A COMEDY club owner believes he has discovered a loop-hole in the smoking ban, allowing customers to have the last laugh.
Since July 1 anyone smoking in an enclosed public place could face a £50 fine, while the management could be fined £2,500.
But Dave Perkin says customers may be able to carry on smoking at his Frog and Bucket club provided they are willing to get on stage and tell a joke. Mr Perkin says he has researched the legislation and discovered that smoking is permitted if it is an integral part of any performance.
He said: "We hold a famous `open mic' night on Mondays and as long as the audience come up on stage and tell a joke about smoking then they can light a cigarette while they are doing it.
"The laws stipulate that smoking has to be an intrinsic part of that performance to be allowed.
Performance
"The law uses the example of a play about Winston Churchill as an instance of when someone needs to be able to smoke as part of their performance.
"Originally, I was very much opposed to the legislation as I thought that it was an infringement of people's civil liberties but I can now see the wisdom in protecting employees from smoke."
The club, in Oldham Street, Manchester, is credited with launching the careers of Peter Kay and Johnny Vegas.
A Manchester council spokesman said the onus would be on Mr Perkin to prove smoking had taken place as part of the `fundamental artistic integrity' of any act.
He said: "The law also includes a limited exemption for performers where the artistic integrity of a show makes it appropriate for that performer to smoke. The exemption only applies during the performance. The onus would be on Mr Perkin to prove smoking was indeed fundamental to the artistic integrity of the performance."
Environmental health officers are to visit managers at The Ritz in Manchester city centre after Happy Mondays frontman Shaun Ryder chain smoked his way through the band's performance and a number of fans copied him.
Tweet
Jokers bid to beat smoking gag
July 11, 2007
SMOKESCREEN: Dave Perkin believes he has found a loop-hole in the new smoking law

Showing comments 1 to 10 and replies | View All
ace, manchester (11/07/2007 at 09:52)
Joey, Ashton under Lyne, (11/07/2007 at 10:12)
There is the 1974 Violence in the Workplace Act, where it is illegal to harass or bully an employee. By telling a smoker that they cannot smoke may be viewed as harassment.
ace, manchester (11/07/2007 at 10:27)
ace, manchester (11/07/2007 at 11:05)
Steve (11/07/2007 at 12:46)
You think telling someone to stop smoking in the workplace is harassment? Get real, it's against the law now for a start, so how can that be harassment. I guess if I take a 6 pack of stella in the office and they tell me to stop drinking, I can say it's against human rights?
People need to get a grip, this landlord needs to be told to follow the rules. And anyway, how many people are going to get up on stage, do a joke about smoking and then sit down? It'll be a really funny place to go then, won't it.
Joey, Ashton under Lyne, (11/07/2007 at 12:58)
Seriously, look at the meaning of the words used in legislation. I can asault you - just by saying "I will thump you", so harassment can be just telling someone to desist.
The Catcher, In the Rye (11/07/2007 at 13:05)
The old smoking ban has really brought out the hypocrits hasn't it.
Bystander, Manchester (11/07/2007 at 14:17)
tony (12/07/2007 at 10:25)
ace, manchester (12/07/2007 at 18:06)
Im asking if he can be charged with wasting councils time? he deserves to give 5grand to a cancer charity for all the free publicity and the trouble he has caused people(what do you think?) CHARITY FIVE GRAND FOR THE HASSTLE???PLEASE ANSWER DAVE