social deprivation in this country. Indeed in some ways they have made it worse. Never forget where it began though, one word; Thatcher.
Chris, Irlam (08/11/2007 at 09:32)
And another thing, Thatcher does not run the Tories anymore than Kinnock runs the Labour party - times change.
This charming Manc (08/11/2007 at 09:34)
southern jessie, London (08/11/2007 at 09:35)
"society was not an abstraction, separate from the men and women who composed it, but a living structure of individuals, families, neighbours and voluntary associations."
Surely she was right. You cannot rely on the state for everything, or people just complain of the nanny state!
Emjay See (08/11/2007 at 09:40)
again true, I agree with what you say. However, have the Tories really changed? The proof in the pudding is in the eating, but last time round it was very hard to stomache.
I believe the Tories will say anything just to get power (just like Labour infact) and then do as they did last time. Look at John Redwood, do you think he's changed?
"Unemployment is a price well worth paying" How many Tories still secretly think like this? I for one don't want to find out.
Emjay See (08/11/2007 at 09:41)
Surfin' Bird, Tameside (08/11/2007 at 09:59)
chris (08/11/2007 at 10:06)
Colin Wilcox (08/11/2007 at 10:07)
Only three of Manchester's 23 non-selective state secondary schools achieve exam results above the national average
Manchester is near the bottom of the league table for truancy, scoring second worst out of 150 councils and fourth worst for school exclusions for bad behaviour
Only one school leaver in four goes to university
Two in five families with children are headed by a lone parent, compared with just over one in five across England
Greater Manchester has the highest number of ASBOs issued to children aged between 10 and 17 in the UK, almost 75% higher than for Greater London
In Greater Manchester there are seven gun-related incidents every day - the number of firearms deaths is only higher in London
One in 14 girls aged between 15 and 17 becomes pregnant in Manchester - almost double the rate across England
In 2004/5 Greater Manchester had the highest number of children under 15 (238) admitted to hospital for alcohol-related problems
In 2005/6 809 per 100,000 of Manchester's male population were admitted to hospital because of alcohol-specific conditions - more than double the national rate of 340 per 100,000
In 2006, 22% of Manchester's working-age population were out of work and on benefits, higher than the national rate of 14.6%
Emjay See (08/11/2007 at 10:12)
"we need to develop education and social awareness, make people hungry to learn and get involved in their surroundings, develop infrastructure and services that encourage businesses to setup and flourish"
Easily said, bloody, bloody hard to achieve. That will take far more than 10 years, shame Labour have wasted so much of it. I severley capable that the Tories would A) Try B) Succeed in doing what you have suggested.
Emjay See (08/11/2007 at 10:15)
Manchester is great despite these things. Inspite of this Manchetser has created a world class cultural scene and if you have money offers you opportunities that very few cities comparabkle in size can. Add to this the humour and attitude and you have a fantastic city. But hey if ain't good enough....Move!
Emjay See (08/11/2007 at 10:18)
I forgot. Lake District, Peak Distict and North Wales all in eeasy reach and an international airport if you feel the need to get away. Again money required.
John Hall (08/11/2007 at 10:21)
Whilst the Greater Manchester Councils are dominated by Labour,and just inspect the actual qualifications of the local Councillors to find answers,
Since James Anderton began his false claims to clean up Manchester,subsequent Chief Constables have proven non of them are fit for purpose.
The Councils are full of sleaze,and until the people in the suburbs put their grey matter into gear Manchester will continue to become a midden.
I bet most people could`nt even tell you there Councillors name,the big part time salaries plus extra`s and even more extra`s,and vote themselves big increases in pensions and salaries,so whilst the Councils,Developers,and Business Organisations cream of the Manchester wealth,you get what you ignore
Happyblue, Failsworth (08/11/2007 at 10:25)
ace, manchester (08/11/2007 at 10:26)
Colin Wilcox (08/11/2007 at 10:34)
I emigrated in 1998 after the writing on the wall became dry after Blair got in..... so what was your point gain?
edwards (08/11/2007 at 10:36)
Emjay See (08/11/2007 at 10:44)
I think I was saying Manchester isn't alll bad and in some ways is great, don't you miss it? Not ever? A pint of real ale in a city centre tavern, or the feeling you get walking around Albert Square/St Peters Square, going for a meal in China town etc etc Or are you living in paradise with no ills whatever and 2 great football teams like City and City reserves?
Happyblue, Failsworth (08/11/2007 at 11:16)
you mean three great teams
man city
mancity reserves and
man city youth
Ms D, Manchester (08/11/2007 at 11:33)
Mr Manchester (08/11/2007 at 11:36)
Gun crime has rocketed in Finland, Colin. In fact, I've been worried for your safety...
Colin Wilcox (08/11/2007 at 12:03)
seems the MEN censor has failed to post my previous response. Yes Manchester does have lots going for it.... however the apathy of the powers tha be are causing it to sink at an alaming rate... social disorder and generally becoming scummier every time i come back to visit friends.
ace, manchester (08/11/2007 at 12:03)
Im in full agreement with you but i think its time that manchester council was changed from the usual labour run councl and give another party a chance at running this council?We have lots of different parties to vote into power in manchester.