A patient ready to be discharged from hospital had to wait NINE years before finally being able to leave.
The man, with complex care needs, was admitted after suffering a stroke and needed to move to a nursing home.
The shocking length of time he spent waiting in hospital was revealed after the M.E.N asked all hospital trusts in Greater Manchester how many bed days were lost due to delayed discharges over the last two years.
The man left waiting for nearly a decade was admitted to Fairfield Hospital in Bury in July 1999. He was finally discharged and moved to a home in 2008. He died a few weeks later.
It is understood staff from the hospital and local authority had tried to help his family find him alternative accommodation.
The figures obtained by the M.E.N also show at least three other people from the region also spent more than a year in hospital unnecessarily.
A total of 110,179 bed days between April 2007 and March 2009 were lost - costing taxpayers thousands.
The problem continues seven years after the government brought in a fees system - allowing hospitals to charge social services £100 for each day they lost to bed blocking - to tackle the issue. But only three trusts in the region claimed cash back.
Paul Mainwaring, chairman of the Manchester-based Patients' Council, said: "The evidence gathered by the M.E.N. clearly shows that the discharge practices for people with complex and long-term conditions are still in need of improvement.
"Leaving patients in hospital for these lengths of times is clearly not beneficial.
“This is also not what our highly-trained nurses and doctors are there for, let alone the costs of keeping people in hospital.
“It has long been a concern of the Patients' Council that too many patients are admitted to easily, or kept in hospital too long.
"In an era where our government is fixated on targets, it would seem that budgets are more important that the person's welfare, so we are sure if people had to pick up the cost of blocked beds, they will become unblocked very quickly."
Many trusts do not use the fines system but Wigan, Wrightington and Leigh used it to recoup £3,400, East Lancashire used it to generate £13,000 between 2007 and 2009 and Pennine Acute recouped £19,700 between 2008 and 2009.
A spokesman for Fairfield Hospital said they have now brought in a new discharge procedure which means no patient should wait more than three weeks before being discharged.
He said: "We are committed to reducing the number of patients who are delayed in hospital, even though they are medically fit to be discharged.
"We work with local primary care trusts and social care services to prevent patients being delayed within the discharge planning process.
"We have recently published a new single discharge policy which has been produced in collaboration with our local authorities and primary care trusts.
"The policy is a more streamlined process for discharging patients from all our hospitals, and an easier process for families, carers and the staff involved."
Greater Manchester West Mental Health Trust had 351 cases of bed blocking in the last two years. Central Manchester Hospitals could have claimed 812 bed days during 2007/08, and 830 during 2008/09 but they have a policy not to claim the cash.
A spokesmen for Central Manchester Hospitals and Stockport Hospitals said they did not record how long individuals were delayed at their trusts.
Manchester Mental Health trust could not provide figures for how many bed days they lost due to delayed discharge.
Among the other delayed discharges are a patient being cared for by the East Cheshire NHS Trust who spent an extra two years four months on a ward and a patient of the East Lancashire Hospitals NHS Trust who spent an extra 220 days in hospital.
Salford Royal kept a patient for an extra 155 days and Manchester Mental Health and Social Care Trust kept one for a year and nine months.

Showing 1 to 16 of 16 comments | View All
North Bury, Bury (15/03/2010 at 09:38)
So nobody was to blame for this poor beggar being kept unnecessarily in hospital for NINE YEARS?
d1v1s1onby0, Wigan (15/03/2010 at 10:01)
James Yates, Hyde, Cheshire (15/03/2010 at 10:08)
MPs gravy train, UK (15/03/2010 at 10:43)
Careless Whisper (15/03/2010 at 10:47)
Northen Bird :), Eccles (15/03/2010 at 11:27)
RT, UK (15/03/2010 at 11:32)
Once there were Wards and Wings of Hospitals that dealt with these matters. These have all been stripped away, no doubt on cost leaving people to their own devices.
The most interesting part of this is the government applying charges and Hospitals taking no notice. Not that the government is right, fining bed blocking is not going to solve anything. It just puts more pressure on a system that is not there.
That is the proper geriatric care of patients (Not addressed by this Government).
minority report, Derby, UK (15/03/2010 at 11:54)
What does irk me is, despite sell-offs, contracting out, PFIs, PPPs and other forms of privatisation - not to mention complete surrender to banks, big business and corporations - some people still regard New Labour as Socialist or even (lol) Marxist.
d1v1s1onby0, Wigan (15/03/2010 at 12:00)
I refer to them as "Tory By Stealth"
Bertie McGrew , Northern Countryside (15/03/2010 at 12:40)
The NHS is the problem but the Thatcher solution wasnt the answer. The people who worked in the NHS in 1986 were jobsworths, knowing that no matter how bad they were, they would never be sacked - and believe me some were pretty awful. Technology was so out of date that it took 16 people in Salford's Accounts section to do the work of 5 or 6.
There was precious little interdepartmental co-operation then, there is F-All now!
My wife has worked as an NHS nurse from 1974 until 2 years ago, on low pay and horribly unsocial hours dealing with some low life scum that are taking the funds that deserving cases dont get.
She now works as a self employed agency nurse, hours to suit and the pay is wonderful. Because the NHS cannot organise their own staff - what an inditement of the service.
And before I moan about the Thatcher legacy - we have had a Labour government for over 15 years and they have done even worse than the Tories.
Privatisation cost this country dearly, in terms of services from untilities, the NHS, the Police (yes a lot of sub contract work goes on in a Police Station cos its cheaper than having trained Bobbies do the paperwork) and most especially the transport networks.
We are going to have a general election this year - we need a party whose policies will reverse this trend and restore the services that our taxation/ NI is paying for.
Nothing I have heard so far suggests we will get one.
minority report, Derby, UK (15/03/2010 at 13:25)
minority report, Derby, UK (15/03/2010 at 15:06)
The welfare state is a great idea for ensuring universal health care, a basic income level for the unemployed and protecting the most vulnerable. The problem with any compassion-based system is that it is a target for unscrupulous, selfish people - they view compassion as weakness. Attempts to block them by tighter admission rules, more rigorous testing and harsher penalties for misuse cause bonafide clients to be regarded as potential criminals.
Another problem with public sector work has been the undervaluing of jobs but with high job security. As you described, this produced low morale and the “jobs worth” mentality. Socialism can only work if people have altruistic motives. Any greed or selfishness will undermine it or require government enforcement which will also undermine it. The tyranny and corruption in the Soviet system illustrates this,
The notion of efficient Capitalism is equally flawed. Your reference to the “utilities” is a prime example. Thatcher’s monetarist guru, Milton Friedman, liked to compare Capitalism to a street market where a stallholder giving better value would survive while his competitors would go bust. In the real world smaller competing companies are swallowed up into corporations - as with our privatised gas, electricity and water companies. These conglomerates monopolise the utility supplies and control prices. Customers have no power, and neither governments nor quangos (like Ofgem) can influence them. Corporations are more powerful than governments and they control the world more every day. The corruption and greed in the American system illustrates this.
I think we have a government that is tied to the corporate Capitalist system but likes the Soviet methods of enforcing its control on the people.
Sarah (15/03/2010 at 17:57)
Surely there must have been some dispute. Having worked in a hospital discharge team it would be unheard of for someone to wait 9 years more like 9 weeks.
I think the MEN should look at the lack of funding for adult care if they want to blame someone for delayed discharges. Or spend some time in hospital and see how 'easy' it is to arrange a discharge.
mike356 (16/03/2010 at 00:23)
boltongirl (16/03/2010 at 07:07)
Donald, manchester (16/03/2010 at 13:45)