A MOTHER has hit out after her five-year-old son was made ill by being forced to go to a different school from his twin sister.
Nina Phoenix, 32, accepted a place for daughter Summer-Rose at Sacred Heart Catholic Primary School near their Baguley home.
But Summer-Rose's twin brother Lawrence couldn't get in because there was only ONE place available.
The twins suffer from chronic eczema and Mrs Phoenix says the trauma of the separation had caused Lawrence's illness to flare up.
She said she turned down places at alternative schools because she wanted her children to be educated in a Catholic setting. She said: "To split twins up is terrible. Lawrence won't be doing the same as his sister.
"He won't be going to mass or celebrating the feast days.
"His chronic eczema has flared up and he has started feeling resentful towards Summer-Rose.
"She has been pretending to be ill so she can come home from school to be with Lawrence."
Under current rules, siblings get priority on school waiting lists - but there is no special priority given to twins.
Mrs Phoenix's appeals to school governors and the independent schools admissions panel were both refused.
Sacred Heart head teacher Aelred Whelan said his hands were tied. He said: "We would like to take Lawrence, but I am bound to class size legislation.
"As it stands, he is at the top of the waiting list because of the sibling rule, though that may change if anybody moves into the area. It makes no difference that he is a twin."
Council education spokesman John Edwards said: "While we sympathise with this family's situation, it is important that all school admissions are dealt with in line with published admissions policies and practices.
"Sacred Heart School had only one place in reception when the family moved into the area in May. The mother chose to accept the place for one of her twins and a place on the school's waiting list for the other."
Senior dermatology nurse Julie Carr, who treats the twins at Sheffield Children's Hospital, said they should stay together for their well-being and medical treatment, which includes cream treatments six times a day and steroids twice a day.
Ms Carr said: "I feel this separation is a detrimental move and could have an impact on their health.
"Stress appears to affect Lawrence's eczema and it can deteriorate rapidly to the point of hospital treatment."
Lawrence is due to start at Baguley Hall Primary School on Monday, after staff completed training to deal with his life-threatening anaphylactic fits.
Mrs Phoenix said: "Lawrence and Summer-Rose suffer from rare allergies. They are at risk going to different schools. But we are also practising Catholics - and that's crucial for their education."
Tweet
Twins sent to different schools
October 04, 2008
Summer-Rose Phoenix and twin brother Lawrence with mum Nina

Showing comments 1 to 13 and replies | View All
garfield (04/10/2008 at 14:41)
and would sharing the story with local newpaper get you anywhere??? im watching this space.
dave pickup (04/10/2008 at 14:55)
Pippa, Manchester (04/10/2008 at 15:32)
mrs curry and diet coke, north m/cr (04/10/2008 at 17:29)
neil sk6 (04/10/2008 at 18:31)
I do hope the children get better soon.
Doobydoo, Worsley (05/10/2008 at 08:44)
In these circumstances maybe the school should have offered the 1 place to another person so that neither of the twins had got a place and then she would have had nothing to complain about. The kids being seperated has upset them and made their condition worse (I also have a child who suffers with severe Eczema so know what she and her children go through).
mspig, Manchester (05/10/2008 at 20:02)
To the person who suggested that they both go to baguley primary obviously doesn't come from the area or had a child at that school - i would rather home tutor.
shelly smith (06/10/2008 at 11:43)
Why not place them in Baguley Hall School. They can still celebrate feast days in Church and go to Mass on a Sunday. They cold make their Holy Communion etc. If they are so ill, why can't they be home tutored?
I am sorry, but if they cannot bear to be separated, then surely their health is more important than their education. The boy has been begging to go to school for months but the mother won't let him go to the other school as she is determined to dig her heels in and be awkward.
Jomov (06/10/2008 at 13:07)
Not all twins do have that close bond actually, I know some that do not anyway.
I also find your comment quite snobbish - maybe that is the problem here.
Melandra (06/10/2008 at 16:00)
angry parent (07/10/2008 at 06:46)
She knowingly accepted a place for one child causing seperation! This was thoughtless and selfish. did she believe that when she got her foot in the door everyone would just ignore the GOVERMENTS rules?
I'm sure there are many parents who would love their children to go to this school but if they are full then there is nothing they can do!
She should now start to put her children first!
Does mrs Phoenix even attend mass every week?
richard jones (07/10/2008 at 10:06)
For her to split the twins up is utterly selfish on her part. The schools hands are tied but she is determined to try and cause trouble.
How dare she move into the area a few months ago and demand rights. Its disgusting.
Mrs Phoenix should stop complaining and get them both into another Catholic School - however, after reading these comments - would they actually want to have a troublemaker in their school? I think not.
ProudMum of4 (12/11/2008 at 22:45)
I have children at Baguley Hall and I think its a fantastic school, they are getting a much better education than they were getting in Surrey 3 years ago! I also have young twins and they will both be attending Baguley Hall also, I can not give the school enough praise.